# Can Gravitons be Detected?

@article{Rothman2006CanGB, title={Can Gravitons be Detected?}, author={Tony Rothman and Stephen Boughn}, journal={Foundations of Physics}, year={2006}, volume={36}, pages={1801-1825} }

Freeman Dyson has questioned whether any conceivable experiment in the real universe can detect a single graviton. If not, is it meaningful to talk about gravitons as physical entities? We attempt to answer Dyson’s question and find it is possible concoct an idealized thought experiment capable of detecting one graviton; however, when anything remotely resembling realistic physics is taken into account, detection becomes impossible, indicating that Dyson’s conjecture is very likely true. We…

## 142 Citations

### Can thermal input from a prior universe account for relic graviton production

- Physics
- 2006

Primer for how intense graviton production can be obtained in the first 10 to the minus 43 seconds of cosmological inflation. In addition several cosmological models which appear to have conclusions…

### Nonquantum Gravity

- Physics
- 2009

One of the great challenges for 21st century physics is to quantize gravity and generate a theory that will unify gravity with the other three fundamental forces of nature. This paper takes the…

### Detailing Coherent, Minimum Uncertainty States of Gravitons, as Semi Classical Components of Gravity Waves, and How Squeezed States Affect Upper Limits To Graviton Mass

- Physics
- 2011

We present what is relevant to squeezed states of initial space time and how that affects both the composition of relic GW, and also gravitons. A side issue to consider is if gravitons can be…

### Newton, entanglement, and the graviton

- PhysicsPhysical Review D
- 2022

Many experiments have recently been proposed to test whether non-relativistic gravitational interactions can generate entanglement. In this note, I consider the extent to which these experiments can…

### Gravitational Casimir effect, the Lifshitz theory, and the existence of gravitons

- Physics
- 2016

It has been predicted that, if gravitational wave reflectors exist, two such parallel plane gravitational mirrors separated by an empty gap will interact not only via the well-known Casimir effect of…

### Gravitons in a box

- PhysicsPhysical Review D
- 2021

Gravity and matter are universally coupled, and this unique universality provides us with an intriguing way to quantifying quantum aspects of space-time in terms of the number of gravitons within a…

### Can Thermal Input from a Prior Universe Account for Relic Graviton Production? Implications for the Cosmological Landscape

- Physics
- 2007

The author presents how to make a link between the low temperature and low entropy of pre big bang state of cosmology as given by Carroll and Chen in 2005, to the quantum cosmology conditions…

### Open questions as to what a Large vacuum energy implies for graviton production in a relic setting, i.e. a Toy Model to Consider

- Physics, Geology
- 2011

A toy model to account for thermal transfer of energy from a prior to a present universe perhaps enabling graviton production and a transition between the two regions in terms of a causal discontinuity regime created by a(t) chaotic behavior.

### Can thermal input from a prior universe account for relic graviton production?

- Physics
- 2006

The author presents how answering Sean Carroll’s supposition of a pre inflation state of low temperature-low entropy pre inflation state as given in 2005 provides a bridge between two models with…

### How Can Brane World Physics Influence the Existence of a Relic Graviton Burst in the Onset of Inflation

- Physics
- 2009

We use an explicit Randall-Sundrum brane world effective potential as congruent with conditions needed to form a minimum entropy starting point for an early universe vacuum state. We justify this by…

## References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 30 REFERENCES

### On the intrinsic entropy of the gravitational field

- Physics
- 1985

I show that in linearized general relativity it is impossible to construct a detector by the use of which the quantum state of the linearized gravitational field could be reliably determined. This is…

### Aspects of graviton detection: graviton emission and absorption by atomic hydrogen

- Physics
- 2006

Graviton absorption cross sections and emission rates for hydrogen are calculated by both semi-classical and field theoretic methods. We point out several mistakes in the literature concerning…

### Indirect Evidence for Quantum Gravity

- Physics
- 1981

An experiment gave results inconsistent with the simplest alternative to quantum gravity, the semiclassical Einstein equations. This evidence supports (but does not prove) the hypothesis that a…

### Primordial black holes: Recent developments

- Physics
- 2005

Black holes with a wide range of masses could have formed in the early Universe as a result of the great compression associated with the Big Bang [70, 143]. A comparison of the cosmological density…

### The necessity of quantizing the gravitational field

- Physics
- 1977

The assumption that a classical gravitational field interacts with a quantum system is shown to lead to violations of either momentum conservation or the uncertainty principle, or to result in…

### QUANTUM THEORY OF GRAVITY. III. APPLICATIONS OF THE COVARIANT THEORY.

- Physics
- 1967

The basic momentum-space propagators and vertices (including those for the fictitious quanta) are given for both the Yang-Mills and gravitational fields. These propagators are used to obtain the…

### The graviton luminosity of the sun and other stars

- Physics
- 1985

Graviton production in electron-electron (e-e) and electron-ion (e-z) scattering is evaluated in the Born approximation. The calculation is compared with that for photon production, that is, Coulomb…

### Particle emission rates from a black hole: Massless particles from an uncharged, nonrotating hole

- Physics
- 1976

Hawking has predicted that a black hole will emit particles as if it had a temperature proportional to its surface gravity. This paper combines Hawking's quantum formalism with the black-hole…

### Electrogravitational conversion cross sections in static electromagnetic fields

- Physics
- 1977

We use Feynman perturbation techniques to analyze a classical process: the conversion of gravitational waves into electromagnetic waves (and vice versa) under the "catalytic" action of a static…

### Black Holes, White Dwarfs, and Neutron Stars

- Physics
- 1983

Only for you today! Discover your favourite black holes white dwarfs and neutron stars book right here by downloading and getting the soft file of the book. This is not your time to traditionally go…