Changes in Exercises Are More Effective Than in Loading Schemes to Improve Muscle Strength

@article{Fonseca2014ChangesIE,
  title={Changes in Exercises Are More Effective Than in Loading Schemes to Improve Muscle Strength},
  author={Rodrigo Fonseca and Hamilton Roschel and Valmor Tricoli and Eduardo Oliveira de Souza and Jacob M. Wilson and Gilberto Candido Laurentino and Andr{\'e} Yui Aihara and Alberto R de Souza Le{\~a}o and Carlos Ugrinowitsch},
  journal={Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research},
  year={2014},
  volume={28},
  pages={3085–3092}
}
Abstract Fonseca, RM, Roschel, H, Tricoli, V, de Souza, EO, Wilson, JM, Laurentino, GC, Aihara, AY, de Souza Leão, AR, and Ugrinowitsch, C. Changes in exercises are more effective than in loading schemes to improve muscle strength. J Strength Cond Res 28(11): 3085–3092, 2014—This study investigated the effects of varying strength exercises and loading scheme on muscle cross-sectional area (CSA) and maximum strength after 4 strength training loading schemes: constant intensity and constant… 

Figures and Tables from this paper

Does Varying Resistance Exercises for the Same Muscle Group Promote Greater Strength Gains?

ABSTRACT Costa, BDV, Kassiano, W, Nunes, JP, Kunevaliki, G, Castro-E-Souza, P, Sugihara-Junior, P, Fernandes, RR, Cyrino, ES, and de Fortes, LS. Does varying resistance exercises for the same muscle

Does the Muscle Action Duration Induce Different Regional Muscle Hypertrophy in Matched Resistance Training Protocols?

TLDR
It was shown that matched RT protocols with different MAD resulted in different region-specific muscle hypertrophic across the individual muscles of QF, which can lead to adaptations of regional muscle hypertrophy.

Does Performing Different Resistance Exercises for the Same Muscle Group Induce Non-homogeneous Hypertrophy?

TLDR
The results suggest that to perform different resistance exercises can induce hypertrophy of all sites assessed in detrained young men.

The effects of exercise variation in muscle thickness, maximal strength and motivation in resistance trained men

TLDR
Varying exercise selection had a positive effect on enhancing motivation to train in resistance-trained men, while eliciting similar improvements in muscular adaptations.

Does Varying Resistance Exercises Promote Superior Muscle Hypertrophy and Strength Gains? A Systematic Review

TLDR
It is concluded that exercise variation should be approached systematically with a focus on applied anatomical and biomechanical constructs; on the contrary, employing different exercises that provide a redundant stimulus, as well as excessive rotation of different exercises, may actually hinder muscular adaptations.

Manual Resistance as a Tool to Increase Muscle Activity and Time under Tension in a Strength Exercise

TLDR
The manual resistance potentialized muscle activation of shoulder flexors when compared with only the dumbbell, and increased the activation of the AD, PMC and PMS in all conditions compared with the Dumbbell Fly without MR (DFW).

Effects of different strength training frequencies during reduced training period on strength and muscle cross-sectional area

TLDR
It appears that RST frequency does not affect the maintenance of muscle mass and strength in untrained males, as long as volume-load is equated between frequencies.

Progressive Resistance Training Volume: Effects on Muscle Thickness, Mass, and Strength Adaptations in Resistance-Trained Individuals

TLDR
Although all of the groups increased maximum strength, the results suggest that the middle dose range may optimize the gains in back squat 1RM, and that differences in weekly set number did not impact in MT and ROI-FFM adaptations in subjects who can squat more than twice their body mass.

Effect of different eccentric tempos on hypertrophy and strength of the lower limbs

TLDR
Different eccentric durations produce similar increases in hypertrophy of the vastus lateralis and rectus femoris; however, the vastu medialis showed greater growth from the slower eccentric duration, suggesting different eccentric duration did not differentially affect strength-related adaptations.

Exercise Variability Did Not Affect Muscle Thickness and Peak Force for Elbow Flexors After a Resistance Training Session in Recreationally-Trained Subjects.

The purpose of this study is to measure the acute effects of exercise variability on muscle thickness and physical performance after two resistance training (RT) protocols using the same or different
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 28 REFERENCES

Effects of Strength and Power Training on Neuromuscular Adaptations and Jumping Movement Pattern and Performance

TLDR
The PT seemed more effective than the ST in increasing jumping performance, but neither the ST nor the PT was able to affect the SJ and the CMJ movement pattern.

Effects of Linear vs. Daily Undulatory Periodized Resistance Training on Maximal and Submaximal Strength Gains

TLDR
Although there was no statistically significant difference between periodization models, DUP promoted superior ES gains in muscular maximal and submaximal strength.

Comparison of Linear and Reverse Linear Periodization Effects on Maximal Strength and Body Composition

TLDR
In practical terms, LP is more effective for strength and hypertrophy as compared with RLP, and 1 week may be an adequate period for application of detraining without causing decreases in the performance of the parameters analyzed.

Comparison Between Nonlinear and Linear Periodized Resistance Training: Hypertrophic and Strength Effects

TLDR
In conclusion, both LP and NLP are effective, but NLP may lead to greater gains in 1RM and MT over a 12-week training period.

A COMPARISON OF PERIODIZATION MODELS DURING NINE WEEKS WITH EQUATED VOLUME AND INTENSITY FOR STRENGTH

TLDR
Results indicate that no separation based on periodization model is seen in early-phase training in training of recreationally trained college-aged volunteers.

A comparison of strength and muscle mass increases during resistance training in young women

TLDR
It is concluded that a more prolonged neural adaptation related to the more complex bench and leg press movements may have delayed hypertrophy in the trunk and legs.

Effects of Training Volume on Strength and Hypertrophy in Young Men

TLDR
Based on the results, the authors recommend 3 sets for sedentary untrained individuals, but this population should incorporate light training days of 1 set into their training program to prevent overtraining and ensure adherence.

American College of Sports Medicine position stand. Progression models in resistance training for healthy adults.

  • Position Stand
  • Education
    Medicine and science in sports and exercise
  • 2009
TLDR
Progression in power training entails two general loading strategies: strength training and use of light loads performed at a fast contraction velocity with 3-5 min of rest between sets for multiple sets per exercise (three to five sets).

American College of Sports Medicine position stand. Progression models in resistance training for healthy adults.

TLDR
In order to stimulate further adaptation toward a specific training goal(s), progression in the type of resistance training protocol used is necessary and emphasis should be placed on multiple-joint exercises, especially those involving the total body.

The Effect of Training Volume on Lower-Body Strength

TLDR
The results suggest that “high” volumes (i.e., >4 sets) are associated with enhanced strength development but that ‘moderate’ volumes offer no advantage and practitioners should be aware that strength development may be dependent on appropriate volume doses and training duration.