Coleman Revisited

  title={Coleman Revisited},
  author={Pat Rubio Goldsmith},
  journal={American Educational Research Journal},
  pages={508 - 535}
  • P. Goldsmith
  • Published 1 June 2011
  • Education, Law
  • American Educational Research Journal
Students from minority segregated schools tend to achieve and attain less than similar students from White segregated schools. This study examines whether peer effects can explain this relationship using normative models and frog-pond models. Normative models (where peers become alike) suggest that minority schoolmates are a liability. Frog-pond models (where students benefit from recognition) suggest that minority schoolmates are an asset. Data from the National Educational Longitudinal Study… 

Figures and Tables from this paper

The Right Fit? Classroom Mismatch in Middle School and Its Inconsistent Effect on Student Learning

Research on college admissions shows that all students tend to benefit from overmatching, but high-status students are most likely to be overmatched, and low-status students are most likely to be

Does the Peer Group Matter? Assessing Frog Pond Effects in Transition to Secondary Schooling

  • P. Skov
  • Education
    Socius: Sociological Research for a Dynamic World
  • 2022
Peers are considered important for adolescents’ educational achievement and attainment, though little conclusive evidence demonstrate peer comparison effects. Using school and year fixed-effects

Opportunity Seeking Across Segregated Schools: Unintended Effects of Automatic Admission Policies on High School Segregation

Automatic admissions policies (AAPs, “percent plans”) redistribute college-going opportunities across segregated high schools to diversify college enrollments, increasing opportunities at

Educational Expectations among Immigrant Youth: Links to Segmented Assimilation and School Context

Although schools are important socialization venues for all children, they also serve as sites of acculturation for immigrant youth. According to segmented assimilation theory, first- and

Narrowing Down the Determinants of Between-School Segregation: An Analysis of the Intake to All Schools in England, 1989–2011

This article describes the social and economic “segregation” of students between schools in England, and the likely causes of its levels and changes over time. It involves a re-analysis of the

Unfulfilled Potential: High-Achieving Minority Students and the High School Achievement Gap in Math

Abstract: This study uses multilevel modeling to examine a subset of the highest performing 9th graders and explores the extent that achievement gaps in math widen for high performing African

Racial Segregation and the Black/White Achievement Gap, 1992 to 2009

In this study, we draw on longitudinal, state-level data to analyze the impact of four distinct forms of school racial segregation on black/white achievement gaps in math and reading. Pooled

Distributive Justice Antecedents of Race and Gender Disparities in First-Year College Performance

Public education is a sphere of society in which distributive justice with respect to the allocation of opportunities to learn can have profound and lasting effects on students’ educational outcomes.

The Role of Desegregation and Teachers of Color in Discipline Disproportionality

Scholars note the multitude of ways that the continual shifts in the racial composition of schools affect students, but fewer studies consider the implications of such shifts for teachers. This study

The association between school climate and school discipline policies and practices in Rhode Island public schools

Exclusionary discipline practices are associated with a range of negative student outcomes, both academic and behavioral, as well as a higher likelihood of later school drop-out and involvement in



Schools' Racial Mix, Students' Optimism, and the Black-White and Latino-White Achievement Gaps

This article examines how schools' racial and ethnic mix of students and teachers influences black, white, and Latino students' occupational expectations, educational aspirations, and concrete

The Winner-Take-All High School: Organizational Adaptations to Educational Stratification

Across the United States, families seek schools with reputations for academic excellence for their children, assuming that such schools improve a talented child’s prospects for college admission.

Schools or Neighborhoods or Both?: Race and Ethnic Segregation and Educational Attainment

Whites, blacks and Latinos in the United States tend to live in different neighborhoods and attend different schools. Does this segregation influence youth in the long run? This study used

Peer Effects in the Classroom: Learning from Gender and Race Variation

Peer effects are potentially important for understanding the optimal organization of schools, jobs, and neighborhoods, but finding evidence is difficult because people are selected into peer groups

Race, Racial Concentration, and the Dynamics of Educational Inequality Across Urban and Suburban Schools

This study uses national data from the National Educational Longitudinal Study to model educational inequality as a feedback process among course placement, student engagement, and academic

Interpreting Community Effects on Youth Educational Attainment

Longitudinal data from 1,128 respondents in the National Survey of Children are used to examine factors that help explain the higher rates of school dropout and lower rates of high school graduation

Social Class, School and Non-School Environments, and Black/White Inequalities in Children's Learning

As social and economic stratification between black and white Americans persists at the dawn of the twenty-first century, disparities in educational outcomes remain an especially formidable barrier.

Does Segregation Still Matter? The Impact of Student Composition on Academic Achievement in High School

The Coleman report, published 12 years after the Brown decision, confirmed that widespread school segregation in the United States created inequality of educational opportunity. This study examines

Family structure, schoolmates, and racial inequalities in school achievement

This study examines the influence of schoolmate family structure, racial concentration, and socioeconomic status on the academic achievement of individual African American and White students. The

Majority African American Schools and Social Injustice: The Influence of De Facto Segregation on Academic Achievement

The research reported here proceeds on the premise that if minority race and its predominance in particular schools constitutes a disadvantage in the educational system, then members of the