Can Learning Constituency Opinion Affect How Legislators Vote? Results from a Field Experiment

  title={Can Learning Constituency Opinion Affect How Legislators Vote? Results from a Field Experiment},
  author={Daniel M. Butler and David W. Nickerson},
  journal={Quarterly Journal of Political Science},
When legislators are uninformed about public opinion, does learning constituents' opinion affect how legislators vote? We conducted a fully randomized field experiment to answer this question. We surveyed 10,690 New Mexicans about the Governor's spending proposals for a special summer session held in the summer of 2008. District-specific survey results were then shared with a randomly selected half of the legislature. The legislators receiving their district-specific survey results were much… 

Figures and Tables from this paper

When Do Legislators Follow Constituent Opinion? Evidence from Matched Roll Call and Referendum Votes
This paper tests theories of representation by studying laws that were challenged by referendum. For these laws, we can compare legislator roll call votes and citizen votes on the same law. In a
Are Legislators More Responsive to Public Opinion on Salient Issues
Are legislators more responsive to public opinion on salient issues? A large literature indicates that the answer is yes. Due to insufficient district-level sample sizes, however, past studies have
How Public Opinion Information Changes Politicians’ Opinions and Behavior
Numerous representation studies suggest that political elites are responsive to the expressed preferences of their voters, but scholars in the field have called for experimental research on the topic
When Do Politicians Pursue More Policy Information?
We conducted a field experiment with 334 Canadian Members of Parliament exploring whether politicians seek out more information about an issue when they are farther offside the average opinion in
Representation When Constituent Opinion and District Conditions Collide
When constituent opinion and district conditions point in two different directions, which factor is most influential for representatives who face important legislative roll calls? To address this
What Politicians Believe About Their Constituents: Asymmetric Misperceptions and Prospects for Constituency Control
Conceptions of democratic governance emphasize the role of public opinion in shaping public policy. We explore a central but dimly understood process by which public opinion affects policy:
Do Republican and Democratic legislators have polarized views of their district’s demographics? 1
Do Republican and Democratic politicians hold the same perceptions about the demographic composition of their district? We test this question by asking state legislators about the size of five key
Call Your Legislator: A Field Experimental Study of the Impact of Citizen Contacts on Legislative Voting
Does contacting one’s legislator influence public policy? We answer this question with a field experiment in which Michigan state legislators are randomly assigned to be contacted by their
Explaining Explanations: How Legislators Explain their Policy Positions and How Citizens React
Legislators claim that how they explain their votes matters as much as or more than the roll calls themselves. However, few studies have systematically examined legislators’ explanations and citizen
How Politicians Discount the Opinions of Constituents with Whom They Disagree
We argue that politicians systematically discount the opinions of constituents with whom they disagree and that this 'disagreement discounting' is a contributing factor to ideological incongruence. A


From Tea Leaves to Opinion Polls: A Theory of Democratic Leadership
Do politicians lead public life or follow it? Does the nature of representative democracy dictate that those in power respond to popular sentiment? And if public opinion is central to political
Representation in Congress: Constituents and Roll Calls in the 106th House
This paper examines the extent to which constituency and subconstituency preferences are reflected in roll-call voting in the 106th House. Aggregating 100,814 randomly selected respondents to measure
Balancing constituency representation and party responsiveness in the US Senate: the conditioning effect of state ideological heterogeneity
Spatial proximity theories of representation focus on the importance of the average views of constituencies in guiding legislators’ decisions. However, legislative scholars also identify political
The logic of congressional action
Congress regularly enacts laws that benefit particular groups or localities while imposing costs on everyone else. Sometimes, however, Congress breaks free of such parochial concerns and enacts bills
The Influence of Party: Evidence from the State Legislatures
American legislative studies in recent years have been occupied to a large degree with the question of the effects of political parties on the policy behavior of elected legislators, with most of the
Representatives' votes on a series of defense budget roll calls in the first year of the Reagan administration's Pentagon buildup are related to constituency opinions on defense spending during the
Politicians Don't Pander: Political Manipulation and the Loss of Democratic Responsiveness
Public opinion polls are everywhere. Journalists report their results without hesitation, and political activists of all kinds spend millions of dollars on them, fuelling the widespread assumption
Representativeness and Elections: A Policy Analysis
This paper looks at representativeness in terms of policy dimensions. As previous studies also have demonstrated, the analysis provides evidence that the level of policy agreement varies across
Has Polling Enhanced Representation? Unearthing Evidence from the Literary Digest Issue Polls
  • David Karol
  • Political Science
    Studies in American Political Development
  • 2007
How has representation changed over time in the United States? Has responsiveness to public opinion waxed or waned among elected officials? What are the causes of such trends as we observe? Scholars
Patterns of Representation: Dynamics of Public Preferences and Policy
Much research shows that politicians represent public preferences in public policy. Although we know that there is representation, we do not understand the nature of the relationship in different