Children can solve Bayesian problems: the role of representation in mental computation

@article{Zhu2006ChildrenCS,
  title={Children can solve Bayesian problems: the role of representation in mental computation},
  author={Liqi Zhu and Gerd Gigerenzer},
  journal={Cognition},
  year={2006},
  volume={98},
  pages={287-308}
}
View on Elsevier
pure.mpg.de
147 Citations
Highly Influential Citations
12
Background Citations
70
Methods Citations
19
Results Citations
8

Figures and Tables from this paper

147 Citations

Citation Type

Citation Type

Children’s quantitative Bayesian inferences from natural frequencies and number of chances
Natural frequencies and Bayesian reasoning: the impact of formal education and problem context
TLDR
The results of the four experiments show that natural frequency resulted in much better estimates than probabilities, and the context of a problem influences people’s ability to solve a Bayesian problem.
Comprehension and computation in Bayesian problem solving
TLDR
It is suggested that understanding this task-individual pair could benefit from considerations from the literature on mathematical cognition, which emphasizes text comprehension and problem solving, along with contributions of online executive working memory, metacognitive regulation, and relevant stored knowledge and skills.
The origins of probabilistic inference in human infants
Natural frequencies improve Bayesian reasoning in simple and complex inference tasks
TLDR
This work shows that natural frequencies facilitate Bayesian reasoning in a much broader class of situations than previously thought, and shows that teaching natural frequencies for simple tasks with one dichotomous cue and two hypotheses leads to a transfer of learning to complex tasks with three cue values and two cues.
Children’s understanding of posterior probability
2 Bayesian Reasoning as a Test Case of Probabilistic Thinking
Is the mind an “intuitive statistician”? Or are humans biased and errorprone when it comes to probabilistic thinking? While researchers in the 1950s and 1960s suggested that people reason…
Icon arrays help younger children's proportional reasoning
TLDR
Proportional reasoning abilities correlate with working memory, approximate number system, and subitizing skills, and younger children's proportional reasoning was more accurate when they were presented with icon arrays.
Inductive Inference in Infants and Young Children: The Role of Probabilistic Reasoning
A recent surge of research in cognitive developmental psychology examines whether human learners, from infancy through adulthood, reason in ways consistent with Bayesian inference. However, when…
Numerical representations and intuitions of probabilities at 12 months.
TLDR
It is shown that intuitions of probabilities may derive from the ability to represent a limited number of possibilities, and at early stages of development the mental representations involved in probability estimations of future individual situations are powerful and sophisticated, but at the same time they depend on infants' overall cognitive architecture, being constrained by the numerical representations spontaneously induced by the situations.
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 78 REFERENCES
How to Improve Bayesian Reasoning Without Instruction: Frequency Formats
TLDR
By analyzing several thousand solutions to Bayesian problems, the authors found that when information was presented in frequency formats, statistically naive participants derived up to 50% of all inferences by Bayesian algorithms.
Solving probabilistic and statistical problems: a matter of information structure and question form
Representation facilitates reasoning: what natural frequencies are and what they are not
Children's probability intuitions: understanding the expected value of complex gambles.
TLDR
Functional understanding of probability and expected value in children as young as 5 or 6 is demonstrated, contributing to the growing evidence on children's intuitive reasoning competence.
Frequency versus probability formats in statistical word problems
Individuation, counting, and statistical inference: The role of frequency and whole-object representations in judgment under uncertainty
Evolutionary approaches to judgment under uncertainty have led to new data showing that untutored subject reliably produce judgments that conform to may principles of probability theory when (a) they…
Are humans good intuitive statisticians after all? Rethinking some conclusions from the literature on judgment under uncertainty
Children's construction of fair chances: adjusting probabilities.
TLDR
A probability-adjustment task was presented to 6-14-year-old children, and the results indicate that only at around the age of 13 did most children proportionally integrate the 2 dimensions (i.e., the numbers of winning and losing beads).
Children's judgments of expected value.
Expected value judgments of 5-, 6-, 8-, and 10-year-olds were studied by using an information integration approach. Children saw roulette-type games with prizes of crayons. They made judgments on a…
Simplifying Bayesian Inference: The General Case
TLDR
The concept of Markov frequencies generalizes Gigerenzer & Hoffrageas anatural frequencies, which are known to foster insight in Bayesian situations with one cue, and allow to visualize Bayesian inference problems even with an arbitrary number of cues.
...
...