Compliance with a Request in Two Cultures: The Differential Influence of Social Proof and Commitment/Consistency on Collectivists and Individualists

  title={Compliance with a Request in Two Cultures: The Differential Influence of Social Proof and Commitment/Consistency on Collectivists and Individualists},
  author={Robert B. Cialdini and Wilhelmina Wosińska and Daniel W Barrett and Jonathan E. Butner and Małgorzata E. G{\'o}rnik-Durose},
  journal={Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin},
  pages={1242 - 1253}
University students in Poland and the United States, two countries that differ in individualistic-collectivistic orientation, indicated their willingness to comply with a request to participate without pay in a marketing survey. Half were asked to do so after considering information regarding their own history of compliance with such requests, whereas the other half were asked to do so after considering information regarding their peers’ history of such compliance. This was designed to assess… 

Figures from this paper

Individual differences in the motivation to comply across cultures: The impact of social obligation.
Abstract This study investigated the hypothesis that similar behavior in different cultures may mask individual differences in the reasons for that behavior. Most previous research on culture and
Consistency-based compliance across cultures☆
A field study investigated cross-cultural differences in choice-congruent behavior and its impact on compliance. U.S. and Asian participants received a request to complete an online survey and a
Compliance behavior and the role of ethnic background, source expertise, self-construals and values
The purpose of this study was to examine whether source expertise and type of compliance-gaining strategy influence compliance behavior differently for people of individualistic versus collectivistic
Cross-Cultural Investigation of Compliance Without Pressure
Compliance-without-pressure techniques have been widely studied in North America and West Europe. Among these techniques, the “but you are free” (BYAF) is a verbal compliance procedure that solicits
Interdependent self-construal in collectivist cultures: Effects on compliance in a cause-related marketing context
This study is a replication and extension of prior work on the effectiveness of cause-related marketing efforts. We show that compliance behavior across cultures can be different depending on the
Reexamining Personal, Social, and Cultural Influences on Compliance Behavior in the United States, Poland, and Hong Kon
Different levels of compliance were affected by culture, principles of influence, and the individual's personal orientation of idiocentrism/allo-centrism (I/A), and the authors' integration of personal, social, and cultural influences provided an interactive model to help researchers explain compliance more comprehensively.
Political Chameleons: An Exploration of Conformity in Political Discussions
Individuals do not always express their private political opinions in front of others who disagree. Neither political scientists nor psychologists have been able to firmly establish why this behavior
The Effect of Prior Commitment on Consumer Choice
Commitment to consistency (CC) theories have been widely studied in the field of social influence. However, studies on CC effect have examined only the decisions consumers make for themselves and
Considering rational self-interest as a disposition: organizational implications of other orientation.
The authors' model exposes a common explanation for diverse organizational phenomena and clarifies inconsistencies surrounding the validity of certain attitudinal and motivational models, cross-cultural differences in attitudes and behavior, escalation of commitment, and the relationship between chief executive officer characteristics and organizational performance.
Resistance to Deficient Organizational Authority: The Impact of Culture and Connectedness in the Workplace
In 2 countries differing on individualistic–collectivistic orientation, we investigated resistance to a request made by a manager perceived as lacking personal power based on a key attribute (e.g.,


Compliance and Value Internalization in Brazil and the U.S.
Brazilian and U.S. student samples responded to measures of behavioral intention, perceived norms, and affect regarding prosocial behaviors. Subjects were randomly assigned to either an anonymous or
Culture and conformity: A meta-analysis of studies using Asch's (1952b, 1956) line judgment task.
A meta-analysis of conformity studies using an Asch-type line judgment task (1952b, 1956) was conducted to investigate whether the level of conformity has changed over time and whether it is related
Persuasion and culture: Advertising appeals in individualistic and collectivistic societies.
Abstract Two studies examined the extent to which a core dimension of cultural variability, individualism-collectivism (Hofstede, 1980, 1983; Triandis, 1990), is reflected in the types of persuasive
Individualism and Collectivism: Cross-Cultural Perspectives on Self-Ingroup Relationships
The individualism and collectivism constructs are theoretically analyzed and linked to certain hypothesized consequences (social behaviors, health indices). Study 1 explores the meaning of these
Self-disclosure and reciprocity in conversation: a cross-national study
The present study examined the association between the stage of a relationship and the depth of reciprocal self-disclosures in dyadic conversations. The effect of nationality upon this association
Crimes of Obedience and Conformity in the Workplace: Surveys of Americans, Russians, and Japanese
One outgrowth of Milgram's (1974) research is the study of public opinion about obedience norms. Extending Kelman and Hamilton's (1989) research on crimes of obedience in the military, this article
A focus theory of normative conduct: Recycling the concept of norms to reduce littering in public places.
Past research has generated mixed support among social scientists for the utility of social norms in accounting for human behavior. We argue that norms do have a substantial impact on human action;
Social Loafing on an Optimizing Task
Research conducted in the United States and in several non-Western societies has found that people exert greater effort when they work individually than when they do so in a group that obscures
Culture′s Consequences: International Differences in Work-Related Values
In his bestselling book Culture's Consequences, Geert Hofstede proposed four dimensions on which the differences among national cultures can be understood: Individualism, Power Distance, Uncertainty
Individualism and collectivism: Theory, method, and applications.
Foreword - Geert Hofstede Series Editors' Introduction - Walter J Lonner and John W Berry Introduction - Uichol Kim et al PART ONE: THEORETICAL ANALYSIS Individualism and Collectivism - Uichol Kim