Comprehensive Longitudinal Study Challenges the Existence of Neonatal Imitation in Humans

@article{Oostenbroek2016ComprehensiveLS,
  title={Comprehensive Longitudinal Study Challenges the Existence of Neonatal Imitation in Humans},
  author={Janine Oostenbroek and Thomas Suddendorf and Mark Nielsen and Jonathan Redshaw and Siobhan Kennedy-Costantini and Jacqueline Davis and Sally Clark and Virginia P. Slaughter},
  journal={Current Biology},
  year={2016},
  volume={26},
  pages={1334-1338}
}

Figures and Tables from this paper

Individual differences in neonatal 'imitation' fail to predict early social cognitive behaviour.

TLDR
Results show that, even using the liberal operationalisation, individual scores for neonatal 'imitation' of tongue protrusion failed to predict any of the later-developing social cognitive behaviours, running counter to Meltzoff et al.'s rebuttal, and to the existence of a "like me" mechanism that is foundational to human social cognition.

Developmental trend towards exact imitation in the second year of life

TLDR
The present analysis of longitudinal deferred imitation data contrasted toddlers’ imitation of functional and relevant (FURE) versus arbitrary and irrelevant (ARIR) target action steps at the ages of 18 and 24 months and showed that the difference between the imitation rates decreased with age, supporting the developmental trend from selective towards more exact imitation.

Neonatal imitation: Temporal characteristics in imitative response patterns.

  • M. HeimannT. Tjus
  • Psychology, Medicine
    Infancy : the official journal of the International Society on Infant Studies
  • 2019
TLDR
The study provides renewed support for neonatal imitation of MO and TP, and suggests that the temporal organization of the responses observed is an important factor to consider, which in turn has methodological and theoretical implications.

Neonatal imitation in context: Sensorimotor development in the perinatal period

TLDR
A case study of a paradigmatic orofacial “gesture,” namely tongue protrusion and retraction (TP/R), and suggests a sequence of three developmental events in which TP/R might participate: the acquisition of tongue control, the integration of the central pattern generator (CPG) for TP/ R with other aerodigestive CPGs, and the formation of connections within the cortical maps of S1 and M1.

Neonatal Imitation: Theory, Experimental Design, and Significance for the Field of Social Cognition

TLDR
The operational definition of differential imitation is presented and why it is important to keep it in mind and the significance of neonatal imitation for the field of social cognition is discussed, including links with theories of social interaction and direct social perception.

Does Neonatal Imitation Exist? Insights From a Meta-Analysis of 336 Effect Sizes

TLDR
A multilevel meta-analysis synthesizing 336 effect sizes from 33 independent samples of human newborns found significant evidence for neonatal imitation but substantial heterogeneity between study estimates.

Do Newborns Have the Ability to Imitate?

Neonatal imitation predicts infant rhesus macaque (Macaca mulatta) social and anxiety-related behaviours at one year

TLDR
The results show that neonatal imitators exhibit more dominant behaviours, are less anxious, and, for males only, spend more time in play at one year old.

Re-examination of Oostenbroek et al. (2016): evidence for neonatal imitation of tongue protrusion.

TLDR
11 flaws are identified in Oostenbroek et al.'s experimental design that biased the results toward null effects that raise fundamental issues about action representation, social learning, and brain-behavior relations.

Running Head : AUTOMATIC IMITATION IN CHILDREN

TLDR
A role for sensorimotor experience in the development of imitative ability is suggested, as actions thought to be performed in synchrony produced stronger automatic imitation effects when compared to actions where previous sensorim motor experience is likely to be more limited.
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 51 REFERENCES

The mirror neuron system as revealed through neonatal imitation: presence from birth, predictive power and evidence of plasticity

TLDR
Evidence that neonatal imitation is influenced by experience in the first week of life is presented and it is proposed that such variation in Neonatal imitation could reflect important individual differences of the MNS.

Is newborn imitation developmentally homologous to later social-cognitive skills?

TLDR
It is outlined how large-scale longitudinal approaches promise to resolve debates and have the potential to use individual difference measures to uncover links to later development.

The development of imitation in infancy

  • Susan S. Jones
  • Psychology, Biology
    Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences
  • 2009
TLDR
An overview of existing data on imitation in infancy suggests that changes in the direction of imitation research are underway and that infants do not imitate others until their second year, and that imitation of different kinds of behaviour emerges at different ages.

The mirror neuron system: grasping others' actions from birth?

TLDR
Evidence suggesting the presence of an MNS in the human child, as well as work that suggests the existence of a mechanism matching the perception and the execution of actions in thehuman newborn are reviewed.

Neonatal Imitation in Rhesus Macaques

TLDR
The findings provide a quantitative description of neonatal imitation in a nonhuman primate species and suggest that these imitative capacities are not unique to the ape and human lineage and their evolutionary origins may be traced to affiliative gestures with communicative functions.

Homo imitans? Seven reasons why imitation couldn't possibly be associative

  • C. Heyes
  • Psychology, Biology
    Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences
  • 2016
TLDR
The empirical success of the ASL model indicates that the mechanisms which make imitation possible, by aligning representations of self with representations of others, have been tweaked by cultural evolution, not built from scratch by genetic evolution.

Exploring the presence of imitation during early infancy.

TLDR
Given the restricted evidence for imitation, and the fact that neither linear nor curvilinear growth trends were apparent, the most appropriate explanation for the reproduction of tongue protrusions at the youngest age is to be sought in terms of a reflexive or fixed action pattern type of response.

What imitation tells us about social cognition: a rapprochement between developmental psychology and cognitive neuroscience.

  • A. MeltzoffJ. Decety
  • Psychology, Biology
    Philosophical transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological sciences
  • 2003
TLDR
The mechanisms involved in infant imitation provide the foundation for understanding that others are 'like me' and underlie the development of theory of mind and empathy for others, and functional neuroimaging studies that explore the neurophysiological substrate of imitation in adults are analyzed.
...