Comparison of Injuries in American Collegiate Football and Club Rugby

@article{Willigenburg2016ComparisonOI,
  title={Comparison of Injuries in American Collegiate Football and Club Rugby},
  author={Nienke W. Willigenburg and James R. Borchers and Richard Quincy and Christopher C. Kaeding and Timothy E. Hewett},
  journal={The American Journal of Sports Medicine},
  year={2016},
  volume={44},
  pages={753 - 760}
}
Background: American football and rugby players are at substantial risk of injury because of the full-contact nature of these sports. Methodological differences between previous epidemiological studies hamper an accurate comparison of injury rates between American football and rugby. Purpose: To directly compare injury rates in American collegiate football and rugby, specified by location, type, mechanism, and severity of injury, as reported by licensed medical professionals. Study Design… 

Tables from this paper

Injury rates and patterns in professional American rugby: a prospective observational study
TLDR
The overall injury rates in this study correspond with previous amateur and international rugby literature showing a trend toward increased injury risk during gameplay at a professional level.
Analysis of Football Injuries by Position Group in Division I College Football: A 5-Year Program Review.
TLDR
Efforts to reduce soft-tissue muscle strains in skill players targeting the preseason may provide one of the best opportunities to significantly decrease current football IRs, whereas efforts to reduce contact exposures may have the greatest effect on concussions and contact mechanism injuries for the other position group.
A Review of a Decade of Rugby Union Injury Epidemiology: 2007-2017
TLDR
A paucity of injury surveillance data exists for women and players of both sexes at all levels of community rugby union, and the incidence of injuries and illnesses are poorly reported in epidemiological studies.
Mechanisms and Factors Associated With Tackle-Related Injuries in South African Youth Rugby Union Players
TLDR
The relative risk of tackle-related injury was higher toward the end of matches and implementing recovery strategies between matches, training safe and effective techniques, and improving levels of conditioning may counter the negative effects of fatigue.
The Most Dangerous Game: A Review of Head and Neck Injuries in American Football and Rugby
TLDR
There was no difference in the rate of hospital admission when comparing football and rugby (OR, 1.2; P = .1), and male gender was associated with an increased risk of admission.
Factors Associated With the Mechanism of ACL Tears in the National Football League: A Video-Based Analysis
TLDR
Although most NFL players sustained ACL tears via a noncontact mechanism, players with an elevated BMI, especially on the offensive line, were more likely to injure their ACL through direct contact.
The Epidemiology of Injuries in Spanish Rugby Union División de Honor
TLDR
Outcomes confirm that more injuries take place during competition, with these also being more severe in nature.
A Narrative Review of the Physical Demands and Injury Incidence in American Football: Application of Current Knowledge and Practices in Workload Management
The sport of American football (AmF) exposes athletes to high-velocity movements and frequent collisions during competition and training, placing them at risk of contact and non-contact injury. Due
Cumulative Sport-Related Injuries and Longer Term Impact in Retired Male Elite- and Amateur-Level Rugby Code Athletes and Non-contact Athletes: A Retrospective Study
TLDR
Across multiple injury types, past participation in rugby union and rugby league, particularly at elite level, is associated with a high cumulative injury load and a continued impact of previous injuries post-retirement.
Australian Football League Injury Characteristics Differ Between Matches and Training: A Longitudinal Analysis of Changes in the Setting, Site, and Time Span From 1997 to 2016
TLDR
The risks of match injuries are significantly higher than those of training injuries in the AFL, and injuries became more severe during the 2007-2011 time span.
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 15 REFERENCES
Injuries in American Collegiate Club Rugby : A Prospective Study
TLDR
The results of this study indicate that rugby players are at substantial risk of injury, especially during games, which is lower than previously reported in international rugby, but higher than in many other American collegiate sports.
Epidemiology of National Football League Training Camp Injuries from 1998 to 2007
Background Football is one of the leading causes of athletic-related injuries. Injury rates and patterns of the training camp period of the National Football League are unknown. Hypothesis Injury
Descriptive epidemiology of collegiate men's football injuries: National Collegiate Athletic Association Injury Surveillance System, 1988-1989 through 2003-2004.
TLDR
Football is a complex sport that requires a range of skills performed by athletes with a wide variety of body shapes and types, and appropriate injury surveillance procedures should be performed to determine the effect of the new equipment on injury rates.
Epidemiology of High School and Collegiate Football Injuries in the United States, 2005-2006
TLDR
Patterns of football injuries vary, especially by type of exposure and level of play, with particular emphasis placed on high-risk plays (running plays) and positions (running backs and linebackers).
Collegiate rugby union injury patterns in New England: a prospective cohort study
TLDR
Collegiate game injury rates for rugby were lower than rates recorded previously in men’s professional club and international rugby and lower than reported by the National Collegiate Athletic Association Injury Surveillance System for American football, but similar to rates reported for men's and women's soccer in 2005–06.
A Meta-Analysis of Injuries in Senior Men’s Professional Rugby Union
TLDR
This meta-analysis confirms match injury incidence rates in professional Rugby Union can be considered high in comparison with other team sports, but similar to other collision sports.
Epidemiology of collegiate injuries for 15 sports: summary and recommendations for injury prevention initiatives.
TLDR
Modifiable factors that, if addressed through injury prevention initiatives, may contribute to lower injury rates in collegiate sports are indicated.
Injury Patterns in Big Ten Conference Football
TLDR
Although the noncontact, helmets-only practices produced the lowest injury rates, the nonspring game scrimmages and the limited-contact practices defined as “practice with pads but without tackling” displayed the highest injury rates.
National Collegiate Athletic Association Injury Surveillance System commentaries: introduction and methods.
TLDR
The publication of this special issue of the Journal of Athletic Training and the evolution of an expanded Web-based ISS enhance the opportunity to apply the health and safety decision-making process at the level of the individual athletic trainer and institution.
AN OPTIMALITY THEORY FOR MID p-VALUES IN 2 × 2 CONTINGENCY TABLES
The contingency table arises in nearly every application of statistics. However, even the basic problem of testing independence is not totally resolved. More than thirty-five years ago, Lancaster
...
...