Beyond the antinomies of structure: Levi-Strauss, Giddens, Bourdieu, and Sewell

  title={Beyond the antinomies of structure: Levi-Strauss, Giddens, Bourdieu, and Sewell},
  author={Omar Lizardo},
  journal={Theory and Society},
In this article, I attempt to address some enduring problems in formulation and practical use of the notion of structure in contemporary social science. I begin by revisiting the question of the fidelity of Anthony Giddens’ appropriation of the idea of structure with respect to Levi-Strauss. This requires a reconsideration of Levi-Strauss’ original conceptualization of “social structure” which I argue is a sort of “methodological structuralism” that stands sharply opposed to Giddens… Expand
Monopolization, classification and symbolic violence: Pierre Bourdieu’s contribution to the analysis of State Nationalism
ABSTRACT The study of nationalism is usually split into its macro-sociological dimension and the political and coercive aspects on the one hand, and into micro-sociological, psychological andExpand
Sociology and philosophy in the United States since the sixties: Death and resurrection of a folk action obstacle
This article uses participant objectivation in sociology and philosophy as two knowledge fields to provide a reflexive comparison of their synced field effect in historical circumstances. Drawing onExpand
Toward a really temporalized theory of event: A Luhmannian critique and reconstruction of Sewell’s logics of history
In recent discussions about event as the foundation of historical research, it is William H Sewell Jr who has developed the most comprehensive version. However, Sewell’s theory of the event is notExpand
Deep culture in action: resignification, synecdoche, and metanarrative in the moral panic of the Salem Witch Trials
Sociological research on moral panics, long understood as “struggles for cultural power,” has focused on the social groups and media conditions that enable moral panics to emerge, and on theExpand
The Persistence of the Power Deficit? Advancing Power Premises in Contemporary Interactionist Theory
Abstract This chapter assesses the power focus in contemporary interactionist theory, and advances several premises about power based on recent research and theory. I first examine the mainExpand
Designing a Structure/Agency approach to transnationalism
Research on post-migration processes usually focuses either on micro-level behaviours or on macro-level interactions between states and their diasporas. This paper aims to fill a gap by proposing aExpand
Religion and its modifiers: making sense of the definition and subtypification of a contested concept
Despite the many definitions of religion offered over the years, religion as a general concept remains “essentially contested” and characterized by a multiplicity of competing definitions andExpand
Anchoring depth ontology to epistemological strategies of field theory: exploring the possibility for developing a core for sociological analysis
ABSTRACT Critical realism's insight into depth ontology creates the possibility for re-imagining sociology as a science of the social world. However, critical realism has yet to gain a strongExpand
Translating Bourdieu into youth studies
ABSTRACT Against a backdrop of lively discussion about the best ways to do youth studies, or sociology of youth, this article asks: Can Pierre Bourdieu’s work be translated into youth studies in waysExpand
Fields of Mutual Alignment: A Dual-Order Approach to the Study of Cultural Holes
This article discusses how network-analytic exploitations of the duality of agents and social object enable the study of fields from two analytical vantage points and provides an analytical framework for identifying structurally important social objects through relationships of asymmetrical competition and incommensurability. Expand


The Origins of Levi-Strauss's Structuralism
The paper is concerned with the intellectual origins of Lévi-Strauss's structuralism. In the first section I define this structuralism, arguing that it consists of far more than a simple method,Expand
The strength of weak programs in cultural sociology: A critique of Alexander’s critique of Bourdieu
Jeffrey Alexander’s recent book on cultural sociology argues that sociologists must grant the realm of ideas autonomy to determine behavior, unencumbered by interference from instrumental or materialExpand
The Relative Autonomy of Party Practices: A Counterfactual Analysis of Left Party Ascendancy in Kerala, India, 1934–19401
  • M. Desai
  • Sociology
  • American Journal of Sociology
  • 2002
This article seeks to modify one of the dominant assumptions in the literature on political parties, namely that parties “reflect” the dominant cleavages of a given society. Instead, drawing on theExpand
The Cognitive Structure of a Moral Crusade: Conservative Protestantism and Opposition to Pornography
Research on social movements has once again come to focus on the cultural foundations of collective action. However, previous works have failed to identify the cognitive structures that composeExpand
Sociology without Philosophy? The Case of Giddens's Structuration Theory*
Specification of an appropriate relationship, or division of labor, between sociology and philosophy, remains a sensitive issue. Anthony Giddens offers a distinctive variant in his concern, inExpand
Thinking with Bourdieu against Bourdieu: A ‘Practical’ Critique of the Habitus
There are two strands in Bourdieu's sociological writings. On the one hand, Bourdieu argues for a theoretical position one might term his “practical theory” which emphasizes virtuosic interactionsExpand
Outline of a theory of practice
Pierre Bourdieu develops a theory of practice which is simultaneously a critique of the methods and postures of social science and a general account of how human action should be understood, able to transcend the dichotomies which have shaped theoretical thinking about the social world. Expand
Max Weber: Rationality and Modernity
This book brings together leading figures in history, sociology, political science, feminism and critical theory to interpret, evaluate, criticize and update Weber's legacy. In a collection ofExpand
Advances in generative structuralism: Structured agency and multilevel dynamics
We set out an approach to theorizing termed generative structuralism. In two stages, respectively, we address two problems in social theory ‐ agency‐structure and micro‐macro linkage ‐ in relation toExpand
Morphogenesis versus structuration: on combining structure and action. 1982.
  • M. Archer
  • Sociology, Medicine
  • The British journal of sociology
  • 2010
The fundamental problem of linking human agency and social structure stalks through the history of sociological theory. Basically it concerns how to develop an adequate theoretical account whichExpand