Bias, Structure, and Injustice: A Reply to Haslanger

  title={Bias, Structure, and Injustice: A Reply to Haslanger},
  author={Robin Zheng},
Sally Haslanger has recently argued that philosophical focus on implicit bias is overly individualist, since social inequalities are best explained in terms of social structures rather than the actions and attitudes of individuals. I argue that questions of individual responsibility and implicit bias, properly understood, do constitute an important part of addressing structural injustice, and I propose an alternative conception of social structure according to which implicit biases are… Expand
17 Citations
What Kind of Responsibility Do We Have for Fighting Injustice? A Moral-Theoretic Perspective on the Social Connections Model
ABSTRACT Iris Marion Young’s influential Social Connections Model (SCM) of responsibility offers a compelling approach to theorizing structural injustice. However, the precise nature of the kind ofExpand
Moral Criticism and Structural Injustice
Moral agency is limited, imperfect, and structurally constrained. This is evident in the many ways we all unwittingly participate in widespread injustice through our everyday actions, which I callExpand
Embodiment & Oppression : Reflections on Haslanger
“As I understand them, feminist and queer theory consist not only in giving an account of the meaning of lives of women and men in all their relational and sexual diversity...Feminist and queerExpand
Social Explanation: Structures, Stories, and Ontology. A Reply to Díaz León, Saul, and Sterken
Abstract In response to commentaries by Esa Díaz León, Jennifer Saul, and Ra- chel Sterken, I develop more fully my views on the role of structure in social and metaphysical explanation. Although IExpand
Moral Responsibility for Racial Oppression
In his recent monograph, (Re-)defining Racism: A Philosophical Analysis (2020), Alberto G. Urquidez invites the reader to take a fresh look at the confused and complicated concept of racism. DrawingExpand
What is My Role in Changing the System? A New Model of Responsibility for Structural Injustice
What responsibility do individuals bear for structural injustice? Iris Marion Young has offered the most fully developed account to date, the Social Connections Model. She argues that we all bearExpand
Reply to My Critics: (Re-)Defining Racism: A Philosophical Analysis
In (Re-)Defining Racism, I offer the first comprehensive examination of the philosophical literature on racism and argue for a new methodological approach that I call conventionalism. Framing myExpand
What is White Ignorance?
In this paper, I identify a theoretical and political role for ‘white ignorance’, present three alternative accounts of white ignorance, and assess how well each fulfils this role. On the WillfulExpand
Response to Inés Valdez’s Review of Injustice and the Reproduction of History: Structural Inequalities, Gender and Redress
Cosmopolitanism—the view that all human beings, independent of their national affiliations, are of equal concern and, thus, that justice applies to the cosmos— may seem a radical theoretical andExpand
Embodiment and Oppression: Reflections on Haslanger
In ‘Cognition as a Social Skill’, Sally Haslanger enhances her theory of oppression with new concepts: ‘mindshaping,’ ‘doxa,’ ‘heterodoxy,’ and ‘hidden transcripts.’ This essay examines these new c...


Attributionism and Moral Responsibility for Implicit Bias
Implicit intergroup biases have been shown to impact social behavior in many unsettling ways, from disparities in decisions to “shoot” black and white men in a computer simulation to unequalExpand
A Plea for Anti-Anti-Individualism: How Oversimple Psychology Misleads Social Policy
This essay responds to the criticism that contemporary efforts to redress discrimination and inequality are overly individualistic. Critics of individualism emphasize that these systemic social illsExpand
Responsibility for Implicit Bias
Philosophers who have written about implicit bias have claimed or implied that individuals are not responsible, and therefore not blameworthy, for their implicit biases, and that this is a functionExpand
Stereotypes, Prejudice, and the Taxonomy of the Implicit Social Mind1
How do cognition and affect interact to produce action? Research in intergroup psychology illuminates this question by investigating the relationship between stereotypes and prejudices about socialExpand
Implicit Bias, Stereotype Threat, and Women in Philosophy
Chapters in this volume and elsewhere show that the number of women in professional philosophy is much lower than the number of men. However, this does not on its own show that there is a problem toExpand
Responsibility for Justice
Foreword Martha C. Nussbaum 1. From Personal to Political Responsibility 2. Structure as the Subject of Justice 3. Guilt versus Responsibility: A Reading and Partial Critique of Hannah Arendt 4. AExpand
Implicit Social Cognition.
The methods that are developed, the findings that have been obtained, and the theoretical questions that remain to be answered are described, which suggest the theory needed to confidently guide those applications remains insufficiently developed. Expand
From Reproduction to Transformation
The point of departure for this article is the observation that, despite his own personal involvement as an engaged intellectual, Pierre Bourdieu offers a very thin account of social movementExpand
Complicity: Ethics and Law for a Collective Age
Acknowledgments 1. Introduction 2. The deep structure of individual accountability 3. Acting together 4. Moral accountability and collective action 5. Complicitous accountability 6. ProblematicExpand
Consciousness, Implicit Attitudes and Moral Responsibility
What role, if any, does consciousness of our reasons for acting play in settling whether we may justifiably be held responsible for our actions? Most philosophers, and ordinary people, seem to assumeExpand