Body or mind: children's categorizing of pretense.

@article{Lillard1996BodyOM,
  title={Body or mind: children's categorizing of pretense.},
  author={Angeline S. Lillard},
  journal={Child development},
  year={1996},
  volume={67 4},
  pages={
          1717-34
        }
}
  • A. Lillard
  • Published 1 August 1996
  • Psychology
  • Child development
Researchers studying early social cognition have been particularly interested in pretend play and have obtained evidence indicating that young children do not understand that pretending involves mental representation. The present research investigates whether children think of pretending as a mental state at all, by looking at whether they cluster it with other mental states or with physical processes when making certain judgments. The results from 5 experiments suggest that most children under… 

Tables from this paper

Wanting to be it: children's understanding of intentions underlying pretense.

Across 5 experiments, children did not demonstrate appreciation that intention is crucial to pretense, and various methodological factors that might have compromised the results were examined, but to no effect.

The impact of fantasy and action on young children's understanding of pretence

Theorists examining children's understanding of the mind have been particularly interested in pretence as it may be a marker for early understanding of mental representation (Leslie, 1987). Although

Preschoolers' attributions of mental states in pretense.

The view that children initially learn to recognize pretense from contextual cues and are able to infer pretenders' beliefs only with further development of metarepresentational ability is supported.

How Do Children Represent Pretend Play

How do young children represent pretend play? One possibility is that recognizing and representing pretend play depends on children’s ability to infer the mental states of the person engaged in

Preschooler's Understanding of the Role of Mental States and Action in Pretense

The results of this study suggest that in certain facilitating conditions (e.g., intention information salient, forced-choice question) children have an early understanding of the role of mind in pretense.

Children’s understanding of the mind’s involvement in pretense: do words bend the truth?

Many have thought that children have an early appreciation of the role of the mind in pretense, fitting with the notion that pretend play is, in general, a ‘zone of proximal development’ (Vygotsky,

Pantomime and theory of mind

Abstract The relationship between pretense and the child's theory of mind (ToM) has recently become a major research interest in developmental psychology. Over the preschool years, pantomime, or

How fantasy benefits young children's understanding of pretense.

  • D. Sobel
  • Psychology
    Developmental science
  • 2006
Data from three experiments are consistent with the hypothesis that preschoolers use actions and appearance more than mental states to make judgments about pretense, but that those judgments can be influenced by the context in which the questions are presented.

Children's developing knowledge of the relationship between mental awareness and pretense.

The hypotheses that by the age of 4, children have some, but not a complete, understanding of the relationship between pretense and mental awareness are supported.

Preschoolers' use of desires to solve theory of mind problems in a pretense context.

It is shown that even young children are able to correctly attribute a false belief to an agent when that belief is about the status of a pretense, and that a reality bias also influences children's ability to consider beliefs.
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 33 REFERENCES

Young children's conceptualization of pretense: action or mental representational state?

The results suggest that 4-year-olds do not understand that pretending requires mental representation, and appear to misconstrue pretense as its common external manifestations, such as actions, until at least the sixth year.

Preschoolers' understanding of others' mental attitudes towards pretend happenings

One question about early understanding of the mind concerns when young children realize that pretence involves persons' thoughts or mental attitudes. Two experiments explored this understanding in 3-

Pretend play skills and the child's theory of mind.

This paper investigates whether pretend play is an area of advanced understanding with reference to 3 skills that are implicated in both pretend play and a theory of mind: the ability to represent one object as two things at once, the able to see one objects as representing another, and the abilityto represent mental representations.

Young children's knowledge about thinking.

Using 14 case studies of differentiation, situations and introspection, this book finds that pre-schoolers may regard thoughts as mysterious, isolated mental events; in general, a young child has difficulty determining both when a person (either self or other) is thinking and what the person is thinking about, even if given clear clues.

A comparison of young children's understanding of contradictory representations in pretense, memory, and belief.

3- and 4-year-olds chose the correct thought picture significantly more often for pretense and memory scenarios than for false belief scenarios, suggesting that young children conceptualize pretense as involving mental representations, and that they have more difficulty understanding contradictory mental representations that purport to correspond to reality.

Theory of mind development and social understanding.

Abstract A cross-sectional, correlational study of 30 children, 3 to 5 years old, investigated relations between their theory of mind development and social interaction, controlling for age and

The Child's Theory of Mind

Wellman presents evidence that children as young as age three do possess a commonsense theory of mind—that they grasp the distinction between mental constructs and physical entities and that they

Children's developing conceptions of the mind and brain.

Evidence is presented to show that by ages 4 and 5 years children commonly regard the brain as an internal mindlike entity associated with a class of distinctly mental acts, which runs counter to previous characterizations of young children as failing to distinguish mental from overt behavioral acts.

Young Children's Understanding of Thinking and Consciousness

opened the box think is in it, the ex perimenter now inquires. "Candy!" says the child, grinning at the trick. The researcher repeats the proce dure with a 3-year-old. The response to the first