Comparison of Mouse and Keyboard Efficiency

@article{Omanson2010ComparisonOM,
  title={Comparison of Mouse and Keyboard Efficiency},
  author={R. Omanson and Craig S. Miller and Elizabeth Young and David Schwantes},
  journal={Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting},
  year={2010},
  volume={54},
  pages={600 - 604}
}
In many corporate settings, users are required to quickly execute commands. [...] Key Result This work confirms the use of toolbars for common commands, but also suggests that for heavily-used interfaces, keyboard shortcuts can be as efficient as toolbars and have the advantage of providing fast access to all commands.Expand
Categorization costs for hierarchical keyboard commands
TLDR
Practical implications are that hierarchical, category-based keyboard commands do not provide a clear advantage to toolbar-based selection and that theory-based evaluation methods may need to reflect this result.
Effects of Item Grouping on Selection Efficiency
TLDR
The use of toolbars for infrequently-used interfaces and keyboard shortcuts for frequently- used interfaces are confirmed, coupled with past research that proficient use of the Keyboard method requires more trials than the other methods.
CommandBoard: Creating a General-Purpose Command Gesture Input Space for Soft Keyboard
TLDR
This work transforms the area above the keyboard into a command-gesture input space that lets users draw unique command gestures or type command names followed by execute, and shows that CommandBoard's inline gesture shortcuts are significantly faster (almost double) than markdown symbols and significantly preferred by users.
ReconViguRation: Reconfiguring Physical Keyboards in Virtual Reality
TLDR
A set of input and output mappings for reconfiguring the virtual presentation of physical keyboards in VR are explored and the resulting design space is probed by specifically designing, implementing and evaluating nine VR-relevant applications.
Increasing the expressive power of gesture-based interaction on mobile devices. (Augmenter le pouvoir d'expression de l'interaction gestuelle sur les appareils mobiles)
TLDR
This thesis designs "Expressive Keyboard" that transforms the gesture variations into rich output, and proposes "CommandBoard", a gesture keyboard that lets users efficiently select commands from a large command space while supporting the transition from novices to experts.
Learning from Gamers: Integrating Alternative Input Devices and AutoHotkey Scripts to Simplify Repetitive Tasks and Improve Workflow.
TLDR
Hardware and software features that do not require support from information technology professionals and can be implemented with any software that relies on user input are discussed.
Re-imagining the Command Line User Experience for Problem Solving
TLDR
Users were found to react well to command suggestion mechanisms, achieving faster tasks Success and engaging in less documentation checking, and there are still challenges for the integration off these in real-world CLI software systems.
Sticky Fingers: The effect of sticky interaction patterns on the design and adoption of a Radiology Information System
TLDR
This thesis explored which actions and processes are the most difficult for users to learn anew and explore the psychological reasons for this, and ten design recommendations are laid out for use when upgrading a system interface.
Diseño de una capacitación para promover el uso de atajos de teclado
TLDR
A training to promote the leaming and use of keyboard shortcuts in internet browsers and Microsoft Office software’s such as PowerPoint, Word and Excel showed a significant improvement in the time of task completion time, shortcut use frequency and shortcut execution speed.
Shortcuts for faster image creation in PyMOL
  • B. Mooers
  • Medicine, Computer Science
    Protein science : a publication of the Protein Society
  • 2019
PyMOL is often used to generate images of biomolecular structures. Hundreds of parameters in PyMOL provide precise control over the appearance of structures. We developed 241 Python functions—called
...
1
2
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 14 REFERENCES
A Comparison of Menu Selection Techniques: Touch Panel, Mouse and Keyboard
TLDR
The studies showed performance advantages for on-screen touch panel entry and preference ratings for the touch panel and keyboard devices depended on the type of task being performed, while the mouse was always the least preferred device.
Hidden Costs of Graphical User Interfaces: Failure to Make the Transition from Menus and Icon Toolbars to Keyboard Shortcuts
TLDR
Two studies show that even experienced users are inefficient in their use of graphical interfaces, and one possible way to improve user efficiency is for training programs to provide a roadmap for users to make the transition from using pull-down menus and clicking icon toolbars to issuing keyboard shortcuts.
Using mouse and keyboard under time pressure: Preference, strategies and learning
TLDR
A study of preference, strategies and learning in using keyboard and mouse in a tracking task under time pressure found the keyboard was preferred by 11 out of 12 subjects due primarily to comfort, frustration, and visual strain.
A predictive model of menu performance
TLDR
A model of menu performance is proposed that goes beyond previous work by incorporating components for Fitts' Law pointing time, visual search time, Hick-Hyman Law decision time when expert, and for the transition from novice to expert behaviour.
Cognitive strategies and eye movements for searching hierarchical computer displays
TLDR
This work combines cognitive modeling and eye tracking to explain this and numerous other visual design guidelines, and demonstrates the power of cognitive modeling for predicting, explaining, and interpreting eye movement data, and how to use eye tracking data to confirm and disconfirm modeling details.
The GOMS family of user interface analysis techniques: comparison and contrast
TLDR
This article compares and contrasts four popular variantsof the GOMS family (the Keystroke-Level Model, the original GomS formulation, NGOMSL, and CPM-GOMS) by applying them to a single task example.
The information capacity of the human motor system in controlling the amplitude of movement.
  • P. Fitts
  • Psychology, Medicine
    Journal of experimental psychology
  • 1954
TLDR
The motor system in the present case is defined as including the visual and proprioceptive feedback loops that permit S to monitor his own activity, and the information capacity of the motor system is specified by its ability to produce consistently one class of movement from among several alternative movement classes.
Strategies and classification learning
How do strategies affect the learning of categories that lack necessary and sufficient attributes? The usual answer is that different strategies correspond to different models. In this article we
On the Rate of Gain of Information
TLDR
The principal finding is that the rate of gain of information is, on the average, constant with respect to time, within the duration of one perceptual-motor act, and has a value of the order of five “bits” per second.
Mechanisms of Skill Acquisition and the Law of Practice
TLDR
A model of practice rooted in modern cognitive psychology, the chunking theory of learning, is formulated in an investigation of the mechanisms underlying the performance improvement in psychology.
...
1
2
...