Comparing the Incomparable? A Systematic Review of Competing Techniques for Converting Descriptive Measures of Health Status into QALY-Weights

@article{Mortimer2008ComparingTI,
  title={Comparing the Incomparable? A Systematic Review of Competing Techniques for Converting Descriptive Measures of Health Status into QALY-Weights},
  author={Duncan Mortimer and Leonie Segal},
  journal={Medical Decision Making},
  year={2008},
  volume={28},
  pages={66 - 89}
}
Background . Algorithms for converting descriptive measures of health status into quality-adjusted life year (QALY)—weights are now widely available, and their application in economic evaluation is increasingly commonplace. The objective of this study is to describe and compare existing conversion algorithms and to highlight issues bearing on the derivation and interpretation of the QALY-weights so obtained. Methods . Systematic review of algorithms for converting descriptive measures of health… 

Tables from this paper

Converting condition-specific measures into preference-based outcomes for use in economic evaluation

  • J. PetrilloJ. Cairns
  • Medicine, Political Science
    Expert review of pharmacoeconomics & outcomes research
  • 2008
TLDR
It is timely to review recent research activity directed at making greater use of condition-specific data to inform assessments of cost–effectiveness.

A Systematic Review of the Literature on the Development of Condition-Specific Preference-Based Measures of Health

TLDR
Various methods have been used at all stages of CSPBM development, and the choice between developing a classification system de novo or from an existing instrument appears to be determined primarily by the purpose for which the instrument is designed.

Statistical Alchemy: Conceptual Validity and Mapping to Generate Health State Utility Values

TLDR
The idea of conceptual validity in mapping and its implications is explained, the consequences of poor conceptual validity when mapping for decision making in the context of healthcare resource allocation are considered, and some preliminary suggestions for improving conceptual validity are offered.

METHODOLOGICAL Should Linking Replace Regression When Mapping from Pro fi le-Based Measures to Preference-Based Measures?

TLDR
An effective way of assessing the validity of linking scores is by assessing whether the linking function is invariant in diverse subpopulations, because differences in constructs or reliability of instruments are manifested by population invariance, as are nonlinearity and other depar-tures from the model.

Putting the Patient in Patient Reported Outcomes: A Robust Methodology for Health Outcomes Assessment

TLDR
Through a series of Monte Carlo simulations, the proposed methodology is shown to be more robust to the distributional properties of QALYs, thereby avoiding the potential bias introduced when converting the multi-dimensional HRQoL into a one-dimensionalQALY.

Review of studies mapping from quality of life or clinical measures to EQ-5D: an online database

  • H. Dakin
  • Psychology
    Health and Quality of Life Outcomes
  • 2013
Systematic literature searches were conducted to identify studies that conducted statistical mapping to predict EQ-5D utilities or responses from any source instrument and reported the estimated

Review and critical appraisal of studies mapping from quality of life or clinical measures to EQ-5D: an online database and application of the MAPS statement

TLDR
The extent to which recently-published studies mapping condition-specific quality of life or clinical measures to the EQ-5D follow the guidelines published in the MAPS Reporting Statement is assessed.

Estimating CHU-9D Utility Scores from the WAItE: A Mapping Algorithm for Economic Evaluation.

  • T. RobinsonY. Oluboyede
  • Medicine
    Value in health : the journal of the International Society for Pharmacoeconomics and Outcomes Research
  • 2019

Putting the Patient in Patient Reported Outcomes: A Robust Methodology for Health Outcomes Assessment.

TLDR
The approach also offers a more patient-centered interpretation of results by estimating regression coefficients and incremental effects in each of the HRQoL domains, while still providing estimated effects in terms of the overall summary score.

Comparison of the underlying constructs of the EQ-5D and Oxford Hip Score: implications for mapping.

  • M. OppeN. DevlinN. Black
  • Medicine, Psychology
    Value in health : the journal of the International Society for Pharmacoeconomics and Outcomes Research
  • 2011
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 91 REFERENCES

Preference-based measures in economic evaluation in health care.

TLDR
Although cost-utility analyses have become more popular recently, many challenges remain for the field and widespread acceptance of the methodology likely awaits more consensus on measurement techniques, as well as educational efforts in the public health and medical communities on the usefulness of the approach.

Can we reduce disease burden from osteoarthritis? An evidence-based priority-setting model

TLDR
The application of the Health-sector Wide model to OA demonstrates its role as an evidence-based model that can be successfully applied to identify marginal interventions - those to be expanded and contracted to reduce the expected burden of disease, within current healthcare resources.

Evaluating Quality-Adjusted Life Years

TLDR
The present model can be used to estimate health utility summary scores in studies that have collected SF-36 data and provide a quantitative link between two important measures of health status.

Item-based versus subscale-based mappings from the SF-36 to a preference-based quality of life measure.

TLDR
The results do not support the hypothesis that fewer restrictions on functional form necessarily result in a lower magnitude of error when predicting between-group differences, and it appears that the subscale-based mapping offers a good compromise--requiring less restrictions on the form of the relationship between SF-36 responses and the AQoL utility score than the scale- based mapping and permitting a more efficient use of SF- 36 data than the item-based mapped.

Assessing Cost-Effectiveness – Mental Health: Introduction to the Study and Methods

TLDR
The main limitation of the study is in the translation of the effect size from trials into a change in the DALY disability weight, which required the use of newly developed methods.

The Estimation of a Preference-Based Measure of Health From the SF-12

TLDR
The SF-12 index provides a useful tool for researchers and policy makers wishing to assess the cost-effectiveness of interventions and to compare it with the original SF-36 preference-based index.

Quality of life and time trade-off utility measures in patients with coronary artery disease.

TLDR
Time trade-off utility scores can be inferred from commonly used quality-of-life measures and patients with recurrent angina significantly reduces patient utility scores.

Estimation and comparison of derived preference scores from the SF-36 in lung transplant patients

TLDR
The mean preferences of patients grouped by levels of dyspnea, depression symptoms, illness burden, and self-rated general health differed significantly with all methods and supported the construct validity of the derived scores as measures of preference.
...