Computing as a Science: A Survey of Competing Viewpoints

@article{Tedre2011ComputingAA,
  title={Computing as a Science: A Survey of Competing Viewpoints},
  author={M. Tedre},
  journal={Minds and Machines},
  year={2011},
  volume={21},
  pages={361-387}
}
  • M. Tedre
  • Published 2011
  • Psychology, Computer Science
  • Minds and Machines
Since the birth of computing as an academic discipline, the disciplinary identity of computing has been debated fiercely. [...] Key Result The article argues that much of the discussion about the scientific nature of computing is misguided due to a deep conceptual uncertainty about science in general as well as computing in particular.Expand
Computing and Experiments
The question about the scientific nature of computing has been widely debated with no universal consensus reached about its disciplinary status. Positions vary from acknowledging computing as theExpand
Computing as Empirical Science – Evolution of a Concept
TLDR
The evolution of philosophical and methodological considerations concerning empiricism in computer/computing science is presented and the most important current events in the history of reflection on computing are traced. Expand
Three Debates about Computing
TLDR
Three debates that are central in understanding how computing as a discipline developed to what it is now are presented: the formal verification debate, the software engineering debate, and the experimental computer science debate. Expand
Stretching the Traditional Notion of Experiment in Computing: Explorative Experiments
TLDR
This work shows how the traditional notion of controlled experiment should be revised to take into account a part of the experimental practice in computing along the lines of experimentation as exploration, and recast explorative experiments as socio- technical experiments, that test new technologies in their socio-technical contexts. Expand
Philosophy of Engineering and the Quest for a Novel Notion of Experimentation
Epistemological issues in engineering knowledge have traditionally played a central role in the debate over the assessment of the philosophy of engineering as a disciplinary field. However, only fewExpand
An easy approach to epistemology and ontology in computing theses
TLDR
This paper introduces a simplified approach to standard research terminology for computing and engineering students by offering a rough-and-ready way for resolving ontological and epistemological questions. Expand
Current perspectives on the development of the philosophy of informatics (with a special regard to some Polish philosophers)
This article is an overview of the philosophy of informatics with a special regard to some Polish philosophers. It juxtaposes the informationistic worldview with the long-prevailing mechanicalExpand
Research Commentary - The Disciplines of Information: Lessons from the History of the Discipline of Medicine
  • D. Schwartz
  • Sociology, Computer Science
  • Inf. Syst. Res.
  • 2014
TLDR
This research commentary shows that the Discipline of information systems IS has much that can be learned from the history of the discipline of medicine, and identifies the primary factors and structural changes which preceded a modern medical discipline characterized by unification and specialization. Expand
The role and relevance of experimentation in informatics
TLDR
The report argues for the key role of empirical research and experimentation in contemporary Informatics and recommends that professionals and students alike are well-educated in the principles of sound experimentation in InformatICS. Expand
Computers in Abstraction/Representation Theory
TLDR
A modification of Abstraction/Representation theory is proposed, which is called Agential AR theory, that does not clearly satisfy some of the desiderata for accounts of concrete computation, yielding an account that could be a serious competitor to other leading account ofcrete computation. Expand
...
1
2
3
4
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 157 REFERENCES
Science and computer science
TLDR
Computer science is, or has the potential to be, a science similar in character to physics and the other natural sciences, however, its traditions, in the areas of experimentation and formulation of theories, may delay its acceptance and inhibit its development as a science. Expand
Shifting the Paradigm of Philosophy of Science: Philosophy of Information and a New Renaissance
TLDR
This paper investigates contemporary trends and the relation between the Philosophy of Science and the philosophy of Computing and Information, which is equivalent to the present relation between Philosophy of science and Philosophy of Physics. Expand
Computing as Engineering
  • M. Tedre
  • Computer Science
  • J. Univers. Comput. Sci.
  • 2009
TLDR
The article depicts the engineering aims manifest in the academic field of computing, compares the engineering tradition with the other traditions of computing as a disci- pline, and presents some epistemological, ontological, and methodological views about the intellectual foundations and contributions of the Engineering tradition in computing. Expand
The development of computer science: a sociocultural perspective
  • M. Tedre
  • Sociology, Computer Science
  • Baltic Sea '06
  • 2006
TLDR
It is argued that understanding of how computer science works is an important part of the knowledge of an educated computer scientist. Expand
The academic image of computer science
TLDR
Students who graduate with degrees in computer science have thus achieved a broad scientific training in thei r career discipline as well as a n acceptable level of professiona l expertise. Expand
Criticism and the Growth of Knowledge: The Nature of a Paradigm
1. The initial difficulty: Kuhn's multiple definitions of a paradigm . 2. The originality of Kuhn's sociological notion of a paradigm: the paradigm is something which can function when the theory isExpand
On the origin of objects
  • B. C. Smith
  • Psychology, Computer Science
  • Trends in Cognitive Sciences
  • 1997
TLDR
On the Origin of Objects is Brian Cantwell Smith's decade-long investigation into the philosophical and metaphysical foundations of computation, artificial intelligence, and cognitive science, and presents an argument for an embedded, participatory, "irreductionist," metaphysical alternative. Expand
Should Computer Scientists Experiment More? Computer Scientists and Practitioners Defend Their Lack of Experimentation with a Wide Range of Arguments. Some Arguments Suggest That
o computer scientists need to experiment at all? Only if we answer “yes” does it make sense to ask whether there is enough of it. In his Allen Newell Award lecture, Fred Brooks suggests that computerExpand
Letter from a past president: Distinction of computer science
TLDR
The panel discussed and recommended to the OCA that they sponsor a definitive study on Computer Science and Engineering, and recommended a recognition of the need for the identity of computer science as a separate discipline as recommended in the formal resolution. Expand
Three traditions of computing: what educators should know
TLDR
In this article the three traditions of computing are presented and some of their underlying assumptions, principles, application areas, restrictions, and weaknesses are portrayed. Expand
...
1
2
3
4
5
...