Confirmation Bias as a Social Skill

@article{Dardenne1995ConfirmationBA,
  title={Confirmation Bias as a Social Skill},
  author={Beno{\^i}t Dardenne and J P Leyens},
  journal={Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin},
  year={1995},
  volume={21},
  pages={1229 - 1239}
}
The authors propose that when testing a hypothesis about a personality trait of another person, a preference for questions that match the hypothesis is a manifestation of a social skill. If so, socially skilled people should request matching questions when the context stresses their relevance. On the contrary, less skilled people should be relatively insensitive to this environmental cue. To test this pragmatic stance, participants varying in self-monitoring sought information to validate an… 
Confirming expectations in asymmetric and symmetric social hypothesis testing.
TLDR
Individuals' expectations in a social hypothesis testing task that investigates the presence of personality traits in a target individual are examined, finding that when people asked questions inquiring about the hypothesized traits that did not entail strong a priori beliefs, they expected to find evidence confirming the hypothesis under investigation.
Confirmation as coping with competition
ABSTRACT Confirmation is a widespread tendency to seek, use, interpret or remember information in such a way as to corroborate one’s hypothesis. We review various conceptions of confirmation and
Search and evaluation strategies in belief revision: psychological mechanisms and normative deviations
The procedures people adopt in order to seek out and use information have been the focus of empirical research since long in psychology, especially so from the late 50s. This dissertation addresses
The effect of metacognitive self on confirmation bias revealed in relation to community and competence
The main goal of our study was to investigate the role of insight into one’s own biases (metacognitive self) in the process of hypothesis validation in accordance to the two fundamental social
Testing Hypotheses About Social Targets: The Effects of Instructions on Asymmetric Strategies
TLDR
Results showed that, although people spontaneously use asymmetric yes-no format questions during the information search on moral traits, in certain conditions the use of such strategies could be monitored.
What Is the Function of Confirmation Bias?
  • U. Peters
  • Philosophy, Psychology
    Erkenntnis
  • 2020
Confirmation bias is one of the most widely discussed epistemically problematic cognitions, challenging reliable belief formation and the correction of inaccurate views. Given its problematic nature,
Social value orientation and impression formation: a test of two competing hypotheses about information search in negotiation
Two experiments investigated negotiators' information search strategies as a function of other's personality (cooperative vs. competitive vs. unknown) and own social value orientation (pro‐social vs.
Suppression and hypothesis testing: does suppressing stereotypes during interactions help to avoid confirmation biases?
Recent work indicates that trying not to think in stereotypical terms increases the accessibility of stereotypical information, which paradoxically results in more stereotypical judgments. The
Better Think Before Agreeing Twice. Mere Agreement: A Similarity-Based Persuasion Mechanism
The present paper shows that people’s compliance with a request can be substantially increased if the requester first gets them to agree with a series of statements unrelated to the request, but
Confirmation and Disconfirmation: Their Social Advantages
In this chapter, we review theory and research on strategies of hypothesis testing. We propose that confirmation is the default option in information processing; however, and contrary to common
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 45 REFERENCES
People's Strategies for Testing Hypotheses about Another's Personality: Confirmatory or Diagnostic?
The present paper reports two studies on information-gathering strategies that people use in testing hypotheses about another's personality. Subjects chose interview questions while planning to test
A hypothesis-confirming bias in labeling effects.
The present study examines the process leading to the confirmation of a perceiver's expectancies about another when the social label that created the expectancy provides poor or tentative evidence
DIAGNOSTIC AND CONFIRMATION STRATEGIES IN TRAIT HYPOTHESIS TESTING
The role of diagnostic and confirmation strategies in trait hypothesis testing is examined. The present studies integrate theoretical and empirical work on qualitative differences among traits with
Social cognition and social perception.
TLDR
Higgins et al (1982) and Bargh and Thein (1985) have demonstrated that when people form an impression of a target person, they are more sensitive to information that is relevant to their chronically accessible constructs than that which isrelevant to other available constructs.
Errors and mistakes: evaluating the accuracy of social judgment.
  • D. Funder
  • Psychology
    Psychological bulletin
  • 1987
TLDR
Although errors can be highly informative about the process of judgment in general, they are not necessarily relevant to the content or accuracy of particular judgments, because errors in a laboratory may not be mistakes with respect to a broader, more realistic frame of reference and the processes that produce such errors might lead to correct decisions and adaptive outcomes in real life.
Motivational Influences on Impression Formation: Outcome Dependency, Accuracy-Driven Attention, and Individuating Processes
How might being outcome dependent on another person influence the processes that one uses to form impressions of that person? We designed three experiments to investigate this question with respect
Another Look At Confirmatory Strategies During a Real Interview
In two experiments, it is shown that interviewers bias to a larger extent their questions towards their hypothesis when they interact with an interviewee than when they only prepare questions for a
Beyond selecting information: Biases in spontaneous questions and resultant conclusions.
Abstract Biases in trait hypothesis testing were examined from both subjects′ and observers′ viewpoints. Subjects formulated two questions to test each of three hypotheses and drew inference from
...
...