Comment on “Protocol for Direct Counterfactual Quantum Communication”

@article{Vaidman2014CommentO,
  title={Comment on “Protocol for Direct Counterfactual Quantum Communication”},
  author={Lev Vaidman},
  journal={Physical Review Letters},
  year={2014},
  volume={112},
  pages={208901}
}
  • L. Vaidman
  • Published 24 April 2013
  • Philosophy
  • Physical Review Letters
I argue that recent "Protocol for Direct Counterfactual Quantum Communication" by Salih et al. [PRL 110, 170502 (2013), arXiv:1206.2042] is counterfactual only for one type of the information bit. 

Figures from this paper

Counterfactual distribution of Schrödinger cat states
In the counterfactual cryptography scheme proposed by Noh (2009), the sender Alice probabilistically transmits classical information to the receiver Bob without the physical travel of a particle.
Counterfactual quantum erasure: spooky action without entanglement
TLDR
This paper proposes a simple yet unusual quantum eraser: A distant Bob can decide to erase which-path information from Alice’s photon, dramatically restoring interference—without previously shared entanglement, and without Alice's photon ever leaving her laboratory.
Reply to "Comment on `Particle path through a nested Mach-Zehnder interferometer' "
This is a Reply to a Comment by H. Salih in arXiv:1608.01640. While the consistency conditions are correctly worked out in the Comment, they do not support the claim that the protocol in question
How Quantum is Quantum Counterfactual Communication?
Quantum Counterfactual Communication is the recently-proposed idea of using quantum physics to send messages between two parties, without any matter/energy transfer associated with the bits sent.
From a Quantum Paradox to Counterportation
We uncover a new quantum paradox, where a simple question about two identical quantum systems reveals unsettlingly paradoxical answers when weak measurements are considered. Our resolution of the
Quantum counterfactual communication without a weak trace
This work was supported by an EPSRC DTA grant and the Cambridge Laboratory of Hitachi Limited via Project for Developing Innovation Systems of the MEXT in Japan.
Protocol for Counterfactually Transporting an Unknown Qubit
Quantum teleportation circumvents the uncertainty principle using dual channels: a quantum one consisting of previously-shared entanglement, and a classical one, together allowing the disembodied
The laws of physics do not prohibit counterfactual communication
It has been conjectured that counterfactual communication is impossible, even for post-selected quantum particles. We strongly challenge this by proposing precisely such a counterfactual scheme
Do the laws of physics prohibit counterfactual communication?
TLDR
This paper proposes exactly such a counterfactual scheme where, unambiguously, none of Alice's photons that make it has been to Bob, and demonstrates counterfactuality experimentally by means of weak measurements, as well as conceptually using consistent histories.
“Counterfactual” quantum protocols
TLDR
The counterfactuality of recently proposed protocols is analyzed and it is argued that an interaction-free measurement (IFM) of the presence of an opaque object can be named “counterfactual”, while proposed “ counterfactUAL” measurements of the absence of such objects are not counterfactual.
...
...