Cause and Effect in Biology Revisited: Is Mayr’s Proximate-Ultimate Dichotomy Still Useful?

@article{Laland2011CauseAE,
  title={Cause and Effect in Biology Revisited: Is Mayr’s Proximate-Ultimate Dichotomy Still Useful?},
  author={Kevin N. Laland and Kim Sterelny and John C. Odling-Smee and William J. E. Hoppitt and Tobias Uller},
  journal={Science},
  year={2011},
  volume={334},
  pages={1512 - 1516}
}
Fifty years ago, Ernst Mayr published a hugely influential paper on the nature of causation in biology, in which he distinguished between proximate and ultimate causes. Mayr equated proximate causation with immediate factors (for example, physiology) and ultimate causation with evolutionary explanations (for example, natural selection). He argued that proximate and ultimate causes addressed different questions and were not alternatives. Mayr’s account of causation remains widely accepted today… Expand
More on how and why: cause and effect in biology revisited
TLDR
It is suggested that evolutionary biology would be better served by a concept of reciprocal causation, in which causation is perceived to cycle through biological systems recursively, and that a newer evolutionary synthesis is unlikely to emerge without this change in thinking about causation. Expand
Using causal models to integrate proximate and ultimate causation
TLDR
Using causal graph theory, this paper offers a unified framework to systematically translate a given “proximate” causal structure into an “ultimate” evolutionary response, and illustrates evolutionary implications of various kinds of causal mechanisms including epigenetic inheritance, maternal effects, and niche construction. Expand
The proximate–ultimate distinction and evolutionary developmental biology: causal irrelevance versus explanatory abstraction
Mayr’s proximate–ultimate distinction has received renewed interest in recent years. Here we discuss its role in arguments about the relevance of developmental to evolutionary biology. We show thatExpand
On reciprocal causation in the evolutionary process
TLDR
It is concluded that reciprocal causation has long been recognized as important both in SET and in the MS tradition, although it remains underexplored, and cautioned against uncritical extension of dialectics towards heredity and constructive development, particularly if such extensions involves attempts to restore Lamarckian or “soft inheritance”. Expand
Causal mechanisms of evolution and the capacity for niche construction
TLDR
Mayr’s dichotomy needs replacement by more realistic, mechanistic views of evolution, in which there is a continuum of adaptations from those evolving as responses to unchanging environmental pressures to those evolve as the capacity for niche construction, and intermediate stages of this can be identified. Expand
On Reciprocal Causation in the Evolutionary Process
TLDR
It is concluded that reciprocal causation has long been recognized as important by naturalists, ecologists and evolutionary biologists working in the in the MS tradition, although it it could be explored even further. Expand
Mayr and Tinbergen: disentangling and integrating
Research on animal behavior is typically organized according to a combination of two influential frameworks: Ernst Mayr’s distinction between proximate and ultimate causes, and Niko Tinbergen’s “fourExpand
On evolutionary causes and evolutionary processes
  • K. Laland
  • Psychology, Medicine
  • Behavioural Processes
  • 2015
TLDR
It is argued that the notion of evolutionary process needs to be broadened to accommodate phenomena such as developmental bias and niche construction that bias the course of evolution, but do not directly change gene frequencies, and that causation in biological systems is fundamentally reciprocal in nature. Expand
Cooperation in a Complex World: The Role of Proximate Factors in Ultimate Explanations
Mayr’s distinction between proximate and ultimate explanation is justly famous, marking out a division of explanatory labor in biology. But while it is a useful heuristic in many cases, there areExpand
Nested explanation in Aristotle and Mayr
  • Lucas Mix
  • Philosophy, Computer Science
  • Synthese
  • 2015
TLDR
A strong case can be made for nested explanation, wherein evolutionary explanations are instantiated in systems of mechanical explanations, wherein biological concepts of organism, gene, function, etc., are etiologically prior to mechanical explanations of function, but temporally posterior to Mechanical explanations of historical adaptation. Expand
...
1
2
3
4
5
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 103 REFERENCES
The proximate/ultimate distinction in the multiple careers of Ernst Mayr
Ernst Mayr's distinction between “ultimate” and “proximate” causes is justly considered a major contribution to philosophy of biology. But how did Mayr come to this “philosophical” distinction, andExpand
Evolutionary Theory and the Ultimate–Proximate Distinction in the Human Behavioral Sciences
TLDR
This article focuses on three specific areas: the evolution of cooperation, transmitted culture, and epigenetics, and suggests ways in which misunderstanding may be avoided in the future. Expand
Ernst Mayr's 'ultimate/proximate' distinction reconsidered and reconstructed
It's been 41 years since the publication of Ernst Mayr's “Cause and Effect in Biology” wherein Mayr most clearly develops his version of the influential distinction between ultimate and proximateExpand
EvoDevo and niche construction: building bridges.
TLDR
It is illustrated here how EvoDevo and niche construction could gain "added value" from each other, and how the niche-construction perspective potentially provides a useful conduit to integrate evolutionary and developmental biology. Expand
Cycles of Contingency: Developmental Systems and Evolution
Many books on evolution neglect the complex dynamics of ontogeny (development) necessary to produce the mature creature. They either ignore it or reduce it to the transmission of genetic information.Expand
Coevolution: Genes, Culture, and Human Diversity
Charles Darwin's On the Origins of Species had two principal goals: to show that species had not been separately created and to show that natural selection had been the main force behind theirExpand
The levels of analysis revisited
TLDR
This review surveys different uses of the term levels of analysis and the benefits of integration, and highlights examples of false debate within and between levels. Expand
PERSPECTIVE: SEVEN REASONS (NOT) TO NEGLECT NICHE CONSTRUCTION
TLDR
Seven putative weaknesses of the niche‐construction perspective are discussed and critically evaluate the theoretical standing of these arguments and consider the empirical evidence that can be brought to bear on the debate. Expand
The proximate and the ultimate: past, present, and future
  • D. Dewsbury
  • Medicine, Psychology
  • Behavioural Processes
  • 1999
TLDR
The distinctions inherent in the proximate-ultimate dichotomy have a long history and it is suggested that such terms as 'function', 'ultimate', and 'ultimate causation' be re- evaluated. Expand
Evolution in Four Dimensions
The subtitle of the book is Genetic, Epigenetic, Behavioral, and Symbolic Variation in the History of Life; thus, the four dimensions of the title. ‘‘The challenge [this book] offers is not toExpand
...
1
2
3
4
5
...