Comment on “The Notion of Locality in Relational Quantum Mechanics”

@article{Pienaar2019CommentO,
  title={Comment on “The Notion of Locality in Relational Quantum Mechanics”},
  author={Jacques L. Pienaar},
  journal={Foundations of Physics},
  year={2019}
}
  • J. Pienaar
  • Published 17 July 2018
  • Philosophy
  • Foundations of Physics
A recent paper [P. Martin-Dussaud, C. Rovelli, F. Zalamea, arXiv:1806.08150] has given a lucid treatment of Bell's notion of local causality within the framework of the relational interpretation of quantum mechanics. However, the authors went on to conclude that the quantum violation of Bell's notion of local causality is no more surprising than a common cause. Here, I argue that this conclusion is unwarranted by the authors' own analysis. On the contrary, within the framework outlined by the… 
Assessing Relational Quantum Mechanics
Relational Quantum Mechanics (RQM) is a non-standard interpretation of quantum theory based on the idea of abolishing the notion of absolute states of systems, in favor of states of systems relative
A Quintet of Quandaries: Five No-Go Theorems for Relational Quantum Mechanics
Relational quantum mechanics (RQM) proposes an ontology of relations between physical systems, where any system can serve as an ‘observer’ and any physical interaction between systems counts as a
QBism and Relational Quantum Mechanics compared
In this paper we compare the subjective Bayesian interpretation of quantum mechanics (QBism) [1–13] with Rovelli’s relational interpretation of quantum mechanics (RQM) [14–31]. Both interpretations
What Ontology for Relational Quantum Mechanics? 1
In this paper, we evaluate some proposals that can be advanced to clarify the ontological consequences of Relational Quantum Mechanics. We first focus on priority monism and ontic structural realism
The Relational Interpretation of Quantum Physics
The relational interpretation (or RQM, for Relational Quantum Mechanics) solves the measurement problem by considering an ontology of sparse relative events, or facts. Events are realized in
The Relational Interpretation
The relational interpretation (or RQM, for Relational Quantum Mechanics) solves the measurement problem by considering an ontology of sparse relative facts. Facts are realized in interactions between
What Ontology for Relational Quantum Mechanics?
In this paper, we evaluate some proposals that have been put forward to clarify the ontological consequences of relational quantum mechanics. We first focus on priority monism and ontic structural
On Relationalist Reconstructions of Quantum Theory
One appealing feature of Carlo Rovelli’s proposal for “Relational Quantum Mechanics” [1] is that it offered a challenge for those who prefer technical work over slinging sentences: the reconstruction
The Bundle Theory Approach to Relational Quantum Mechanics
TLDR
A new metaphysical interpretation of Relational Quantum Mechanics (RQM) in terms of mereological bundle theory is provided, claiming that a physical system in RQM can be defined as a mereological fusion of properties whose values may vary for different observers.
Stable Facts, Relative Facts
Facts happen at every interaction, but they are not absolute: they are relative to the systems involved in the interaction. Stable facts are those whose relativity can effectively be ignored. In this
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 16 REFERENCES
The Notion of Locality in Relational Quantum Mechanics
TLDR
The present article shows that the failure of ‘locality’ in the sense of Bell, once interpreted in the relational framework, reduces to the existence of a common cause in an indeterministic context.
Relational quantum mechanics
I suggest that the common unease with taking quantum mechanics as a fundamental description of nature (the “measurement problem”) could derive from the use of an incorrect notion, as the unease with
Quantum common causes and quantum causal models
Reichenbach’s principle asserts that if two observed variables are found to be correlated, then there should be a causal explanation of these correlations. Furthermore, if the explanation is in terms
A Lenient Causal Arrow of Time?
TLDR
In the present work, some retrocausal toy-models which reproduce the predictions of quantum mechanics for Bell-type correlations are reviewed and it is pointed out that a certain toy-model which is ostensibly superdeterministic—based on denying the free-variable status of some of quantum Mechanics’ input parameters—actually contains within it a complete retrocaused toy- model, indicating that Occam’s razor indicates that the superDeterministic point of view is superfluous.
The two Bellʼs theorems of John Bell
Many of the heated arguments about the meaning of ‘Bellʼs theorem’ arise because this phrase can refer to two different theorems that John Bell proved, the first in 1964 and the second in 1976. His
Observer-dependent locality of quantum events
TLDR
The causal reference frame description can be used to gain insight into the question of realisability of such strongly non-causal processes in laboratory experiments and it is shown that the new formalism is equivalent to the pure process matrix formalism.
Quantum causal modelling
TLDR
This work defines quantum analogues for core features of classical causal modelling techniques, including the causal Markov condition and faithfulness, and introduces a new framework for quantum causal modelling that allows for the discovery of causal structure.
Theory-independent limits on correlations from generalized Bayesian networks
TLDR
This work generalizes the formalism of classical Bayesian networks in order to investigate non-classical correlations in arbitrary causal structures, and finds that no probabilistic theory predicts perfect correlation between three parties using only bipartite common causes.
Time's arrow and Archimedes' point new directions for the physics of time
The View from Nowhen More Apt to Be Lost than Got: The Lessons of the Second Law New light on The Arrow of Radiation Arrows and Error in Contemporary Cosmology Innocence and Symmetry in Microphysics
and F
  • Zalamea,
  • 2018
...
...