# Comment on “The Free Will Theorem”

@article{Tumulka2007CommentO, title={Comment on “The Free Will Theorem”}, author={Roderich Tumulka}, journal={Foundations of Physics}, year={2007}, volume={37}, pages={186-197} }

In a recent paper Conway and Kochen, Found. Phys. 36, 2006, claim to have established that theories of the Ghirardi-Rimini-Weber (RW) type, i.e., of spontaneous wave function collapse, cannot be made relativistic. On the other hand, relativistic GRW-type theories have already been presented, in my recent paper, J. Stat. Phys. 125, 2006, and by Dowker and Henson, J. Stat. Phys. 115, 2004. Here, I elucidate why these are not excluded by the arguments of Conway and Kochen.

## 43 Citations

What Does the Free Will Theorem Actually Prove

- Philosophy
- 2009

Conway and Kochen have presented a "free will theorem" (Notices of the AMS 56, pgs. 226-232 (2009)) which they claim shows that "if indeed we humans have free will, then [so do] elementary…

The Free Will Theorem

- Philosophy
- 2008

I begin with description of quantum entanglement and its relevance to the EPR-type experiments, which played a decisive role in rejecting determinism and hidden-variable theories. Thereby I prove the…

The Strong FreeWill Theorem

- Physics, Philosophy
- 2008

T he two theories that revolutionized physics in the twentieth century, relativity and quantum mechanics, are full of predictions that defy common sense. Recently, we used three such paradoxical…

The Conway-Kochen Free Will Theorem

- Mathematics
- 2009

John Conway and Simon Kochen say that their recent Free Will Theorem (henceforth, FWT) is “the culmination of a series of theorems about quantum mechanics that began in the 1960s” (Conway & Kochen,…

THE POINT PROCESSES OF THE GRW THEORY OF WAVE FUNCTION COLLAPSE

- Philosophy
- 2009

The Ghirardi–Rimini–Weber (GRW) theory is a physical theory that, when combined with a suitable ontology, provides an explanation of quantum mechanics. The so-called collapse of the wave function is…

Lorentz-Invariant, Retrocausal, and Deterministic Hidden Variables

- EconomicsFoundations of Physics
- 2019

We review several no-go theorems attributed to Gisin and Hardy, Conway and Kochen purporting the impossibility of Lorentz-invariant deterministic hidden-variable model for explaining quantum…

Free Will in a Quantum World?

- PhilosophySynthese Library
- 2019

In this paper, I argue that Conway and Kochen’s Free Will Theorem (Conway and Kochen 2006, 2009) to the conclusion that quantum mechanics and relativity entail freedom for the particles, does not…

The General Free Will Theorem

- Philosophy, Mathematics
- 2010

It is argued that the Strong Free Will Theorem (Conway-Kochen) does not prove nonlocal determinism wrong. This is done by the before-before (Suarez-Scarani) experiment, which is used here to prove…

On the free-will postulate in Quantum Mechanics

- Philosophy
- 2007

The so-called "free will axiom" is an essential ingredient in many discussions concerning hidden variables in quantum mechanics. In this paper we argue that "free will" can be defined in different…

Schrödinger’s Paradox and Proofs of Nonlocality Using Only Perfect Correlations

- PhilosophyJournal of Statistical Physics
- 2019

We discuss proofs of nonlocality based on a generalization by Erwin Schrodinger of the argument of Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen. These proofs do not appeal in any way to Bell's inequalities. Indeed,…

## References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 20 REFERENCES

The Conway-Kochen Argument and Relativistic GRW Models

- Philosophy
- 2006

In a recent paper, Conway and Kochen proposed what is now known as the “Free Will theorem” which, among other things, should prove the impossibility of combining GRW models with special relativity,…

Collapse and Relativity

- Physics
- 2006

Ever since we have been in the possession of quantum theories without observers, such as Bohmian mechanics or the Ghirardi‐Rimini‐Weber (GRW) theory of spontaneous wave function collapse, a major…

The Free Will Theorem

- Economics
- 2006

On the basis of three physical axioms, we prove that if the choice of a particular type of spin 1 experiment is not a function of the information accessible to the experimenters, then its outcome is…

A Relativistic Version of the Ghirardi–Rimini–Weber Model

- Physics
- 2006

Carrying out a research program outlined by John S. Bell in 1987, we arrive at a relativistic version of the Ghirardi-Rimini-Weber (GRW) model of spontaneous wavefunction collapse. The GRW model was…

On the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen paradox

- Physics
- 1964

THE paradox of Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen [1] was advanced as an argument that quantum mechanics could not be a complete theory but should be supplemented by additional variables. These additional…

John Bell and Bell's Theorem

- Physics
- 2004

John Stewart Bell (1928-1990), a truly deep and serious thinker, was one of the leading physi-cists of the 20th century. He became famous for his discovery that quantum mechanics impliesthat nature…

Completeness, supervenience and ontology

- Philosophy
- 2007

In 1935, Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen raised the issue of the completeness of the quantum description of a physical system. What they had in mind is whether or not the quantum description is…

Schrödinger: Are there quantum jumps?

- Physics
- 1987

If we have to go on with these damned quantum jumps, then I'm sorry that I ever got involved. E. Schrodinger Introduction I have borrowed the title of a characteristic paper by Schrodinger…

Spontaneous Collapse Models on a Lattice

- Physics
- 2004

We present spontaneous collapse models of field theories on a 1+1 null lattice, in which the causal structure of the lattice plays a central role. Issues such as “locality,” “nonlocality,” and…

On the Common Structure of Bohmian Mechanics and the Ghirardi–Rimini–Weber Theory

- PhilosophyThe British Journal for the Philosophy of Science
- 2008

Bohmian mechanics and the Ghirardi–Rimini–Weber theory provide opposite resolutions of the quantum measurement problem: the former postulates additional variables (the particle positions) besides the…