Causation: The elusive grail of epidemiology

@article{Karhausen2000CausationTE,
  title={Causation: The elusive grail of epidemiology},
  author={L. Karhausen},
  journal={Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy},
  year={2000},
  volume={3},
  pages={59-67}
}
  • L. Karhausen
  • Published 2000
  • Medicine, Psychology
  • Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy
The paper discusses the evolving concept of causationin epidemiology and its potential interaction with logic and scientific philosophy. Causes arecontingent but the necessity which binds them totheir effects relies on contrary-to-fact conditionals,i.e. conditional statements whose antecedent is false.Chance instead of determinism plays a growing role inscience and, although rarely acknowledged yet, inepidemiology: causes are multiple and chancy; a priorevent causes a subsequent event if the… 

Topics from this paper

Variational Causal Claims in Epidemiology
TLDR
It is suggested that causality in epidemiology ought to be interpreted according to Williamson's epistemic theory, and that causal attribution depends on the available evidence and on the methods used.
What characterises a useful concept of causation in epidemiology?
  • J. Olsen
  • Psychology, Medicine
    Journal of epidemiology and community health
  • 2003
It has recently been suggested that epidemiologists should avoid thinking of causes in deterministic terms. This would mean giving up the component-cause model in its original form. A model that has
Chapter 35 – Introduction to Epidemiology
Publisher Summary This chapter introduces the concept of epidemiology, which employs the tools of basic science (e.g., observation, hypothesis testing, statistics, correlation, and causal reasoning)
Causal criteria and the problem of complex causation
  • Andrew Ward
  • Psychology, Medicine
    Medicine, health care, and philosophy
  • 2009
TLDR
This paper examines one method of warranting causal claims that is especially widespread in epidemiology and the health sciences generally—the use of causal criteria, and argues that cases of complex causation generally, and redundant causation—both causal overdetermination and causal preemption—specifically, undermine the use of such criteria to warrant causal claims.
The causation of disease – The practical and ethical consequences of competing explanations
TLDR
A three-tier taxonomy of the most prominent models of causal explanations for the high and rising prevalence of the common complex conditions of coronary artery disease and type 2 diabetes mellitus is proposed and elaborated with a micro-level thematic analysis to illustrate how some explanations are semantically and rhetorically foregrounded over others.
Exposures, mutations and the history of causality.
  • P. Vineis
  • Medicine
    Journal of epidemiology and community health
  • 2000
TLDR
To better understand the intertwining between causes and mechanisms, it is useful to recall some of the most influential interpretations of causality.
Causation in epidemiology: a Socratic dialogue: Plato.
  • L. Karhausen
  • Medicine
    International journal of epidemiology
  • 2001
TLDR
Every event has a cause but this does not imply that every event is determined by its cause, except if the authors interpret it as ‘probabilistically’ determined.
Introduction to Epidemiology
TLDR
This chapter discusses the fundamental principles of descriptive and analytic epidemiology, and defines the concepts of incidence and prevalence, outlines the basic epidemiological principles of risk and association, and discusses the various types of studies used to conduct epidemiological research.
Hume, Mill, Hill, and the sui generis epidemiologic approach to causal inference.
  • A. Morabia
  • Medicine
    American journal of epidemiology
  • 2013
TLDR
Hill's viewpoints may be philosophically novel, sui generis, still waiting to be validated and justified, because the epidemiologic literature is clueless about a plausible, pre-1965 philosophical origin of Hill's viewpoints.
The social epidemiologic concept of fundamental cause
  • Andrew Ward
  • Psychology, Medicine
    Theoretical medicine and bioethics
  • 2007
TLDR
This paper begins the process of characterizing the social epidemiological concept of fundamental cause in a theoretically respectable and robust way by applying the statistical tools of the health sciences to hypotheses about fundamental causes, their outcomes, and policies intended to enhance the health of populations.
...
1
2
3
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 33 REFERENCES
Epidemiology and causation: a realist view.
  • A. Renton
  • Medicine
    Journal of epidemiology and community health
  • 1994
TLDR
It is argued that a realist analysis identifies a richer role for epidemiology as an integral part of an ontologically unified medical science, which decides causes and provides a key element to the foundations of rational public health decision making.
Attribution of causation in epidemiology: chain or mosaic?
  • B. Charlton
  • Medicine
    Journal of clinical epidemiology
  • 1996
TLDR
It is argued that historical trends in epidemiological reasoning have meant that ascribing causal status to an independent variable has become easier, while refuting a causal hypothesis has become harder, leading to the development of a broadly applicable, but dubiously valid, practice of multicausal risk factor epidemiology.
The Logic of Causation in Epidemiology
  • L. Karhausen
  • Psychology, Medicine
    Scandinavian journal of social medicine
  • 1996
The paper attempts to model causality with logical conditionals by way of conditional probability. This provides a broad conceptualisation of causality according to which we merely observe tendencies
Causation in Medicine: The Disease Entity Model
This paper examines the way in which causal relations are understood in the dominant model in contemporary medicine. It argues that the causal relation is not definable in terms of the condition
Untangling causation issues in law and medicine: hazardous substance litigation.
  • T. Brennan
  • Medicine
    Annals of internal medicine
  • 1987
TLDR
Doctors who testify in hazardous substance cases, either as the treating doctor or as expert witnesses, must be aware of the court's difficulty with probabilistic evidence and state clearly the role of such evidence in the identification of a hazardous substance as the cause of a disease or injury.
The Poverty of Epidemiology
  • P. Skrabanek
  • Psychology, Medicine
    Perspectives in biology and medicine
  • 1992
TLDR
Whether epidemiology, in the absence of epidemics, is not a misnomer for scaremongering made respectable by the use of sophisticated statistical methods, and whether one of the reasons for this state of affairs is a high prevalence of epidemiologists when the incidence of problems soluble by epidemiological methods is low.
The poverty of Popperian epidemiology.
  • L. Karhausen
  • Philosophy, Medicine
    International journal of epidemiology
  • 1995
Karl Popper is one of the leading scientific philosophers of this century and his death marks the end of an era in philosophy which started with the publication of the Logic of Scientific Discovery
In defense of black box epidemiology.
  • D. Savitz
  • Psychology, Medicine
    Epidemiology
  • 1994
Assume that an epidemiologic study has been con? ducted reporting a positive association of an exposure and a disease. The investigators selected subjects in a manner free of selection bias, response
The Abuse of Language and Logic in Epidemiology
  • J. McCormick
  • Medicine
    Perspectives in biology and medicine
  • 1992
TLDR
A glance at some of the journals currently on my desk provides examples of the abuses of language and logic that, when reported more widely, contribute to the devaluation of health information.
Statistics and Causal Inference
Abstract Problems involving causal inference have dogged at the heels of statistics since its earliest days. Correlation does not imply causation, and yet causal conclusions drawn from a carefully
...
1
2
3
4
...