Collaboration Both Hurts and Helps Memory

@article{Rajaram2011CollaborationBH,
  title={Collaboration Both Hurts and Helps Memory},
  author={Suparna Rajaram},
  journal={Current Directions in Psychological Science},
  year={2011},
  volume={20},
  pages={76 - 81}
}
  • S. Rajaram
  • Published 1 April 2011
  • Psychology
  • Current Directions in Psychological Science
Humans spend a majority of their lives in a social context. So historically, several disciplines have pursued a study of the social aspects of memory. Yet, research on memory in cognitive psychology has, for more than a century, concentrated mainly on individuals working in isolation. A recent shift in this orientation has led to a rapid growth in cognitive research revealing both counterintuitive and complex effects of collaboration on learning and remembering. For example, despite subjective… 

Figures from this paper

Collaborative Inhibition in Group Recall: Cognitive Principles and Implications
Until the 1990s, cognitive research on memory focused largely on the individual and thrived on paradigms inspired by the Ebbinghausian tradition. For about a century until then (Ebbinghaus, 1885),
Learning and Remembering with Others: The Key Role of Retrieval in Shaping Group Recall and Collective Memory.
TLDR
Collaboration impaired the group recall product at both time points, but especially so at retrieval, and only collaborative retrieval played a significant role in the formation of collective memories.
Transactive Memory in Small, Intimate Groups: More Than the Sum of Their Parts
Thirty years after social psychologist, Daniel Wegner, pitched a new approach to the study of individual and group behavior, his theory of transactive memory has inspired rich literatures on the
The Effect of Affect on Group Memory
Memory typically improves when recollecting in a group the larger the group, the better the memory (McClure 2010; Atkinson 2011). High arousal at the time of encoding also improves memory (Bohannon,
Collaboration changes both the content and the structure of memory: Building the architecture of shared representations.
TLDR
It is observed that as the size of the collaborative inhibition effect-a counterintuitive finding that collaboration reduces group recall-increased, so did the amount of shared memory and the shared organization of memories.
Disrupters as Well as Monitors: Roles of Others During and After Collaborative Remembering in the DRM Procedure
TLDR
The novel implication of the current study is that it reveals the sensitivity of collaborative inhibition and error pruning in DRM lists to testing conditions and demonstrates that the modulation of collaboration on false memory occurs in the same way both during and after collaboration.
Collaborative remembering revisited: Study context access modulates collaborative inhibition and later benefits for individual memory
TLDR
A critical role of access to study context at test for collaborative inhibition is demonstrated, indicating that impaired context access may reflect a general boundary condition for the recall impairment.
eaping what they sow : Benefits of remembering together in intimate ouples
Recent research suggests that remembering with a long-term partner may scaffold successful memory. To test whether collaboration reduces the episodic deficit shown by older adults, we created a
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 33 REFERENCES
Collaborative Memory: Cognitive Research and Theory
TLDR
The cognitive components of this complex phenomenon are elucidated and an overarching theoretical framework that specifies the cognitive mechanisms associated with the costs and benefits of collaboration on memory is proposed.
Social Memory Processes
Towards a psychology of collective memory
TLDR
The place of psychology within the now voluminous social scientific literature on collective memory is discussed, distinguishing between the design of social resources and memory practices, on one hand, and on the other, the effectiveness of each in forming and transforming the memories held by individuals and the psychological mechanisms that guide this effectiveness.
Collective memory: collaborative and individual processes in remembering.
TLDR
There was evidence that the collaborative groups tended to rely on the best individual to a greater extent in story than in list recall, and group recall appeared to be more stable over time than individual recall.
Collaboration can improve individual recognition memory: Evidence from immediate and delayed tests
TLDR
Findings show that consensus is not necessary for producing benefits of collaboration on individual recognition, collaborative facilitation on individual memory is robust, and collaboration enhances individual memory further if conditions predispose individual accuracy in the absence of collaboration.
Collaborative remembering in older adults: age-invariant outcomes in the context of episodic recall deficits.
TLDR
Despite older adults recalling less overall than young adults, both age groups exhibited similar costs and benefits of collaboration: Collaboration reduced both correct and false recall during collaborative remembering, and was associated with more positive beliefs about its value.
Communication, Learning, and Retrieval in Transactive Memory Systems☆☆☆
A laboratory experiment examined the impact of communication during learning and during recall on collective recall. Dating couples and dyads of strangers worked together to learn and later recall
When two is too many: Collaborative encoding impairs memory
TLDR
The collaborative-encoding deficit is robust in nature and likely occurs because collaborative encoding produces less effective cues for later retrieval.
Group remembering: does social loafing underlie collaborative inhibition?
TLDR
Examination of the role of motivational factors by varying monetary incentives, recall criterion, personal accountability, group cohesion, and group gender suggests that collaboration interferes with an individual's ability to reconstruct his or her knowledge.
Collective memory: A perspective from (experimental) clinical psychology
TLDR
It is argued that a factual focus induced by collaborative remembering may be beneficial to natural recovery in the immediate aftermath of trauma, and proposed that shared remembering techniques may provide a useful addition to the treatment of post-traumatic stress disorder.
...
...