Constitutional Transplants, Borrowing, and Migrations

  title={Constitutional Transplants, Borrowing, and Migrations},
  author={Vlad F. Perju},
  journal={Jurisprudence \& Legal Philosophy eJournal},
  • Vlad F. Perju
  • Published 2012
  • Political Science
  • Jurisprudence & Legal Philosophy eJournal
This paper, which will be published in the Oxford Handbook on Comparative Constitutional Law (M. Rosenfeld & A. Sajo, eds., forthcoming 2012), explores the borrowing and migration of constitutional ideas and institutions across jurisdictions. Despite the fact that comparative constitutional law is a form of comparative law, comparative constitutionalism has thus far largely ignored the rich debates in comparative law on the topic of legal transplants. I argue that those debates can illuminate… Expand
From Foreign Text to Local Meaning: The Politics of Religious Exclusion in Transnational Constitutional Borrowing
Abstract Constitutional drafters often look to foreign constitutional models, ideas, and texts for inspiration; many are explicit about their foreign borrowing. However, when implementedExpand
The competing effect of national uniqueness and comparative influences on constitutional practice
This chapter focuses on theoretical, historical and recent trends in constitutional drafting with a particular focus on how local context and characteristics that are unique to particular countriesExpand
Constitutional cases, foreign law and theoretical authority
  • O. Doyle
  • Political Science
  • Global Constitutionalism
  • 2016
Abstract: The judicial use of foreign law in constitutional cases is often unsatisfactorily explained in terms of persuasive authority, judicial learning or judicial dialogue. In this article, IExpand
Constitutional Reasoning as Legitimacy of Constitutional Comparison
For ten years, the legitimacy of constitutional comparison in courts has been intensely debated. The case law of the U.S. Supreme Court led to an intense discussion on constitutional comparison andExpand
Constitution without Constitutionalism? Challenges to constitutionalism in the Kyrgyz Republic
Application of basic principles revolving around the constitutionalism into third wave democracies, produced such phenomenon as constitutions “without constitutionalism”. This paper will revisit andExpand
Unconstitutional constitutional amendments: a study of the nature and limits of constitutional amendment powers
This research project stems from a single puzzle: how can constitutional amendments be unconstitutional? Adopting a combination of theoretical and comparative enquiries, this thesis establishes theExpand
The Doctrine of Reception of Law and Its Significance in Legal Development of Bangladesh
Legal transplantation is the process of how laws and legal institutions actually develop and progress in a given country. The past few decades have shown an upward trend in the volume of legalExpand
Area Studies and the Decolonisation of Comparative Law: Insights from Alternative Southeast Asian Constitutional Modernities
Like “philosophy”, constitutional law is a disguised form of area studies that should more adequately be called “Western” or “Euroamerican” constitutional law. In this field, as in many others, theExpand
Constitutional Migration and the Meaning of Religious Freedom: From Ireland and India to the Islamic Republic of Pakistan
Building on current research regarding constitutional migration, this article shows how constitutional provisions protecting religious freedom (“subject to public order”) arrived in the IslamicExpand
Why Constitutional Meaning is not Necessarily Fixed - A Reply to Solum
Abstract : In this paper, I show that certain parts of constitutional texts can plausibly be thought of as having a meaning that changes and evolves on its own. This idea is widely rejected,Expand


Paradoxes of constitutional borrowing
This essay presents some observations about the transplanting of constitutionalism. It looks at the general idea of constitutionalism and specific institutions and provisions included inExpand
Constitutional borrowing and nonborrowing
Constitutional borrowing comes in different forms. Judges may consider decisions reached by their counterparts in other societies when resolving disputes; constitutional framers may look abroad whenExpand
Constitutional transfer: The IKEA theory revisited
Text books and articles on comparative constitutional law, regardless of their focus or methodological orientation, suggest that constitutions all over the world, at least most of them, come in theExpand
Constitutional Transplants and the Mutation Effect
This paper is concerned with legal transplantation, that is, the borrowing of legal institutions from foreign jurisdictions. Constitutional trans-plants are a species of legal transplants. ByExpand
Globalization in Search of Justification: Toward a Theory of Comparative Constitutional Interpretation
The use of comparative constitutional materials in constitutional interpretation – comparative constitutional interpretation – has emerged as a central component of contemporary constitutionalExpand
The Limits of Constitutional Convergence
Globalization, some legal scholars suggest, is a force that makes increasing convergence among different countries’ constitutions more or less inevitable. This Essay explores this hypothesis byExpand
Returning with Interest: Observations on Some Putative Benefits of Studying Comparative Constitutional Law
Borrowing has rightfully been called "one of the grand old topics of comparative law." In the United States, however, there is far more interest in exporting or lending than there is in borrowing.Expand
Against borrowings and other nonauthoritative uses of foreign law
In this article I reflect both on borrowings and on other uses of foreign law. Section 2 describes the relevance of foreign law, especially U.S. law, to the constitutional development of Argentina.Expand
The Politics and Incentives of Legal Transplantation
The last ten years have seen an exponential increase in the volume of legal transplantation, the process by which laws and legal institutions developed in one country are then adopted by another.Expand
Constitutional borrowing: The influence of legal culture and local history in the reconstitution of comparative influence: The South African experience
Far too often one sees citation by counsel of, for instance, an American judgment in support of a proposition relating to our Constitution, without any attempt to explain why it is said to be inExpand