Computational opposition analysis using word embeddings: A method for strategising resonant informal argument

  title={Computational opposition analysis using word embeddings: A method for strategising resonant informal argument},
  author={Cameron Shackell and Laurianne Sitbon},
  journal={Argument Comput.},
In informal argument, an essential step is to ask what will “resonate” with a particular audience and hence persuade. Marketers, for example, may recommend a certain colour for a new soda can because it “pops” on Instagram; politicians may “fine-tune” diction for different social demographics. This paper engages the need to strategise for such resonance by offering a method for automating opposition analysis (OA), a technique from semiotics used in marketing and literary analysis to plot… 

Figures and Tables from this paper


Opposition theory and computational semiotics
Opposition theory suggests that binary oppositions (e.g., high vs. low) underlie basic cognitive and linguistic processes. However, opposition theory has never been implemented in a computational
Towards a framework for computational persuasion with applications in behaviour change
Computational persuasion is the study of formal models of dialogues involving arguments and counterarguments, of user models, and strategies, for APSs for behaviour change.
How Computational Tools Can Help Rhetoric and Informal Logic with Argument Invention
This paper compares the features and methods of the two leading implemented systems that offer a tool for helping a user to find or invent arguments to support or attack a designated conclusion, the
Comfort or safety? Gathering and using the concerns of a participant for better persuasion
This paper investigates how to acquire and represent concerns of a participant, and her preferences over them, and shows how this can be used for selecting good moves in a persuasion dialogue.
Less Ado, More Done: Verbal and Visual Antithesis in the Media.
The inventive, argumentative and stylistic possibilities generated by figures in general and the figure antithesis in particular are explored by Jeanne Fahnestock in the field of science. These ideas
Strategical Argumentative Agent for Human Persuasion
This work presents a novel methodology for persuading people through argumentative dialogs that combines theoretical argumentation modeling, machine learning and Markovian optimization techniques that together result in an innovative agent named SPA.
Software Framework for Topic Modelling with Large Corpora
This work describes a Natural Language Processing software framework which is based on the idea of document streaming, i.e. processing corpora document after document, in a memory independent fashion, and implements several popular algorithms for topical inference, including Latent Semantic Analysis and Latent Dirichlet Allocation in a way that makes them completely independent of the training corpus size.
Handbook of Brand Semiotics
Semiotics has been making progressively inroads into marketing research over the past thirty years. Despite the amply demonstrated conceptual appeal and empirical pertinence of semiotic perspectives
Distributed Representations of Words and Phrases and their Compositionality
This paper presents a simple method for finding phrases in text, and shows that learning good vector representations for millions of phrases is possible and describes a simple alternative to the hierarchical softmax called negative sampling.
The Quest for Meaning
Semiotics is the study of the most critical feature of human consciousness - the capacity for creating and using signs such as words and symbols for thinking, communicating, reflecting, transmitting,