Breaking the Cycle of Iwo Jima Mythology: A Strategic Study of Operation Detachment

  title={Breaking the Cycle of Iwo Jima Mythology: A Strategic Study of Operation Detachment},
  author={Robert S. Burrell},
  journal={The Journal of Military History},
  pages={1143 - 1186}
The American struggle to capture the Pacific Island of Iwo Jima from the Japanese in 1945 proved to be the bloodiest fight in Marine Corps history. Yet, ironically, the justifications for seizing the island have undergone little critical analysis. A detailed look into the planning for Iwo Jima demonstrates that the service rivalry resulting from the competing agendas of the Navy, Army and Army Air Forces in the Pacific negatively influenced the decision to initiate Operation Detachment. The… 
5 Citations

Tables from this paper

The American Doctrine for the Use of Naval Gunfire in Support of Amphibious Landings: Myth vs. Reality in the Central Pacific of World War II.
The United States Marine Corps and the United States Navy developed during the interwar period a doctrine that addressed the problems inherent in the substitution of naval gunfire for artillery
Marine Corps Boot Camp during World War II: THE GATEWAY TO THE CORPS’ S U C C E S S AT I WO J I M A
Was the Marine Corps’ success at Iwo Jima a matter of leadership, bravado, or fundamental training? This article examines the efficacy of boot camp, replacement training, and unit training as it
The Myth of Iwo Jima: A Rebuttal
The author is critical of the methodology and conclusions of an essay by Robert Burrell published in the October 2004 JMH asserting that the invasion of Iwo Jima in 1945 was unnecessary and in part a
How the War Was Won: Air-Sea Power and Allied Victory in World War II
World War II is usually seen as a titanic land battle, decided by mass armies, most importantly those on the Eastern Front. Phillips Payson O'Brien shows us the war in a completely different light.
Books, Articles, Chapters
This bibliography covers books, articles and chapters that appeared in 2004 and the early part of 2005, with some of earlier date sighted too late for inclusion previously. Most official publications


The Rise of American Air Power: The Creation of Armageddon
This prizewinning book is the first in-depth history of American strategic bombing. Michael S. Sherry explores the growing appeal of air power in America before World War II, the ideas, techniques,
God's Samurai: Lead Pilot at Pearl Harbor
This is the story of Mitsuo Fuchida, the career naval aviator - and, later, internationally known Christian evangelist - who not only led the air attack on Pearl Harbour, but participated in most of
Kaigun: Strategy, Tactics, and Technology in the Imperial Japanese Navy, 1887-1941
One of the great spectacles of recent naval history was the Imperial Japanese Navy's instrumental role in Japan's rise from an isolationist feudal kingdom to a potent military empire, stridently
U.S. War Plans, 1939-1945
During World War II the United States produced war plans for every major campaign. The actual course of the war was, however, often very different. Coalition politics, enemy reactions, and logistical
American Airpower Comes of Age: General Henry H. "Hap" Arnold's World War II Diaries. Volume 1
Abstract : Although the need for a comprehensive biography of Gen Henry H. "Hap" Arnold exists, this volume does not constitute such a biography. Nor is this work intended as a history of the Army
Eagle Against the Sun. The American War With Japan.
Traces the war in the Pacific from Pearl Harbor to the atomic bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, and examines the major battles and campaigns.
Fading Victory: The Diary of Admiral Matome Ugaki, 1941-1945
David Wojahn deftly mixes personal history and recollections with a wide range of character studies and monologues, but the center of this book is a sequence of thirty-five poems, mainly sonnets, in