Classification, Detection and Consequences of Data Error: Evidence from the Human Development Index

@article{Wolff2010ClassificationDA,
  title={Classification, Detection and Consequences of Data Error: Evidence from the Human Development Index},
  author={Hendrik Wolff and Howard Chong and Maximilian Auffhammer},
  journal={Wiley-Blackwell: Economic Journal},
  year={2010}
}
We measure and examine data error in health, education and income statistics used to construct the Human Development Index. We identify three sources of data error which are due to (i) data updating, (ii) formula revisions and (iii) thresholds to classify a country's development status. We propose a simple statistical framework to calculate country specific measures of data uncertainty and investigate how data error biases rank assignments. We find that up to 34% of countries are misclassified… Expand
View on SSRN
ecommons.cornell.edu
111 Citations
Highly Influential Citations
9
Background Citations
32
Methods Citations
9

Topics from this paper

      111 Citations

      Citation Type

      Citation Type

      Classifying Human Development with Latent Class Analysis
      We use latent class analysis to create an indicator of human development that integrates a broad range of country characteristics including per capita income, health, inequality, environmental… Expand
      The Quality of Growth
      We use latent class analysis to categorize development experiences. This technique allows us to consider a broad range of country characteristics including per capita income growth, health,… Expand
      Using Spatial Factor Analysis to Measure Human Development
      We propose a Bayesian factor analysis model as an alternative to the Human Development Index (HDI). Our model provides methodology which can either augment or build additional indices. In addition to… Expand
      Multidimensional Poverty Measurement and Analysis: Chapter 8 – Robustness Analysis and Statistical Inference
      TLDR
      This chapter shows how to apply dominance and rank robustness tests to assess comparisons as poverty cutoffs and other parameters changes, and presents ingredients of statistical inference, including standard errors, confidence intervals, and hypothesis tests. Expand
      The Analysis of Human Development Index (HDI) for Categorizing the Member States of the United Nations (UN)
      To categorize the nations to reflect the development status, to date, there are many conceptual frameworks. The Human Development index (HDI) that is published by the United Nations Development… Expand
      Measurement Error in Macroeconomic Data and Economics Research: Data Revisions, Gross Domestic Product, and Gross Domestic Income
      We use a preanalysis plan to analyze the effect of measurement error on economics research using the fact that the Bureau of Economic Analysis both revises its gross domestic product (GDP) data and… Expand
      How robust are composite indicators? An almost certain stochastic simulation approach
      Stochastic techniques such as Monte Carlo simulations are widely used to investigate complex empirical problems. In particular, they can be used to quantify the sensitivity of composite indicators to… Expand
      HDI: The Old, the New and the Elegant
      TLDR
      This paper evaluates three aggregation methods of computing HDI using a set of axioms and proposes an alternative measure, where HDI is the additive inverse of the distance from the ideal. Expand
      Making Data Measurement Errors Transparent: The Case of the IMF
      In 1950 Morgenstern pointed out that absolute precision and certainty are impossible in economic observations, but estimates are often hampered by a substantial degree of measurement error. Unlike… Expand
      Assessing the Effects of Various Socio-Economic and Health Indicators on HDI Country Categories
      The human development indicator (HDI) is based on three indicators: standard of living, life expectancy, and education level. Although being widely known and commonly used, the accuracy of the HDI… Expand
      ...
      1
      2
      3
      4
      5
      ...

      References

      SHOWING 1-10 OF 128 REFERENCES
      Disease and Development: The Effect of Life Expectancy on Economic Growth
      We exploit the major international health improvements from the 1940s to estimate the effect of life expectancy on economic performance. We construct predicted mortality using preintervention… Expand
      The Human Development Index: "Handle with Care"
      ECONOMISTS AND POLICYMAKERS have long questioned the emphasis on growth of gross national product per capita (GNP/N) as the singular goal and measure of national development. GNP/N fails to capture… Expand
      The human development index: some technical issues and alternative indices
      This paper examines the components and structure of the UNDP's Human Development Index and briefly reviews the criticisms of this index in the literature. It suggests some improvements on the… Expand
      Human Capital in Growth Regressions: How Much Difference Does Data Quality Make?
      We construct a revised version of the Barro and Lee (1996) data set for a sample of OECD countries using previously unexploited sources and following a heuristic approach to obtain plausible time… Expand
      The Human Development Index: Yet Another Redundant Composite Development Indicator?
      Abstract In its Human Development Report 1990 , the United Nations Development Program (UNDP) proposes yet another composite indicator of development levels: the “human development index” (HDI). The… Expand
      International Data on Educational Attainment Updates and Implications
      This paper presents a data set that improves the measurement of educational attainment for a broad group of countries. We extend our previous estimates of educational attainment for the population… Expand
      human Development Index
      How many countries are included in the 2013 HDI? The 2013 HDI covers 187 countries, the same number as in 2012 and 2011. Maintaining the same number of is the result of intensified efforts by the… Expand
      An empirical note on inequality in the world development indicators
      A broad range of inequality measures is used to examine inter-country inequality in two highly correlated indicators of development, the per capita real income (Y) and the Human Development Index… Expand
      Measurement of Human Development: an alternative approach
      The quality of life of an individual is standardly regarded as having three dimensions: (i) prospective longevity, (ii) educational attainment and (iii) standard of living. An index of human… Expand
      Human development:Concepts and measurement
      Abstract The Human Development Report (HDR) of the UNDP argues for a new approach to the definition, measurement and achievement of development. This paper traces the intellectual origins of the HDR… Expand
      ...
      1
      2
      3
      4
      5
      ...