Comment on : Quantum direct communication with authentication

  title={Comment on : Quantum direct communication with authentication},
  author={Zhan-jun Zhang},
  journal={Physical Review A},
Two protocols of quantum direct communication with authentication [Phys. Rev. A 73, 042305 (2006)] were recently proposed by Lee, Lim, and Yang. In this paper we will show that in the two protocols the authenticator Trent should be prevented from knowing the secret message. The first protocol can be eavesdropped on by Trent using the intercept-measure-resend attack, while the second protocol can be eavesdropped on by Trent using a simple single-qubit measurement. To fix these leaks, we revise… 

Tables from this paper

Efficient quantum secure direct communication with authentication
Two novel efficient protocols of quantum direct communication with authentication are presented by utilizing four kinds of Pauli operations (I, sigmax, isigmay, sigmaz ) that can transmit two bits message every GHZ state, instead of one bit in the aforementioned protocols.
Quantum Authenticated Direct Communication Using Bell States
Two authenticated quantum direct communication (AQDC) protocols using Bell states are proposed that can identify each other by checking the correlation of Bell states and economize the quantum resource.
Quantum Secure Direct Communication with Mutual Authentication using a Single Basis
The security of the proposed protocol against some common attacks is discussed and it is shown that no eavesdropper can get any information from the quantum and classical channels and a repetition code based protection scheme that requires minimal overhead is proposed.
Cryptanalysis of Quantum Secure Direct Communication Protocol with Mutual Authentication Based on Single Photons and Bell States
This work shows that the QSDC protocol is not secure against intercept-and-resend attack and impersonation attack, and proposes a modification of this protocol, which defeats the above attacks along with all the familiar attacks.
Revisiting Controlled Quantum Secure Direct Communication Using a Non-symmetric Quantum Channel with Quantum Superdense Coding
Recently Xia and Song [Phys. Lett. A 364 (2007) 117] have proposed a controlled quantum secure direct communication (CQSDC) protocol. They claimed that in their protocol only with the help of the
Cryptanalysis of quantum broadcast communication and authentication protocol with a one-time pad*
It is found that an intercept-resend attack can be preformed successfully by a potential eavesdropper, who will be able to destroy the authentication function.
Improvement on Quantum Secure Direct Communication with W State in Noisy Channel
In this paper, another improvement on C-protocol is given, and the quantum bit error rate of the eavesdropping will increase to 8.75%, which is 1.1 times larger than that in C- Protocol and 0.4 times larger in Y-Protocol.
A one-way quantum secure direct communication protocol with quantum identification utilizing two-photon three-qubit linear cluster states that achieves a high efficiency and source capacity since more qubits can be encoded on the same photon.
Efficient Quantum Secure Direct Communication with Authentication
Two protocols of quantum direct communication with authentication are presented by using four Pauli operations, which are secure against inner Trent attacks as well as outer Eve attacks and generalize them to multiparty quantum direction communication.
A Multiparty Controlled Bidirectional Quantum Secure Direct Communication and Authentication Protocol Based on EPR Pairs
A multiparty controlled bidirectional quantum secure direct communication and authentication protocol is proposed based on EPR pair and entanglement swapping. The legitimate identities of


Phys. Lett
  • Phys. Lett
  • 2005