Citation analysis and the complex problem of intellectual influence

@article{Zuckerman2005CitationAA,
  title={Citation analysis and the complex problem of intellectual influence},
  author={Harriet Zuckerman},
  journal={Scientometrics},
  year={2005},
  volume={12},
  pages={329-338}
}
  • H. Zuckerman
  • Published 1 November 1987
  • Education
  • Scientometrics
The problem of tracing intellectual influences in the development of science and learning has a long history of much discussion and some investigation, a history that cannot be examined here. But, by way of historical perspective on the "evolving grammar of citation analysis," it is useful to recognize that from its emergence, citation analysis has been just one, hardly the sole procedure, used to trace intellectual influence flowing from designated works in science and scholarship by… 
Citation analysis
TLDR
A critical review of the theories that have formed and/or continue to form the basic assumptions underlying citation analysis and symbolic characteristics of citations, which have attracted a great deal of attention from researchers in information science and other fields.
The intellectual structure and substance of the knowledge utilization field: A longitudinal author co-citation analysis, 1945 to 2004
TLDR
It is concluded that the received view that social science disciplines are in a state where no accepted set of principles or theories guide research could not be supported for this field, and Everett Rogers was the dominant figure in the field and, until the emergence of evidence-based medicine, his representation of the general diffusion model was the dominance paradigm.
The Use of Bibliometrics for Assessing Research: Possibilities, Limitations and Adverse Effects
TLDR
This chapter provides an overview of bibliometric methods, from the development of citation indexing as a tool for information retrieval to its application in research evaluation, and discusses their misuse and effects on researchers’ scholarly communication behavior.
Theories of citation?
TLDR
The specific contexts represented in the modern citation can be deconstructed from the perspective of the cultural evolution of scientific communication.
Towards Mining Intellectual Influence Associations and Developing Efficient Author Representations in Bibliographic Network
TLDR
This work defines proxy scores that attempt to determine the associative bilateral influence of the cited author over the citing author using a diffusion-based influence aggregation approach, and develops an objective approach of evaluating the influence model for the bibliographic dataset.
A Study on the Citation Behavior by Academic Background of Researchers
Although it has been a long subject of study why researchers prefer some cited documents to others, the existing relative researches have had a variety of perspectives on the nature and complexity of
In matters of quantitative studies of science the fault of theorists is offering too little and asking too much
TLDR
It is emphasized that citations should be conceived of as ‘binding properties’ of an individual publication, from which many types of structuring follow, and as there are empirically established relations between the citation domain and the word domain, it is useless to develop a model concerning citations only.
The multilayered nature of reference selection
TLDR
A fresh perspective on a 30-year-old problem by extending the context of the discussion about citation theories with a new perspective, that of the readers, by layers or phases, in the final choice of references, allowing for a new classification in which any paper, to date, could be included.
Chinese Interpreting Studies: a data-driven analysis of a dynamic field of enquiry
TLDR
The findings show that the field is steadily moving forward with new papers continuously being cited, although a number of influential papers stand out, having received a stream of citations in all the years examined.
Mining Intellectual Influence Associations
TLDR
This study defines proxy scores that attempt to determine the associative influence of the cited author over the citing author and generates author vector representations using these influence scores in order to harness structural connectivity of the network.
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 38 REFERENCES
Co-Citation Analyses of Science: An Evaluation
For the past several years, Henry Small and collaborators1 have been arguing strongly on behalf of the utility of a technique called 'co-citation analysis' as a tool for understanding the specialty
MEASURING THE QUALITY OF SOCIOLOGICAL RESEARCH : PROBLEMS IN THE USE OF THE SCIENCE CITATION ZNDEX
The problem of assessing the " quality " of scientific publications has long been a major impediment to progress in the sociology of science. Most researchers have typically paid homage to the belief
A Co-Citation Model of a Scientific Specialty: A Longitudinal Study of Collagen Research
The phenomenon of specialization in science is receiving increasing attention as it becomes clear that the 'specialty' is the principal mode of social and cognitive organization in modern science.
Citation Indexes in Sociological and Historical Research
The use of citation data in the computer construction of historical network diagrams is proposed. A new ‘critical path method’ of evaluating the impact of individual scientific discoveries is
Precise Measurement in the Face of Error: A Comment on MacRoberts and MacRoberts
MacRoberts and MacRoberts have given us a lucid classification of different sources of possible error in the use of citations as an indication of influence. 1 Their paper will without doubt be itself
Some Results on the Function and Quality of Citations
Citations of scientific articles have been used in recent years as measures of scientific accomplishments of an individual, a group, an institution, or a country, as well as for following the
The norms of citation behavior: Prolegomena to the footnote
TLDR
The state of the authors' knowledge is reviewed, questions are raised, and suggestions and hypotheses for studying the relationships between footnoting practices among scientists and the social system of science are proposed.
Patterns of Name Ordering Among Authors of Scientific Papers: A Study of Social Symbolism and Its Ambiguity
With increasing scientific collaboration, visibility of individual role-performance has diminished. Ordering of author's names is an adaptive device which symbolizes their relative contributions to
A re-examination of the Ortega hypothesis: The Dutch case
TLDR
Using data collected for a sample of 69 Dutch physicists, a multivariate approach is employed in order to re-examine the Ortega hypothesis, and eminent scientists are shown to cite other eminent scientists, although not to the extent reported among American physicists in earlier research by theColes.
Methodology in the sociology of science: Some reflections on the study of radio astronomy
The traditional view of methodology in sociology has been relatively simple. Its basic assumptions have been as follows: that empirical data relevant to sociological analysis exists independently of
...
...