Collaborative learning through formative peer review: pedagogy, programs and potential

@article{Sndergaard2012CollaborativeLT,
  title={Collaborative learning through formative peer review: pedagogy, programs and potential},
  author={Harald S{\o}ndergaard and Raoul A. Mulder},
  journal={Computer Science Education},
  year={2012},
  volume={22},
  pages={343 - 367}
}
We examine student peer review, with an emphasis on formative practice and collaborative learning, rather than peer grading. Opportunities to engage students in such formative peer assessment are growing, as a range of online tools become available to manage and simplify the process of administering student peer review. We consider whether pedagogical requirements for student peer review are likely to be discipline-specific, taking computer science and software engineering as an example. We… 
View on Taylor & Francis
wikidata.org
72 Citations
Highly Influential Citations
8
Background Citations
38
Methods Citations
9
Results Citations
1

72 Citations

Reflection on peer reviewing as a pedagogical tool in higher education

Previous research has emphasized both the importance of giving and receiving peer feedback for the purpose of active learning, as well as of university students’ engagement in reflection to improve…

Good practices to influence engagement and learning outcomes on a traditional introductory programming course

TLDR
An improved system based on the received evaluations of a previously developed web-based programming-assisted environment automatically manages the peer code review process and delivers feedback to peers in a manner that favours the incremental learning of the concepts presented throughout the course.

Anonymous Online Peer Review for Innovation-Based Learning

TLDR
A distributed, scalable, student-driven method to provide timely, nuanced, unbiased, and personalized feedback to students learning in diverse self-defined project teams is presented and peer review effectiveness is evaluated.

Analysing Usability and UX in Peer Review Tools

TLDR
This paper presents perspectives from professors and students about aspects of User Experience (UX) on two collaborative tools that support Peer Review: The Moodle Assessment Laboratory ( MoodlePRLab ) and Model2Review .

Peer Assessment in Engineering Group Projects: A Literature Survey

TLDR
Opportunities and challenges in applying peer assessment in a project-based creative engineering program are presented based on the review of the literature.

Gamification of student peer review in education: A systematic literature review

TLDR
It is found that artifact assessment and artifact creation are the two most commonly gamified actions with respect to the peer review model and that the quantity and quality of both the artifacts and the generated feedback are the most popular reward criteria.

A Two-Dimensional Typology for Characterizing Student Peer and Instruc- tor Feedback in Capstone Design Project Courses

This work in progress describes a study that is being conducted in a management engineering capstone design series of courses at a large Canadian university. The courses utilize a design review…

Formative assessment diversity to foster students engagement

Students learning can be tremendously affected by the way they will be assessed. Traditionally, teachers relied on summative (final) exams, however the use of other form of assessments, namely…

THROUGH THE LENS OF THE REVIEWER: INFORMATION LITERACY, AN LMS, AND PEER REVIEW

TLDR
This research paper describes the use of peer review to improve information literacy and investigates peer review activities for linear relationships to that of a perceived social element inclusion, changes in learning from the perspective of the reviewer rather than the receiver of feedback, and improvement in perceived information literacy.

Development of a Web Platform for Code Peer-Testing

TLDR
This paper reports on the development of a Web platform for peer feedback on programming artifacts through program testing and discusses the development process of the peer-testing platform informed by teachers and students.
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 66 REFERENCES

Learning from and with peers: the different roles of student peer reviewing

TLDR
This paper lays out the pedagogical philosophy behind my own use of student peer reviews, and my experience using PRAZE, an online tool for student peer reviewing, as well as students' response to the tool and its use.

Using peer review as a vehicle for communication skill development and active learning

There is a renewed interest in incorporating peer review activities into computer science courses in response to current interest in active learning and group projects. The peer review process models…

From peer assessment towards collaborative learning

  • S. Trahasch
  • Computer Science
    34th Annual Frontiers in Education, 2004. FIE 2004.
  • 2004
TLDR
This work has implemented a peer assessment application for review and discussion of artifacts, new that students use presentation recording tools to create personal presentations and it is possible to use these continuous documents for peer assessment.

Peer Assessment Between Students in Colleges and Universities

A definition and typology of peer assessment between students in higher education is proposed, and the theoretical underpinnings of the method are discussed. A review of the developing literature…

Peer feedback: the learning element of peer assessment

This paper focuses on peer feedback in relation to assessment processes. It examines the rationale for peer feedback, emphasizing its potential for enhanced student learning. We draw on relevant…

Electronic peer review: a large cohort teaching themselves?

[Abstract]: Electronic peer review can empower lecturers of large courses to produce rapid feedback, promote social interaction and encourage higher order learning for students. But what are the…

Contribution-oriented pedagogy.

TLDR
A contribution-oriented pedagogical approach in which students find, create, submit, and/or share resources using a Web-based course-support environment is identified as a model that is particularly valuable for forms of distance and computer-based learning.

A systematic review of tools that support peer assessment

TLDR
The tools that support peer assessment are reviewed and analysed, revealing the common features and significant differences.

Unravelling peer assessment: Methodological, functional, and conceptual developments

Scaffolded writing and rewriting in the discipline: A web-based reciprocal peer review system

...