Beyond Legislative Veto Power: The Transformative Effects of the Early Warning System for Subsidiarity Control Ten Years Down the Line

  title={Beyond Legislative Veto Power: The Transformative Effects of the Early Warning System for Subsidiarity Control Ten Years Down the Line},
  author={Karolina Borońska-Hryniewiecka},
  journal={Pol{\'i}tica y Sociedad},
The majority of European Union (EU) studies tend to be critical of the Early Warning System (EWS) for subsidiarity control, deeming it as ineffective in blocking unwanted EU legislation. Against this background, the aim of this paper is to identify and discuss several transformative effects of the EWS connected with the quality and democratic character of the EU governance, beyond the tool’s legislative veto power. A critical review of the EWS’ interpretations as an accountability mechanism… 


Democratising the European Multi-level Polity? A (Re-)Assessment of the Early Warning System
One of the main promises of the Treaty of Lisbon was to increase the democratic legitimacy of the European Union through strengthening the role of national parliaments in EU policy-making under the
Beyond subsidiarity: the indirect effect of the Early Warning System on national parliamentary scutiny in European Union affairs
ABSTRACT The Early Warning System (EWS) introduced with the Lisbon Treaty allows national parliaments to directly intervene in European Union (EU) decision-making for the first time. Most scholars
Domesticating the Democratic Deficit? The Role of National Parliaments and Parties in the EU’s System of Governance
The Lisbon Treaty (LT) grounds the European Union (EU) in the principles of political equality and representative democracy. It also acknowledges the role national parliaments play in realizing these
National parliaments in the democratic politics of the EU: the subsidiarity early warning mechanism, 2009–2017
  • I. Cooper
  • Political Science
    Comparative European Politics
  • 2018
With the Early Warning Mechanism (EWM), the Treaty of Lisbon empowered national parliaments to collectively intervene in the EU’s legislative process. Yet at first glance their impact seems to have
Differential Europeanization? Explaining the impact of the early warning system on subnational parliaments in Europe
The inclusion of subnational parliaments into the early warning system (EWS) for subsidiarity control generates transforming dynamics in parliamentary modus operandi in European Union (EU)
The Game of Cards: National Parliaments in the EU and the Future of the Early Warning Mechanism and the Political Dialogue
The article analyses the subsidiarity guardianship function of national parliaments and argues that, while a positive development, the current concept and practice of subsidiarity monitoring do not
Why the Early Warning Mechanism does not Alleviate the Democratic Deficit
This paper discusses the effects of the Early Warning Mechanism, introduced in the Treaty of Lisbon, on democracy in the European Union. It argues that the mechanism does not contribute to democracy
Destined for Irrelevance? Subsidiarity Control by National Parliaments
The Lisbon Treaty introduced the "early-warning mechanism", with national legislatures assigned the right to monitor whether initiatives for EU laws comply with the principle of subsidiarity. Does
Beyond Institutional Capacity: Political Motivation and Parliamentary Behaviour in the Early Warning System
The Early Warning System gives national parliaments the right to intervene in European Union policy-making. This article investigates their incentives to submit reasoned opinions. It analyses the
“Yellow card, but no foul”: The role of the national parliaments under the subsidiarity protocol and the Commission proposal for an EU regulation on the right to strike
The article analyses the role of the national Parliaments under the Subsidiarity Protocol, taking the recent Commission proposal for a regulation on the exercise of the right to strike and the