Bringing Ourselves to Grief

  title={Bringing Ourselves to Grief},
  author={David W. McIvor},
  journal={Political Theory},
  pages={409 - 436}
Within political theory there has been a recent surge of interest in the themes of loss, grief, and mourning. In this paper I address questions about the politics of mourning through a critical engagement of the work of Judith Butler. I argue that Butler’s work remains tethered to an account of melancholic subjectivity derived from her early reading of Freud. These investments in melancholia compromise Butler’s recent ethico-political interventions by obscuring the ambivalence of political… 

Beyond mourning and melancholia: Nostalgia, anger and the challenges of political action

Political theorists have increasingly adopted the psychoanalytic language of ‘mourning’ to characterize experiences of loss and injury, and to legitimate these as claims about a past political or

Judith Butler and the Politics of Epistemic Frames

  • G. Rae
  • Philosophy, Sociology
    Critical Horizons
  • 2022
ABSTRACT Judith Butler’s work has tended to be read through two axes: (1) an early gender theory/later ethical theory division, and/or (2) an ethical/political divide. In contrast, I aim to undercut

Norms, vision and violence: Judith Butler on the politics of legibility

Judith Butler’s meditations on precarity have received considerable attention in recent years. This article proposes that an undertheorized strain of her argument offers productive resources for

American Mourning: Tragedy, Democracy, Resilience

‘The dead are alive in the American polity.’ With this line Simon Stow begins his wonderful book, American Mourning: Tragedy, Democracy, and Resilience, which unfolds as a thorough and thoughtful

Do the Dead Matter? Identifying Mourning and Funerals As a Political Act

The rise of the hyper-nationalist conservative right, the refugee crisis, state sponsored torture and prison abuse, wars, climate change, and the continued presence of racism, sexism and queer-phobia

Affect, Diversity, and the Problem of Consolation in the Critique of Public Servant Identity

  • F. Valenzuela
  • Political Science
    Diversity, Affect and Embodiment in Organizing
  • 2018
This chapter seeks to contribute to the project of constructing a more radical, feminist-oriented diversity through the critical study of affect in Public Service. It does so by focusing on the

‘A Baby Is a Baby’: The Asha Protests and the Sociology of Affective Post-Nationalism

Theories of post-nationalism are concerned with deconstructing the relationship between citizenship and national identity. While literature in this field has tended towards macro-institutionalist

Framing Wrongs and Performing Rights in Northern Ireland: Towards a Butlerian Approach to Life in Abortion Strategising

Introduction Abortion is an issue that engages diverse feminist strategising in a myriad of contemporary global locations. Within this strategising, "pro-choice" approaches towards achieving enhanced

Why spontaneity matters: Rosa Luxemburg and democracies of grief

The article seeks to explain why spontaneity, a concept that political theorists have given scant attention to, matters. It argues that it matters because it delivers a capacity for producing

The End of the Affair with Life: Political Theory and the Corpse

ABSTRACT The relationship between death and politics figures prominently for us. However, the dead body has been neglected by this tradition. This paper shows how the figure of the corpse offers



Preparing for politics: Judith Butler's ethical dispositions

The question of Judith Butler's ‘politics’ and their normative justification has been raised by critics and supporters alike for some time. The number of recent texts dedicated to this topic suggests

Violence, Mourning, Politics

This essay argues that mourning can provide resources for the rethinking of community and of international relations and that the military preemption and derealization of loss undermines fundamental

Towards a cultural politics of vulnerability: precarious lives and ungrievable deaths

For a long time now I have been interested in what I see to be a particular tension in the work of Judith Butler. This is the tension between her explicit commitment to producing ‘ontology itself as

Frames of War: When Is Life Grievable?

This is a profound exploration of the current wars, looking at violence, gender and different forms of resistance. In "Frames of War", Judith Butler explores the media's portrayal of state violence,

Precarious Life: The Powers of Mourning and Violence

Written after September 11, 2001, in response to the conditions of heightened vulnerability and aggression that have prevailed since then, Judith Butler critiques the use of violence and argues for a

Giving an Account of Oneself

What does it mean to lead a moral life?In her first extended study of moral philosophy, Judith Butler offers a provocative outline for a new ethical practice-one responsive to the need for critical

Antigone's Laments, Creon's Grief

This paper reads Sophocles' Antigone contextually, as an exploration of the politics of lamentation and larger conflicts these stand for. Antigone defies Creon's sovereign decree that her brother

Disappearing Acts: Spectacles of Gender and Nationalism in Argentina's "Dirty War"

In Disappearing Acts , Diana Taylor looks at how national identity is shaped, gendered, and contested through spectacle and spectatorship. The specific identity in question is that of Argentina, and

Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity

Preface (1999) Preface (1990) 1. Subjects of Sex/Gender/Desire I. 'Women' as the Subject of Feminism II. The Compulsory Order of Sex/Gender/Desire III. Gender: The Circular Ruins of Contemporary

Concerning the Public Use of History

issue of Die Zeit and has not been following the emotional discussion in the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung must have the impression that the argument we are involved in is about historical details.