Broad versus narrow personality measures and the prediction of behaviour across cultures

  title={Broad versus narrow personality measures and the prediction of behaviour across cultures},
  author={S. V. Paunonen and Geoffrey Haddock and Friedrich Forsterling and Mirja Keinonen},
  journal={European Journal of Personality},
  pages={413 - 433}
Measures of several personality variables, from both within and beyond the domain of the Big Five personality factors, were used to predict a variety of complex behaviour outcomes of some social and cultural significance (e.g. alcohol consumption and grade point average). Analyses focused on replicated predictions across participants in four countries (Canada, England, Germany, and Finland) and on the relative predictive accuracies of narrow trait predictors versus broad factor predictors. The… Expand

Tables from this paper

Personality and prejudice: from Big Five personality factors to facets.
Multiple regression analyses showed the strongest facets to outperform the strongest factors in predicting prejudice in all three studies and the two major approaches - the personality and the social psychological - to explaining individual differences in prejudice. Expand
On the validity of narrow and broad personality traits: A response to
Abstract Salgado, Moscoso, and Berges (2013) have recently commented on the issue of the comparative validity of broad factor-level personality traits and narrow facet-level personality traits,Expand
Personality and Behavior Prediction and Consistency Across Cultures: A Multimethod Study of Blacks and Whites in South Africa
Drawing a distinction between subjective beliefs and objective behavior in the study of personality and culture is proposed, suggesting larger cultural differences can be expected in beliefs and perceptions than in the links between personality and actual behavior. Expand
Traits and values as predictors of the frequency of everyday behavior: Comparison between models and levels
The aims of this study were to compare (a) personality traits vs personal values, (b) Five-Factor Model (FFM) vs HEXACO model of personality traits, and (c) broad vs narrow personality constructs inExpand
Incremental criterion prediction of personality facets over factors: Obtaining unbiased estimates and confidence intervals
Many researchers have argued that higher order models of personality such as the Five Factor Model are insufficient, and that facet-level analysis is required to better understand criteria such asExpand
HEXACO personality and Schwartz's personal values: A facet-level analysis
Abstract This study systematically examined the correlates of Schwartz’s basic values with the broad and narrow traits of the HEXACO model of personality. A sample of 1244 adults (53% male; M age =Expand
Personality traits and health‐risk behaviours in university students
Relations between personality and health‐risk behaviours in university undergraduates were examined using multiple measures of personality across multiple samples (N = 1151). Big Five personalityExpand
Five-Factor Measure of Borderline Personality Traits
The Five Factor Borderline Inventory (FFBI) subscales were shown to have good internal consistency, convergent, discriminant, and incremental validity and were replicated in a clinical sample of female residents at a substance abuse treatment facility. Expand
Measurement and research using the Big Five, HEXACO, and narrow traits: A primer for researchers and practitioners
Abstract Objective Personality traits influence human behaviour across a broad range of situations and are consequently relevant to many theoretical and applied disciplines. In this perspectiveExpand
Personality traits beyond the big five: are they within the HEXACO space?
Results indicated that the first unrotated factor underlying the 10 SPI traits was heavily saturated with variance from Honesty-Humility, highlighting the importance of the facet-level assessment of personality traits. Expand


Big Five factors of personality and replicated predictions of behavior.
  • S. Paunonen
  • Psychology, Medicine
  • Journal of personality and social psychology
  • 2003
The results indicated substantial consistency in behavior predictions across the different Big Five assessments, supporting both the construct validity of the personality measures used and the role of the Big Five factors as determinants of certain complex behaviors. Expand
Hierarchical Organization of Personality and Prediction of Behavior
Two studies evaluated personality trait measures and Big Five factor measures for their accuracy in predicting important behavior criteria. The results of both studies showed that the narrower traitsExpand
Big five factors and facets and the prediction of behavior.
The authors compared the Big 5 factors of personality with the facets or traits of personality that constitute those factors on their ability to predict 40 behavior criteria, finding the narrow facets did noticeably better in that regard. Expand
Narrow reasoning about the use of broad personality measures for personnel selection
Ones and Viswesvaran (1996) have argued for the use of broad bandwidth, rather than narrow bandwidth, personality predictors in personnel selection research when overall job performance is theExpand
Construct Validity and the Search for Cross-Cultural Consistencies in Personality
Personality psychologists have long been interested in the issue of the consistency of human behavior across cultures. Research and theorizing in this area has typically addressed questions of theExpand
The Structured Assessment of Personality across Cultures
The purpose of this article is to review several popular, structured, personality questionnaires in terms of their applicability in cross-cultural assessment contexts. Prior to our review, weExpand
Bandwidth-fidelity dilemma in personality measurement for personnel selection
This paper presents a discussion of the bandwidth–fidelity dilemma in personality measurement for personnel selection purposes. Should job applicants be assessed on fine-grained personality variablesExpand
Big Five Predictors of Academic Achievement
A large-sample study (N = 717) is described in which two broad Big Five factor measures were compared with two narrow personality trait measures in the prediction of final grades in an undergraduateExpand
Predicting dimensions of personality disorder from domains and facets of the Five-Factor Model.
Use of the NEO-PI-R facets afforded substantial improvement over the Five-Factor Model domains in predicting interview-based ratings of DSM-IV personality disorder, such that the NEO facets and the SNAP scales demonstrated roughly equivalent levels of predictive power. Expand
An introduction to the five-factor model and its applications.
It is argued that the five-factor model of personality should prove useful both for individual assessment and for the elucidation of a number of topics of interest to personality psychologists. Expand