Clausewitz and the “New Wars” Scholars

@article{Schuurman2010ClausewitzAT,
  title={Clausewitz and the “New Wars” Scholars},
  author={Bart Schuurman},
  journal={The US Army War College Quarterly: Parameters},
  year={2010}
}
  • B. Schuurman
  • Published 1 March 2010
  • Political Science
  • The US Army War College Quarterly: Parameters
Since the Second World War, western armed forces have been most successful against opponents whose weapons, methods of organization, and ways of thinking closely resembled their own. Conflicts such as Israel's Six-Day War (1967) and the first Gulf War (1991) exemplified western militaries' excellence at defeating those adversaries who closely matched their own capabilities. The collapse of the Soviet Union in the early 1990s seemed to underline the West's military, economic, and ideological… 

‘New Wars’ Fought ‘Amongst the People’: ‘Transformed’ by Old Realities?

Despite George MacDonald Fraser’s cogent observation, fierce debate regularly complements significant periods of historical change; often proposing, inter alia, the unprecedented transformation not

At war with social theory: Instrumental and communicative action in US military doctrine during the War on Terror

As US counterinsurgency campaigns draw to a close, doctrine for asymmetric warfare written during the War on Terror has come under heavy criticism. While many have argued that this shift to ‘winning

The New War Thesis and Clausewitz: A Reconciliation

  • B. Banta
  • Political Science
    Global Policy
  • 2019
Mary Kaldor’s work constitutes an exceptionally sustained, cohesive, and also broadly aimed argument for often radical – and generally cosmopolitan – changes to state’s approaches to security.

An Alternative War: The Development, Impact, and Legality of Hybrid Warfare Conducted by the Nation State

The alleged use of “Hybrid Warfare” by the Russian Federation in the annexation of the Ukrainian territory, Crimea, in 2014, thrust the term into the media spotlight and raised concerns over the lack

The Cyber Military Revolution and the Need for a New Framework of War

Abstract : The introduction of the cyber domain has fostered massive and profound changes in all aspects of society. Cyber technology has completely restructured the methods and manners of

Civilizational Dynamics of "Hybrid Warfare"

Since the end of the Cold War, analysts have struggled to make sense of the proliferation of smaller scale conflicts. Several labels have been used to describe this phenomenon, the most recent being

Counterinsurgency: Exposing the Myths of the New Way of War

1. A 'happy combination of clemency with firmness'. The small wars prologue 2. The road from Sedan 3. The paroxysms of imperial might in the shadow of the Great War 4. From Tipperary to Tel Aviv:

THE NATURE OF WAR–UNCHANGING IN THE FACE OF SHIFTING FORMS AND MATERIAL DIMENSIONS

  • Political Science
  • 2020
The essay comprises two central arguments—first, the fundamental concepts of war have endured and are still applicable today; and second, the way in which wars are being conducted is constantly

In Defence of New Wars

This article reviews the literature on ‘new wars’. It argues that ‘new wars’ should be understood not as an empirical category but rather as a way of elucidating the logic of contemporary war that

Should the Changing Character of War Affect Our Theories of War?

War has changed so much that it barely resembles the paradigmatic cases of armed conflict that just war theories and international humanitarian law seemed to have had in mind even a few decades ago.

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 26 REFERENCES

Elegant irrelevance revisited: A critique of fourth-generation warfare

Since the end of the Cold War, a school of military theory has emerged that argues that non-state, low-intensity conflict represents the future of war. This new school rejects the salience of

Busting the Icon. Restoring Balance to the Influence of Clausewitz

Abstract : Many US military thinkers and practitioners have embraced a view of war that is out of touch with current circumstances--and, consequently, dangerous. This has a direct effect on the

The ‘New Wars’ Debate: A Historical Perspective is Needed

In recent years, a number of analysts have argued that qualitative changes have occurred in the nature of violent conflict and that it is now possible to think in terms of ‘new wars’ that are

Strategic Theory and the History of War

1 This essay surveys the development of strategic theory from its emergence in the seventeenth century through the era of the world wars. Although the focus is on ideas, some account is taken of

War evolves into the fourth generation: A comment on Thomas X. Hammes

Posing the most serious challenge to international security today, fourth-generation warfare (4GW) uses all available networks – political, economic, social and military – to convince the enemy's

War evolves into the fourth generation

Posing the most serious challenge to international security today, fourth-generation warfare (4GW) uses all available networks – political, economic, social and military – to convince the enemy's

Historical Perspectives on Future War

THINKING DEEPLY about the future of war requires careful reflection on its past. A paradox? Certainly. B.H. Liddell Hart likened the opposing pull of science and history in forecasting the role of

Reclaiming the Clausewitzian Trinity

Abstract : In a recent Parameters article, "US Military Doctrine and the Revolution in Military Affairs" (Autumn 1994), Dr. David Jablonsky made frequent reference to the theories of Carl von

Resurrecting the "Icon" The Enduring Relevance of Clausewitz's On War

Abstract : For students of strategy, Carl von Clausewitz has long been a polarizing figure. Notwithstanding their rather different interpretations of "On War," soldiers, statesmen, and scholars such

A cosmopolitan response to new wars

Some have argued that the post‐Cold War period has been much more unstable or violent than what came before. Certainly the number of wars has increased in the 1980s and 1990s, especially in Europe