Comparative Journal Ratings: A Survey Report

  title={Comparative Journal Ratings: A Survey Report},
  author={I. McLean and A. Blais and James C. Garand and Micheal W. Giles},
  journal={Political Studies Review},
  pages={18 - 38}
The expert survey and bibliometric methods of assessing the quality of work in political science are complementary. This project builds on previous surveys of academic political science journals conducted among US political scientists. The current wave extends the survey to political scientists in Canada and the UK. Preliminary results suggest both similarities and differences across the three countries. These results matter for policy debate in any country that is considering channelling flows… Expand

Figures from this paper

Reputations and Research Quality in British Political Science: The Importance of Journal and Publisher Rankings in the 2008 RAE
Research Highlights and Abstract The article seeks to make a contribution in the following areas: Departments that submitted a large proportion of books published with a top university press tendedExpand
Where is the Quality? Political Science Scholarship in Australia
This article presents a comparison of research quality in political science among Australian universities. Two sources are used to assess the output of high-quality political science scholarship. TheExpand
Reputational Rankings of Peer-Reviewed Law Journals: A Survey Approach
  • P. Collins
  • Political Science
  • PS: Political Science & Politics
  • 2018
ABSTRACT This article presents the results of the first-ever survey that captures how political scientists view peer-reviewed law journals with regard to overall impact, familiarity, and articleExpand
Publication Output of Swiss Political Science Departments
This paper compares the scientic publication output and international academic visibility of Swiss political science departments, using three indicators (number of publications, number of citations,Expand
The Assessment of Research Quality in UK Universities: Peer Review or Metrics?
This paper investigates the extent to which the outcomes of the 2008 Research Assessment Exercise in the UK, determined by peer review, can be explained by a set of quantitative indicators. ThreeExpand
Publishing in Public Administration: Issues with Defining, Comparing, and Ranking the Output of Universities
ABSTRACT The measurement and comparison of the public administration output of universities is an important means for mapping the state of the field. However, such exercises are very sensitive toExpand
Publishing in Public Administration: Issues with Defining, Comparing and Ranking the Output of Universities
ABSTRACTThe measurement and comparison of the public administration output of universities is an important means for mapping the state of the field. However, such exercises are very sensitive toExpand
Assessing Political Science Quality: ‘Excellence in Research for Australia’
The results from the first foray into the research quality in Australia, Excellence in Research for Australia (ERA), were released in 2011. This article critically assesses the methodology of ERA andExpand
Trends in Political Science Research and the Progress of Comparative Politics
  • M. Wilson
  • Political Science
  • PS: Political Science & Politics
  • 2017
ABSTRACT This article illustrates major trends in political science research and frames the progress of research agendas in comparative politics. Drawing on the titles and abstracts of every articleExpand
Metrics versus Peer Review?
At a time when research evaluation policy in the UK is in some flux, and when there are a multitude of proposals for change but little hard-headed analysis, Political Studies Review is to beExpand


A Global Ranking of Political Science Departments
Rankings of academic institutions are key information tools for universities, funding agencies, students and faculty. The main method for ranking departments in political science, through peerExpand
Journals in the Discipline: A Report on a New Survey of American Political Scientists
A long with books, scholarly journals constitute the primary media through which political scientists communicate the results of their research to their discipline. However, not all journals areExpand
Political Scientists' Evaluations of Sixty-three Journals
Professional journals are central in our professional lives. They are a primary means of communicating new ideas and research findings to other political scientists, and hence help record, howeverExpand
Political Scientists' Journal Evaluations Revisited
Refereed journals are a principal means of communication within the scholarly community. Accordingly, publication in refereed journals is taken as a sino quo non for success within the discipline.Expand
An Alternative Interpretation of Recent Political Science Journal Evaluations
In their recent article in PS, Giles, Mizell, and Patterson (1989) provide a long-awaited update of an earlier article (Giles and Wright, 1975) on subjective evaluations by political scientists of aExpand
What Economists Think of Their Journals
Economists tend to accord widely varying degrees of respect to the many different journals and alternative publication media available to them. Even though colleagues in casual luncheon conversationExpand
Party Policy in Britain 1997: Results from an Expert Survey
Given the wide range of policy-based models of party competition, as well as the very common tendency for people in all walks of life to talk informally about politics in terms of the policyExpand
Mapping Policy Preferences: Estimates for Parties, Electors, and Governments 1945-1998
Who Governs: Democracy and Power in an American City.
In this now-classic work, one of the most celebrated political scientists of the twentieth century offers a powerful interpretation of the location of political power in American urban communities.Expand
Community Power Structure. A Study of Decision Makers
Spend your time even for only few minutes to read a book. Reading a book will never reduce and waste your time to be useless. Reading, for some people become a need that is to do every day such asExpand