Biological Nitrogen Fixation Prevents the Response of a Eutrophic Lake to Reduced Loading of Nitrogen: Evidence from a 46-Year Whole-Lake Experiment

  title={Biological Nitrogen Fixation Prevents the Response of a Eutrophic Lake to Reduced Loading of Nitrogen: Evidence from a 46-Year Whole-Lake Experiment},
  author={Scott N. Higgins and Michael J. Paterson and Robert E. Hecky and David W. Schindler and Jason J. Venkiteswaran and David L. FindlayD.L. Findlay},
AbstractA whole-ecosystem experiment in Lake 227 (L227) at the Experimental Lakes Area, ongoing since 1969, examined the roles of carbon (C), nitrogen (N), and phosphorus (P) in controlling eutrophication. During 2011, we conducted a series of sub-experiments and more intensive monitoring to improve estimates of N fixation and its ability to meet algal growth demands in the decades following the cessation of artificial N loading, while maintaining long-term high artificial P loading… Expand

Figures from this paper

Nitrogen transformations differentially affect nutrient‐limited primary production in lakes of varying trophic state
The concept of lakes “evolving” phosphorus (P) limitation has persisted in limnology despite limited direct evidence. Here, we developed a simple model to broadly characterize nitrogen (N) surplusesExpand
Mitigating eutrophication and toxic cyanobacterial blooms in large lakes: The evolution of a dual nutrient (N and P) reduction paradigm
Cyanobacterial harmful algal blooms (CyanoHABs) are an increasingly common feature of large, eutrophic lakes. Non-N2-fixing CyanoHABs (e.g., Microcystis) appear to be proliferating relative toExpand
Phosphorus-only fertilization rapidly initiates large nitrogen-fixing cyanobacteria blooms in two oligotrophic lakes
Two small, oligotrophic lakes at the IISD-Experimental Lakes Area in northwestern Ontario, Canada were fertilized weekly with only phosphorus (P) in the summer and early fall of 2019. The PExpand
The influence of cyanobacteria blooms on the attenuation of nitrogen throughputs in a Baltic coastal lagoon
We combined a mass balance approach with measurements of air–water and sediment–water nitrogen (N) exchange to better understand the mechanisms attenuating N throughputs in a eutrophic coastalExpand
Assessment of nitrogen fixation rates in the Laurentian Great Lakes
Lakes are significantly different in NFix rates from one another and that rates are depth dependent, and linear regression models indicate NFix is generally positively correlated with chlorophyll-a concentration and negatively correlated with oxidized nitrogen species concentrations, suggesting that NFix may persist to meet cellular and community nitrogen demands. Expand
N2 fixation in urbanization area rivers: spatial-temporal variations and influencing factors
Robust evidence is provided that N2 fixation can supply a substantial portion of the N input to human-impacted river ecosystems, which has not been sufficiently accounted for when determining the N mass balance of riverine ecosystems. Expand
Phosphorus concentrations into a subtropical lake strongly influence nitrogen accumulation, nitrogen export, and Chl a concentrations
We measured water quality monthly for 22 years in water entering, within, and exiting a 65 km2 shallow polymictic and eutrophic freshwater lake in the northern Gulf of Mexico. Fertilizer use in theExpand
Long-term influence of climate and experimental eutrophication regimes on phytoplankton blooms
Examination of a long-term dataset from Lake 227, a site exposed to a fertilization experiment, finds that blooms were dampened under a “no climate change” scenario, suggesting that the interaction of nutrient loading and increased temperature intensifies blooms. Expand
Spatial distribution of sediment nitrogen and phosphorus in Lake Taihu from a hydrodynamics-induced transport perspective.
Although the horizontal transport of phosphorus was found to be weaker than that of nitrogen, short-distance vertical transport of sediment phosphorus may relieve nutrient limitations, leading to maintenance of cyanobacterial blooms found in Lake Taihu. Expand
Phytoplankton nutrient deficiencies vary with season in sub-tropical lakes of Nepal
This is one of few studies to comprehensively examine seasonality and phytoplankton nutrient deficiency in sub-tropical lakes over multiple years, to our knowledge. We tested whether phytoplanktonExpand


Recent Changes of N2-Fixation in Lake 227 in Response to Reduction of the N:P Loading Ratio
Five years of phytoplankton nutrient-status measurements, together with estimates of N2-fixation before and after lowering the N:P loading ratio, verified the importance of this ratio in producing blooms of N1-fixing cyanobacteria. Expand
Nitrogen fixation may not balance the nitrogen pool in lakes over timescales relevant to eutrophication management
We explored multiyear linear trends in nutrient concentrations, nitrogen (N):phosphorus (P) ratio, and phytoplankton biomass within the 37-yr, whole-ecosystem nutrient enrichment experiment in LakeExpand
Eutrophication of lakes cannot be controlled by reducing nitrogen input: Results of a 37-year whole-ecosystem experiment
Reducing nitrogen inputs increasingly favored nitrogen-fixing cyanobacteria as a response by the phytoplankton community to extreme seasonal nitrogen limitation, and the lake remained highly eutrophic, despite showing indications of extreme nitrogen limitation seasonally. Expand
The effectiveness of cyanobacteria nitrogen fixation: Review of bench top and pilot scale nitrogen removal studies and implications for nitrogen removal programs
One of the primary goals of eutrophication management of freshwater systems is to lower the risk of cyanobacterial blooms by placing controls on phosphorus discharge from point sources, but several researchers have questioned the predominance of the P management paradigm, arguing that dual nitrogen (N) and P controls would be more effective at preventing cyanobacteria blooms than P controls alone. Expand
Pelagic C:N:P Stoichiometry in a Eutrophied Lake: Responses to a Whole-Lake Food-Web Manipulation
The results show that strong effects of food-web structure can occur in eutrophic lakes and that stoichiometric mechanisms play a potentially important role in generating these effects. Expand
Nitrogen Fixation in Canadian Precambrian Shield Lakes
Generally, algal nitrogen fixation occurred in Shield lakes that were subject to total N:total P loading ratios (wt/wt) of less than approximately 10, which suggests that in these lakes phosphorus removal from loading is the best technique for eutrophication abatement and that nitrogen removal, when applied by itself, may be detrimental because it could encourage bloom formation of nitrogen fixing blue-green algae. Expand
N2 fixation exceeds internal nitrogen loading as a phytoplankton nutrient source in perpetually nitrogen-limited reservoirs
It is suggested that, even though the annual cycle of ecosystem N inputs via N2 fixation has occurred over many years or decades in these reservoirs, reactive N accumulation has not been sufficient to alleviate seasonal N deficiency and lead to perpetual P limitation of phytoplankton. Expand
The effects of Daphnia on nutrient stoichiometry and filamentous cyanobacteria: a mesocosm experiment in a eutrophic lake
It is concluded that Daphnia did not cause reductions in cyanobacteria by altering the N : P ratio of available nutrients, and changes in nutrient cycling consistent with other aspects of stoichiometric theory. Expand
Towards an ecological understanding of biological nitrogen fixation
Despite the many groups of organisms capable of fixing N, and the very different ecosystems in which the process is important, it is suggested that common controls provide a foundation for the development of regional and global models that incorporate ecological controls of biological N fixation. Expand
Comment: Lake 227 shows clearly that controlling inputs of nitrogen will not reduce or prevent eutrophication of lakes
The conclusion from our earlier paper, that decreasing nitrogen (N) inputs to lakes does not substantially reduce symptoms of eutrophication (Schindler et al. 2008), was recently challenged by ScottExpand