Competition, Monopoly, and Aftermarkets

  title={Competition, Monopoly, and Aftermarkets},
  author={Dennis W. Carlton and Michael Waldman},
  journal={NBER Working Paper Series},
Consider a durable goods producer that potentially has market power in the aftermarkets associated with its products. An important question is to what extent, if any, should the antitrust laws restrict the firm's behavior in these aftermarkets? In this paper we explore a number of models characterized by either competition or monopoly in the new-unit market, and show that a variety of behaviors that hurt competition in aftermarkets can, in fact, be efficient responses to potential… Expand
Consumer Myopia, Standardization and Aftermarket Monopolization
In this paper, I show that the standard Bertrand competition argument does not apply when firms compete for myopic consumers who optimize period-by-period. I develop the model in the context ofExpand
Efficient Durable Good Pricing and Aftermarket Tie-In Sales
The conditions under which a durable good supplier employs a tying arrangement that binds aftermarket purchases to the original sale was a central issue in the Kodak case. Two competing theories wereExpand
When Does Aftermarket Monopolization Soften Foremarket Competition ?
This paper investigates firms’abilities to tacitly collude when they each monopolize a proprietary aftermarket. When firms’aftermarkets are completely isolated from foremarket competition, theyExpand
Using Aftermarket Power to Soften Foremarket Competition
This paper studies competition among equipment sellers who each monopolize their equipment’s aftermarket. However, their aftermarket power is contested by foremarket competition as equipment ownersExpand
Aftermarket power and foremarket competition
I revisit the issue of aftermarkets by developing an infinite period model with overlapping consumers. If the aftermarket is characterized by constant returns to scale, then social surplus andExpand
Competition with Aftermarket Power When Consumers are Heterogeneous
We study a model of competitive foremarkets and partly monopolized aftermarkets. We show that high aftermarket power prompts firms to engage in inefficiently aggressive below-cost pricing in theExpand
Competition with Aftermarket Power when Consumers are Heterogeneous
We study a model of competitive foremarkets and partly monopolized aftermarkets. We show that high aftermarket power prompts firms to engage in inefficiently aggressive below-cost pricing in theExpand
Competition, Monopoly Maintenance, and Consumer Switching Costs
Significant attention has been paid to why a durable goods producer with little or no market power would monopolize the maintenance market for its own product. This paper investigates an explanationExpand
When Does Aftermarket Monopolization Soften Foremarket Competition?
This paper investigates firms’ abilities to tacitly collude when these firms each monopolize a proprietary aftermarket. When firms’ aftermarkets are isolated from foremarket competition, they cannotExpand
Pricing strategy in the product and service market
Abstract Existing studies have mainly focused on pricing in either primary markets or aftermarkets. However, in practice, prices in primary markets and aftermarkets are closely correlated. This studyExpand


Upgrades, Tradeins, and Buybacks
We study monopoly pricing of overlapping generations of a durable good. We consider two sorts of goods: those with an active secondhand market and anonymous consumers, such as textbooks, and thoseExpand
Exercising Market Power in Proprietary Aftermarkets
Over 20 recent antitrust cases have turned on whether competition in complex durable-equipment markets prevents manufacturers from exercising market power over proprietary aftermarket products andExpand
Markets with consumer switching costs
Ex ante homogeneous products may, after the purchase of one of them, be ex post differentiated by switching costs including learning costs, transaction costs, or "artificial" costs imposed by firms,Expand
Eliminating the Market for Secondhand Goods: An Alternative Explanation for Leasing1
There are a number of prominent specific instances in which a durable goods manufacturer with significant market power employed a lease‐only policy: (i) United Shoe in the market for shoe machinery,Expand
Durable-Goods Monopolists
Durable-goods monopolists face special problems because the sale of their products creates a secondhand market not controlled by the monopolist. To the extent the monopolist is able to rent hisExpand
Orders to Supply as Substitutes for Commitments to Aftermarkets
A number of recent antitrust cases in Canada and other countries have involved durable goods manufacturers refusing to supply proprietary parts to independent service organizations. Earlier workExpand
Durable Goods Pricing When Quality Matters
This article considers a durable goods monopolist's choice of price and durability in a setting where durability choice controls the speed with which quality deteriorates. This article derives threeExpand
Refusals to deal and orders to supply in competitive markets
Abstract A number of recent antitrust cases in North America and Europe have involved allegations that manufacturers of durable products have refused to supply parts to independent serviceExpand
Interfering with Secondary Markets
We present a model to address in a unified manner four ways in which a monopolist can interfere with secondary markets. In the model, consumers have heterogeneous valuations for quality so thatExpand
Price Wars Caused by Switching Costs
In many markets consumers have "switching costs", for example learning costs or transaction costs, of changing between functionally equivalent brands of a product, or of using any brand for the firstExpand