Beyond crusades: how (not) to engage with alternative archaeologies

  title={Beyond crusades: how (not) to engage with alternative archaeologies},
  author={Cornelius Holtorf},
  journal={World Archaeology},
  pages={544 - 551}
  • C. Holtorf
  • Published 1 December 2005
  • Sociology
  • World Archaeology
Abstract Archaeologists have often felt uneasy when encountering alternative (fringe, cult, fantastic, pseudo-) archaeologies. Some have suggested that alternative approaches and their results must be disproved, while others have been calling for better public understanding of science. My contribution takes a different point of view. I emphasize the social and cultural needs that both scientific and alternative archaeologies address and suggest that the main significance of archaeology does not… 

Do you even know what public archaeology is? Trends, theory, practice, ethics

Abstract Archaeology is a discipline influenced by emerging cultural trends, especially with regard to theoretical approaches to interpretation and practice. Public archaeology is a relatively young

Are We There Yet? Archaeology and the Postmodern in the New Millennium

The present text discusses the significance of the postmodern condition in contemporary archaeology. Five themes associated with postmodernism are discussed (a) the relativization of truth,

'The Bible in Stone': Pyramids, Lost Tribes and Alternative Archaeologies

Abstract Fascination with the Great Pyramid of Khufu is one of the cornerstones of alternative archaeology, with mystical or prophetic significance attached to its every dimension and measurement. In

Collaborate, Condemn, or Ignore? Responding to Non-Archaeological Approaches to Archaeological Heritage

What do archaeologists do when approached by groups or individuals with unorthodox, or even simply inappropriate, approaches to, and ideas about the past? What should they do? While much guidance and

Addressing the Alien in the Room: Why Public Perception is Imperative to the Field of Archaeology

Pseudoscience in archaeology, or pseudoarchaeology, are ideas formed by distrust, with minimal observable evidence that explain the human past. In a world of widespread, accessible misinformation,

de Soto (Probably) Never Slept Here: Archaeology, Memory, Myth, and Social Identity

Accounts of the expedition of Spanish conquistador Hernando de Soto to Southeastern North America (1539–43 CE) provide the first written descriptions of the Indigenous peoples and physical geography

Cinema, Supernatural Archaeology, and the Hidden Human Past

Abstract Close analysis of modern movies reveals — yet archaeologists and historians have failed to understand — that the dominant representation of archaeological research and ancient human culture

‘Giant Strides’ in Documentaries, ‘Ascents’ in Archaeology: Nautical Archaeology's Relationship with and Place within Popular Culture

This article covers 30 years of the representation of nautical archaeology on television. It criticises and positions current research, then develops an objective methodology for examining television

The Place of Folklore in Archaeological Landscapes: Narratives and Identity in Medieval to Modern Britain

This research explores the relationship between archaeology and folklore through folk narratives about sites and landscapes in Britain and their association with changing socio-political contexts

Introduction: New Perspectives in Global Public Archaeology

Since its very beginning, archaeology has in many senses always related to a much wider constituency than just archaeologists. Archaeological excavations, for example, have affected and been affected



Archaeological messages and messengers

Abstract Archaeological resources include important places and objects of commemoration and remembrance. Properly investigated, they provide interpretations of pasts that are often inaccessible

The Ancient Maya and the Political Present

  • R. Wilk
  • Sociology
    Journal of Anthropological Research
  • 1985
Can archaelogists depict the past with any accuracy, and is that their goal? Where do archaeologists' ideas come from in the first place? This paper suggests that archaeological discourse has a dual

Cult Archaeology and Creationism: Understanding Pseudoscientific Beliefs About the Past

UFOs and aliens, unexplained mysteries, religious cults, diffusion, creationism. We are all familiar with beliefs about human life that lie outside traditional scientific boundaries. Notions such as

Cult Archaeology and Unscientific Method and Theory

On archaeology and alterity.

Responding effectively to aItemative ideas about humanity's past is a growing concern for many archaeologists, as popular television programs, the Internet, and best-selling books

Folk Archaeology in Anthropological Perspective

Criticizing a variety of popular approaches to the past that violate professional canon, archaeologists claim the high ground, moral as well as scholarly. The collection of folk ideas in question,

The religious use of prehistoric imagery in contemporary goddess spirituality

Abstract For archaeologists, the principal value of prehistoric figurines is that they offer a means – however limited – into the cultures and lives of prehistoric peoples. There is a long tradition

Frauds, Myths, and Mysteries: Science and Pseudoscience in Archaeology

A comparison of the hypotheses and approaches of pseudo-archaeologists to those of archaeologists and other scientists. By describing the flaws in the purported evidence for each claim, the author

Why queer archaeology? An introduction

(2000). Why queer archaeology? An introduction. World Archaeology: Vol. 32, Queer Archaeologies, pp. 161-165.

Notes on the Underground: An Essay on Technology, Society, and the Imagination

The underworld as a vision of the technological future excavations 1 - digging down to the truth excavations 2 - creating the substructure of modern life underground aesthetics - from sublimity to