Command Hallucinations: Who Obeys and Who Resists When?

  title={Command Hallucinations: Who Obeys and Who Resists When?},
  author={Ralf Erkwoh and Klaus Willmes and A. Eming-Erdmann and Hanns J{\"u}rgen Kunert},
  pages={272 - 279}
The impact of auditory command hallucinations on the behaviour of schizophrenic patients sometimes appears to be unpredictable. In order to tackle this problem, the psychopathological characteristics of command hallucinations in 31 schizophrenic patients were assessed using a 24-item questionnaire. Using binary data and relative risk analysis methods, predictors were determined for obeying or resisting command hallucinations. Characteristics of voices and the attitude toward the voices appear… 

Tables from this paper

Command Hallucinations and Violence: Implications for Detention and Treatment
The evidence for the association between CHs and violence and the factors found to be associated with compliance with CHs are reviewed and a new psychological intervention is proposed — Treatment for Resistant Command Hallucinations (TORCH).
Acting on Harmful Command Hallucinations in Psychotic Disorders: An Integrative Approach
The findings suggest that compliance with harmful commands is driven by a complex interaction between beliefs related to the command hallucination and personal characteristics, with risk of compliance increasing with age.
Responding to command hallucinations to harm: the unpleasant voices scale and harm command safety protocol.
The implementation of the Harm Command Safety Protocol and the Unpleasant Voices Scale to respond to command hallucinations to harm in the context of the dissemination of a multisite, evidence-based behavioral management course for patients with auditory hallucinations is described.
Hallucinations: The Science of Idiosyncratic Perception
This book review the latest research on the cognitive and neural bases of hallucinations and outline their unique neurobiology by drawing on evidence from brain imaging and neurotransmission studies to put forward a comprehensive, multicomponent model of hallucinations.
Responding to Command Hallucinations to Harm Self and Others: The Unpleasant Voices Scale and Harm Command Safety Protocol
The implementation of the Harm Command Safety Protocol and the Unpleasant Voices Scale to respond to command hallucinations to harm in the context of the dissemination of a multisite, evidence-based behavioral management course for patients with auditory hallucinations is described.
The relationship between command hallucinations and factors of compliance: A critical review of the literature
Abstract Within the context of the general debate regarding mental illness and violence, clinicians are often asked to provide a professional judgement regarding the risk posed by patient reports of
Auditory hallucinations.
  • J. Blom
  • Psychology, Medicine
    Handbook of clinical neurology
  • 2015
Behavioral management of command hallucinations to harm in schizophrenia.
People who attended the course perceived it as helpful, and improvement was seen in all seven characteristics of auditory hallucinations, intensity of auditory hallucination, and anxiety and depression immediately after the course and 1-year post-course.
The usefulness of a self-report questionnaire measuring auditory verbal hallucinations


The clinical significance of command hallucinations.
It is suggested that command hallucinations alone may not imply greater risk for acute, life-threatening behavior, and patients with command hallucinations were not significantly different from patients without commands on demographic and behavioral variables, including suicidal ideation or behavior and assaultiveness.
The clinical presentation of command hallucinations in a forensic population.
The group with command hallucinations differed in the content of their hallucinations (more aggression, dependency, and self-punishment themes), and nearly one-half did not report or denied their command hallucinations to the assessment team.
The auditory hallucination: a phenomenological survey.
A pattern emerged of increasing complexity of the auditory-verbal hallucination over time by a process of accretion, with the addition of more voices and extended dialogues, and more intimacy between subject and voice, which seemed to relate to the lessening of distress and improved coping.
Clinical characteristics of auditory hallucinations
This finding supports the hypothesis that the concept of auditory hallucinations represents many aspects of patients’ hallucinatory experiences, which are relatively independent of one another.
Command hallucinations in outpatients with schizophrenia.
Although command hallucinations may be more frequent than clinicians generally note, in most cases they have minimal influence on the outcome of schizophrenia, and in outpatients with schizophrenia who have a history of suicide attempts, suicidal command hallucinations should be taken seriously.
The Effects of Varying Auditory Input on Schizophrenic Hallucinations
Findings were broadly consistent with predictions, indicating that it is not stimulation per se, but rather the extent to which structure is present and attended to, that is important in determining the occurrence of hallucinatory phenomena.
Predicting compliance with command hallucinations.
  • J. Junginger
  • Psychology, Medicine
    The American journal of psychiatry
  • 1990
Of 44 patients who experienced command hallucinations, those with hallucination-related delusions and hallucinatory voices they could identify were more likely to comply with the commands. The danger
Self‐Report of the Frequency and Phenomenology of Verbal Hallucinations
This study was an assessment of several parameters of verbal hallucinations (“voices”) based on the self-report of 52 hallucinating psychiatric patients, showing that the reliability of the subjects' estimates on the parameters differed greatly.
Reality monitoring and psychotic hallucinations.
Hallucinating psychiatric patients, patients with delusions but without a history of hallucinations and normal controls were compared on a reality-monitoring task in which they were first required to
Is chronicity a function of the relationship between the person and the auditory hallucination?
Thirty psychiatric inpatients each rated their relationship with their auditory hallucination using the Structural Analysis of Social Behavior questionnaires which assess partnerships in terms of interpersonal focus, love-hate, and enmeshment-differentiation, suggesting that the relationship with the hallucination may serve an adaptive function.