Charles I: A Case of Mistaken Identity

@article{Kishlansky2005CharlesIA,
  title={Charles I: A Case of Mistaken Identity},
  author={Mark A. Kishlansky},
  journal={Past \& Present},
  year={2005},
  volume={189},
  pages={41 - 80}
}
There is no event in the history of the British monarchy more studied than the downfall of Charles I. It riveted the attention of contemporaries and has fascinated historians ever since. It is one of those deWning historical moments that serve as a prism through which the present sees itself. Sometimes the collapse of the Stuart monarchy has been told as the tale of an ineffectual king, a lesson in the consequences of gripping the reins too loosely.2 At other times, it has been seen as a… 
15 Citations
From Revisionist to Royalist History; or, Was Charles I the First Whig Historian
This essay is intended, in large part, as an homage to Kevin Sharpe and Mark Kishlansky. It locates their work within the course of Revisionist and post-Revisionist scholarship since the 1970s. In so
Debating Britain in Seventeenth-Century Scotland: Multiple Monarchy and Scottish Sovereignty
This article deploys the concept of multiple monarchy as a means of reassessing the constitutional relationship between Scotland and England from the union of the crowns in 1603 to the union of
The Blindness of Charles I
This essay explores the contested reputation of Charles, comparing the judgments of contemporaries and posterity. Whereas apologists considered Charles the best of all monarchs, some historians have
Religion, Political Thought and the English Civil War
Religion has always been central to explanations of the political and ideological causes and course of the English civil war. Where historians once privileged aspects of the conflict that associated
Evil Counsel: The Propositions to Bridle the Impertinency of Parliament and the Critique of Caroline Government in the Late 1620s
I n November 1629, King Charles and his Privy Council discovered a particularly nasty rumor: the council, it was said, had decided to resolve England’s mounting political crisis by altering the
Revisiting the Causes of the English Civil War
This essay offers a critical reassessment of Revisionism from the perspective of a specialist on the later seventeenth century who has recently moved back to work on the early Stuart period. It
CHARLES I, CLEMENT COKE, AND SEDITION*
ABSTRACT Clement Coke was a minor figure of the early Stuart period, especially in comparison to his brilliant and prominent father, Sir Edward Coke. People seem to have taken note of ‘Fighting Clem’
Sir Edward Coke and the Reformation of the Laws: Religion, Politics and Jurisprudence, 1578-1616
1. Introduction 2. Uncertainty and the reformation of the laws 3. 'The most dangerous oppressor': the misuse of the law 4. Confidence and corruption: the law in the Fens 5. Identity and narratives of
The Caroline Court of Wards and Liveries 1625-41
This thesis titled 'The Caroline Court of Wards and Liveries, 1625-41' seeks to contribute towards existing scholarly research into both the Court and early seventeenth century English society. It
The Arts of Witnessing
Abstract The essay examines Archbishop Laud’s prison diaries and scaffold sermon in relation to post-Foxean martyrology. In Laud’s writings one sees a distinctive theological stance reworking a
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 68 REFERENCES
The Legal Status of the Petition of Right
  • L. Reeve
  • History
    The Historical Journal
  • 1986
One hundred years ago the most scholarly of the whig historians, Samuel Rawson Gardiner, gave the Petition of Right a leading place in his interpretation of early Stuart England, as the beginning of
The Personal Rule of Charles I
The period of government without parliaments from 1629 to 1640, variously described as the ‘eleven years tyranny’ and ‘The Personal Rule of Charles I’, has been little studied (at least as far as the
Power Struggle, Parliament, and Liberty in Early Stuart England
  • J. Hexter
  • History, Economics
    The Journal of Modern History
  • 1978
In its December 1977 issue the Journal of Modern History published five articles bearing on the same historical crisis, an episode called, according to one's historical taste and angle of vision, the
Images of Rule: Art and Politics in the English Renaissance, 1485-1649.
Images of Rule offers a fascinating, authoritative, and highly readable account of the vital role the visual arts played in Great Britain during the Tudor and early Stuart monarchies. David Howarth
The First Modern Society: Essays in English History in Honour of Lawrence Stone
List of illustrations List of tables Notes on contributors Preface Prologue: Lawrence Stone - as seen by others 1. The myth and the man Julian Mitchell 2. The enfant terrible? C. S. L. Davies 3. 'Il
Religion, culture and society in early modern Britain : essays in honour of Patrick Collinson
List of illustrations List of contributors Preface List of abbreviations Patrick Collinson Christopher Brooke 1. Nicolas Pithou: experience, conscience and history in the French civil wars Mark
The values of republicanism in early modern Europe
Introduction Quentin Skinner Part I. Republicanism and Political Values: 1. Classical liberty and the coming of the English Civil War Quentin Skinner 2. Empire and liberty: a Republican dilemma David
The history of the rebellion and civil wars in England
the history of the rebellion and civil wars in england volume 1 part 1 by is among the most effective vendor books worldwide? Have you had it? Never? Silly of you. Now, you could get this outstanding
Britain in revolution, 1625-1660
Prologue I: BACKGROUND AND BEGINNINGS 1625-1640 1. King Charles's Inheritance, i: Three Kingdoms, Three Peoples 2. King Charles's Inheritance, ii: The Matter of Religion 3. The New Reign 4. Storm
The Dead and the Living in Paris and London, 1500-1670
This book is an exploration in social history, showing how the practices surrounding death and burial can illumine urban culture and experience. Vanessa Harding focuses on the crowded and turbulent
...
...