But Is It for Real? The British Columbia Citizens’ Assembly as a Model of State-Sponsored Citizen Empowerment

  title={But Is It for Real? The British Columbia Citizens’ Assembly as a Model of State-Sponsored Citizen Empowerment},
  author={Amy Schrager Lang},
  journal={Politics \& Society},
  pages={35 - 70}
  • A. Lang
  • Published 2007
  • Political Science
  • Politics & Society
Emerging forms of empowered participatory governance have generated considerable scholarly excitement, but critics continue to ask if such initiatives are “for real”: Are participatory governance processes sufficiently independent? Do citizen participants make good policy choices? An in-depth look at the case of the British Columbia Citizens’ Assembly on Electoral Reform suggests that real citizen empowerment depends on both the institutional constraints of the participa-tory setting and how… Expand
Democratic Innovations: Designing Institutions for Citizen Participation
Can we design institutions that increase and deepen citizen participation in the political decision making process? At a time when there is growing disillusionment with the institutions of advancedExpand
Participatory democracy at the regional scale in Europe: size vs. politics?
The settlement of tools and devices of participatory democracy at the regional level in Europe, for few years, has been the occasion to wonder about the “scale” issue in the modern democracy. Indeed,Expand
Democracy and STV – Why Disagree ? Explaining the “ Preference Gap ” Between British Columbia ’ s Citizens ’ Assembly and the Larger Public
The meaning of democracy in Canada is a highly contested concept. Although many agree that a great rift exists between our ideal notion of democracy and the actual reality of our democracy as it isExpand
Deliberative Democratic Practices in Canada: An Analysis of Institutional Empowerment in Three Cases
  • G. Johnson
  • Political Science
  • Canadian Journal of Political Science
  • 2009
Abstract. Analyzing three timely Canadian cases, this article develops an important relationship between the theory and practice of deliberative democracy. The Canadian Nuclear Waste ManagementExpand
Should Voters Decide? Exploring Successes, Failures and Effects of Electoral Reform
Are Citizens’ Assemblies useful tools for reforming democratic institutions and addressing the democratic deficit? Evaluating the utility of using mini-publics to deliberate issues like electoralExpand
Through the Social Web: Citizen-led Participation in Ontario Policy-making
In the mid to late 1990s, many states developed eGovernment programs that included the use of consultation technologies. More recently, the social characteristics of the web have emerged as offeringExpand
Democracy’s New Discipline: Public Deliberation as Organizational Strategy
Scholars of politics have studied deliberative events as political processes aimed at empowering citizens, a perspective that frames organizational subsidies of public deliberation as civil societyExpand
Acknowledging that mechanisms of direct democracy can fall prey to narrow and egoistic interests (regardless of how legitimate they may be) and that legislatures do not always have the incentives toExpand
The Spillover Effects of Participatory Governance
In contrast to more pessimistic studies, the authors find evidence that civic participation in one domain of public life can lead to more participation elsewhere, what they call spillover effects.Expand
Democratic Innovation Through Ideas? Participatory budgeting and frames of citizen participation in France, Germany and Great Britain
This research investigates the processes of adaptation of participatory budget (PB) institutions to France, Germany, and Great Britain in relation to frames of citizen participation, for instanceExpand


Deepening Democracy
As the tasks of the state have become more complex and the size of polities larger and more heterogeneous, the institutional forms of liberal democracy developed in the nineteenthExpand
Democracy and Disagreement
. According to Popper's critical rationalism, the possibility of disagreement is at the heart of open societies. If this is assumed to be true, is it not illiberal to try to justify principles ofExpand
Deliberative Democracy: Deliberation and Ideological Domination
“I did not realize how sophisticated they [the opponents] would be in conveying messages that were effective politically even though substantively wrong.” Hillary Clinton, interview in the New YorkExpand
Elections in Australia, Ireland, and Malta under the Single Transferable Vote: Reflections on an Embedded Institution
The Single Transferable Vote, or STV, is often seen in very positive terms by electoral reformers, yet relatively little is known about its actual workings beyond one or two specific settings. ThisExpand
Should Blacks Represent Blacks and Women Represent Women? A Contingent "Yes"
Disadvantaged groups gain advantages from descriptive representation in at least four contexts. In contexts of group mistrust and uncrystallized interests, the better communication and experientialExpand
Equal Voice, an organization dedicated to increasing women's political representation
  • 41. Government of Canada, 38th Parliament Standing Committee on Procedure and House AffairsPROC/Meetings/Evidence/PROCEV25-E.HTM#Int-1168247
  • 2005
The Citizens Assembly Model " (paper presented at the Designing Democratic Institutions Workshop
  • The Citizens Assembly Model " (paper presented at the Designing Democratic Institutions Workshop
  • 2005
The Citizens Assembly Model” (paper presented at the Designing Democratic Institutions Workshop, University of British Columbia
  • 2005
Transforming the House of Lords into a Citizens Assembly
  • 2005
What Were They Thinking? And When? The BC Referendum Survey, n=2661
  • (paper presented at the Designing Democratic Institutions Workshop,
  • 2005