Comment: Understanding Simpson’s Paradox

@article{Pearl2014CommentUS,
  title={Comment: Understanding Simpson’s Paradox},
  author={Judea Pearl},
  journal={Probabilistic and Causal Inference},
  year={2014}
}
  • J. Pearl
  • Published 2 January 2014
  • Philosophy
  • Probabilistic and Causal Inference
I thank the editor, Ronald Christensen, for the opportunity to discuss this important topic and to comment on the article by Armistead. Simpson’s paradox is often presented as a compelling demonstration of why we need statistics education in our schools. It is a reminder of how easy it is to fall into a web of paradoxical conclusions when relying solely on intuition, unaided by rigorous statistical methods. In recent years, ironically, the paradox assumed an added dimension when educators began… 
On Simpson’s paradox: To remain or not to remain a population-based science
In this article, I critically reflect on J. F. Arocha’s (2021) contention that psychologists need to use methods and tools that are suitable for data analysis at the individual level. First, I
Revisiting Simpson ’ s Paradox : statistically warranted vs . unwarranted inference results
The primary objective of this paper is to revisit Simpson’s paradox using a statistical misspecification perspective. It is argued that the reversal of statistical associations is sometimes spurious,
Yule–Simpson’s paradox: the probabilistic versus the empirical conundrum
The current literature views Simpson’s paradox as a probabilistic conundrum by taking the premises (probabilities/parameters/ frequencies) as known. In such a context, it is shown that the paradox
Truths about Simpson's Paradox: Saving the Paradox from Falsity
TLDR
It is argued that there are no causal factors at play in answering questions (i) and (ii) of Simpson's paradox, becauseCausality enters only in connection with action.
The Trouble With Binaries: A Perspective on the Science of Reading
In this article, we critique the science of reading when it is positioned within the reading wars as settling disagreements about reading and how it should be taught. We frame our argument in terms
“Click!” Bait for Causalists
Causalists and Evidentialists can agree about the right course of action in an (apparent) Newcomb problem, if the causal facts are not as initially they seem. If declining $1,000 causes the Predictor
Misunderstood and Unattributed: Revisiting M. H. Doolittle's Measures of Association, With a Note on Bayes’ Theorem
In the 1880s, American scholars developed measures of association and chance for cross-classification tables that anticipated the more widely known work of Galton, Pearson, Yule, and Fisher. Three of
Quantitative Aspects of Simpson’s Paradox
Simpson’s Paradox has received a lot of attention in the contemporary literature. Typically, these presentations focus only on the qualitative structure of the phenomenon, and various explanations of
Simpson’s Paradox in LGBTQ+ Policy: a Case Study
Introduction Simpson’s paradox occurs when trends found in the underlying data disappear or are reversed when groups are aggregated. Because reported data are used to guide policymaking,
Simpson's paradox, a tale of causality
For the mathematically wary and unwary alike, Simpson's paradox may well function as a permanent invitation to error. We present Simpson's paradox and discuss its nature based on three examples. It
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 36 REFERENCES
The Simpson's paradox unraveled.
TLDR
It is shown how the paradox disappears when the statistical analysis is appropriately guided by subject-matter knowledge and the problem is stripped of its causal context and analyzed merely in statistical terms.
Comment: Graphical Models, Causality and Intervention
TLDR
I will focus on the connection between graphical models and the notion of causality in statistical analysis, and supplement the discussion with an ac'count of how causal models and graphical models are related.
An Introduction to Logic and Scientific Method
THIS book, by two American teachers of philosophy, helps to show how far the best representatives of logic in modern universities have travelled from the Aristotelian tradition which formerly
All of Statistics
TLDR
The first € price and the £ and $ price are net prices, subject to local VAT, and the €(D) includes 7% for Germany, the€(A) includes 10% for Austria.
On Simpson's Paradox and the Sure-Thing Principle
Abstract This paradox is the possibility of P(A|B) <P(A|B') even though P(A|B)≥P(A| B') both under the additional condition C and under the complement C' of that condition. Details are given on why
Discrete Multivariate Analysis: Theory and Practice
TLDR
Discrete Multivariate Analysis is a comprehensive text and general reference on the analysis of discrete multivariate data, particularly in the form of multidimensional tables, and contains a wealth of material on important topics.
Conditioning and Intervening
We consider the dispute between causal decision theorists and evidential decision theorists over Newcomb-like problems. We introduce a framework relating causation and directed graphs developed by
Identification, Inference and Sensitivity Analysis for Causal Mediation Effects
Causal mediation analysis is routinely conducted by applied researchers in a variety of disciplines. The goal of such an analysis is to investigate alternative causal mechanisms by examining the
NOTES ON THE THEORY OF ASSOCIATION OF ATTRIBUTES IN STATISTICS
THE simplest possible form of statistical classification is "division" (as the logicians term it) "by dichotomy," i.e. the sorting of the objects or individuals observed into one or other of two
Interpretation and Identification of Causal Mediation
  • J. Pearl
  • Psychology
    Psychological methods
  • 2014
TLDR
It is shown that natural effects can be identified by methods that go beyond standard adjustment for confounders, applicable to observational studies in which treatment assignment remains confounded with the mediator or with the outcome.
...
...