Comment on "Evidence for Neutrinoless Double Beta Decay"

@article{Aalseth2002CommentO,
  title={Comment on "Evidence for Neutrinoless Double Beta Decay"},
  author={Craig E. Aalseth and F. T. Iii Avignone and Alexander Barabash and Felix Boehm and Ronald L. Brodzinski and J. I. Collar and Peter J. Doe and Hiroyasu Ejiri and Stephen R. Elliott and Ettore Fiorini and R. J. Gaitskell and Giorgio Gratta and Ryuta Hazama and Kareem Kazkaz and George S. King and Richard T. Kouzes and Harry S. Miley and Michael Moe and {\'A}ngel Morales and J. Perez Morales and Andreas Piepke and R. G. Hamish Robertson and Werner Tornow and Petr Vogel and R. A. Warner and John F. Wilkerson},
  journal={Modern Physics Letters A},
  year={2002},
  volume={17},
  pages={1475-1478}
}
We comment on the recent claim for the experimental observation of neutrinoless double-beta decay. We discuss several limitations in the analysis provided in that paper and conclude that there is no basis for the presented claim. 

Tables from this paper

EXPERIMENTS FOR NEUTRINOLESS DOUBLE-BETA DECAY
The recent neutrino oscillation experimental results indicate that at least one neutrino has a mass greater than 50 meV. The next generation of double-beta decay experiments will very likely have a
Double beta decay: experiments
The results obtained so far and those of the running experiments on neutrinoless double beta decay are reviewed. The plans for second generation experiments, the techniques to be adopted and the
CONSTRAINTS FROM NEUTRINOLESS DOUBLE BETA DECAY
We examine the constraints from the recent HEIDELBERG–MOSCOW double beta decay experiment. It leads us to the almost degenerate or inverse hierarchy neutrino mass scenario. In this scenario, we
Neutrino Oscillation Physics at Neutrino Factories and Beta Beams
We analyze the potential of the dedicated future neutrino long baseline experiment scenarios of neutino factories and beta beams to observe three-flavor effects in neutrino oscillations and measure
Phenomenological and cosmological implications of neutrino oscillations
I discuss the implications of neutrino oscillations for neutrino mass patterns and mass matrices, and for neutrinoless double beta decay. I then go on to discuss the implications for cosmological
2 The Two-Minute Review
We update our recent didactic survey of neutrino physics, including new results from the Sudbury Neutrino Observatory and KamLAND experiments, and recent constraints from WMAP and other cosmological
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-3 OF 3 REFERENCES
EVIDENCE FOR NEUTRINOLESS DOUBLE BETA DECAY
The data of the Heidelberg–Moscow double beta decay experiment for the measuring period August 1990–May 2000 (54.9813 kg y or 723.44 molyears), published recently, are analyzed using the potential of
Latest results from the HEIDELBERG-MOSCOW double beta decay experiment
Abstract:New results for the double beta decay of 76Ge are presented. They are extracted from data obtained with the HEIDELBERG-MOSCOW experiment, which operates five enriched 76Ge detectors in an
Isotopes, edited by V.S
  • Eur. Phys. J. A12
  • 2001