• Corpus ID: 44062098

Causal Structure Learning with Continuous Variables in Continuous Time

  title={Causal Structure Learning with Continuous Variables in Continuous Time},
  author={Zachary Davis and Neil R. Bramley and Bob Rehder},
  journal={Cognitive Science},
Interventions, time, and continuous-valued variables are all potentially powerful cues to causation. Furthermore, when observed over time, causal processes can contain feedback and oscillatory dynamics that make inference hard. We present a generative model and framework for causal inference over continuous variables in continuous time based on Ornstein-Uhlenbeck processes. Our generative model produces a stochastic sequence of evolving variable values that manifest many dynamical properties… 

Figures from this paper

The Paradox of Time in Dynamic Causal Systems
This study introduces a novel Causal Event Segmentation model based on the notion that people compress the continuous scenes into events and use these to drive structure inference, and finds that slowing the task indeed reduced the frequency of one type of error, but increased the error rate overall.
A Causal Model Approach to Dynamic Control
A novel class of dynamic control environments using Ornstein-Uhlenbeck processes connected in causal Markov graphs that allow us to systematically test people’s ability to learn and control various dynamic systems are introduced.
The Role of Granularity in Causal Learning
Prior experiments on causal learning have typically investigated how people learn about the relationships between binary variables (e.g., patients either take or do not take a drug, and either
1 Intervening in Time
This chapter traces how causal inference tools developed in data science have been applied to understanding human causal learning and reasoning, highlights the current shortcomings of both intervention-based and time-based approaches taken separately, and describes recent work that starts to bring the two together.


Theory-based causal induction.
This work identifies 3 key aspects of abstract prior knowledge-the ontology of entities, properties, and relations that organizes a domain; the plausibility of specific causal relationships; and the functional form of those relationships-and shows how they provide the constraints that people need to induce useful causal models from sparse data.
Causal Learning With Continuous Variables Over Time
It is found that subjects’ causal strength judgments were better predicted by change scores than the simple correlation, and that use of change scores was facilitated by naturalistic stimuli, helping explain how people uncover true causal relations in complex time series contexts.
Inferring causal networks from observations and interventions
Temporal predictability facilitates causal learning.
The authors demonstrated that causal relations with fixed temporal intervals are consistently judged as stronger than those with variable temporal intervals, and that causal judgments decline as a function of temporal uncertainty, which clearly indicate that temporal predictability facilitates causal discovery.
Formalizing Neurath’s Ship: Approximate Algorithms for Online Causal Learning
An algorithmic-level model of causal structure learning under which learners represent only a single global hypothesis that they update locally as they gather evidence is proposed and a related scheme for understanding how learners choose informative interventions that manipulate the causal system to help elucidate its workings is proposed.
Bayesian generic priors for causal learning.
A Bayesian model of causal learning that incorporates generic priors--systematic assumptions about abstract properties of a system of cause-effect relations that explains why human judgments of causal structure are influenced more by causal power and the base rate of the effect and less by sample size is presented.
Causal learning from interventions and dynamics in continuous time
It is shown that successful learners use interventions to structure and simplify their interactions with the devices and that they can capture judgment patterns with heuristics based on online construction and testing of a single structural hypothesis.
Structure and strength in causal induction
A rational model of causal induction with continuous causes
This model successfully predicts human judgments from previous studies better than models of discrete causal inference, and outperforms several other plausible models of causal induction with continuous causes in accounting for people's inferences in a new experiment.
Reasoning With Causal Cycles.
  • B. Rehder
  • Computer Science
    Cognitive science
  • 2017
How people reason with categories whose features are related in causal cycles is assessed and chain graphs-a mechanism for representing the equilibrium distribution of a dynamic system-may be good candidates for modeling how people reason causally with complex systems.