Beyond Asimov: The Three Laws of Responsible Robotics

@article{Murphy2009BeyondAT,
  title={Beyond Asimov: The Three Laws of Responsible Robotics},
  author={Robin R. Murphy and David D. Woods},
  journal={IEEE Intelligent Systems},
  year={2009},
  volume={24}
}
Asimov's three laws of robotics have been inculcated so successfully into our culture that they now appear to shape expectations as to how robots should act around humans. However, there has been little serious discussion as to whether the laws really do provide a framework for human-robot interactions. Asimov actually used his laws as a literary device to explore the lack of resilience in the interplay between people and robots in a range of situations. This paper briefly reviews some of the… 

Tables from this paper

Empowerment As Replacement for the Three Laws of Robotics
TLDR
This work makes a concrete, operational proposal as to how the information-theoretic concept of empowerment can be used as a generic heuristic to quantify concepts such as self-preservation, protection of the human partner and responding to human actions.
Bridging the Ethical Gap: From Human Principles to Robot Instructions
TLDR
The characterization of the ethical gap leads to a proposal for a shift in focus away from the autonomous behavior of the robot to human-robot communication at the interface, and the development of interdependence rules to underpin the process of ethical decision-making.
An architecture for ethical robots
TLDR
A control architecture that supplements existing robot controllers is presented that ensures robots behave according to a predetermined set of ethical rules by predicting the outcomes of possible actions and evaluating the predicted outcomes against those rules.
Responsible Robotics and Responsibility Attribution
TLDR
The proposal here is to extend the three alternative laws of responsible robotics into a more robust framework for responsibility attribution as part of the responsible robotics goal.
Symbiosis with artificial intelligence via the prism of law, robots, and society
The rapid advances in Artificial Intelligence and Robotics will have a profound impact on society as they will interfere with the people and their interactions. Intelligent autonomous robots,
The evitability of autonomous robot warfare
Abstract This is a call for the prohibition of autonomous lethal targeting by free-ranging robots. This article will first point out the three main international humanitarian law (IHL)/ethical issues
The rights and wrongs of robotics: Ethics and robots in public organizations
Some electronics experts believe that robots, like present-day computers, will be commonplace. A diverse assortment of robots, with varying purposes, capacities, forms, and sizes, is emerging with
Towards a Science of Resilient Robotic Autonomy
TLDR
Resilience and its key characteristics relating to robustness, redundancy, and resourcefulness are discussed, followed by a selected - but not exhaustive - list of research themes and domains that are crucial to facilitate resilient autonomy.
Roboethics principles and policies in Europe and North America
Robotics and artificial intelligence (AI) are revolutionizing all spheres of human life. From industrial processes to graphic design, the implementation of automated intelligent systems is changing
Robots Autonomy: Some Technical Issues
  • C. Tessier
  • Art
    Autonomy and Artificial Intelligence
  • 2017
TLDR
The conclusion shows that many questions have to be answered through research and technical work so as to make sure that robots and autonomous machines will be beneficial for society.
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 24 REFERENCES
Asimov's Laws of Robotics: Implications for Information Technology - Part 2
TLDR
The Laws of Robotics were primarily a literary device intended to support a series of stories about robot behavior, but over time they revealed problems that might later confront real roboticists and information technologists attempting to establish rules for the behavior of intelligent machines.
Three laws of robotics and surgery.
INTRODUCTION In 1939, Isaac Asimov solidified the modern science fiction genre of robotics in his short story "Strange Playfellow" but altered our thinking about robots in Runaround in 1942 by
Asimov’s “three laws of robotics” and machine metaethics
TLDR
Using Asimov’s “Bicentennial Man” as a springboard, a number of metaethical issues concerning the emerging field of machine ethics are discussed and it is argued that Asimov's “three laws of robotics” are an unsatisfactory basis for machine ethics, regardless of the status of the machine.
Moral Machines: Teaching Robots Right from Wrong
Computers are already approving financial transactions, controlling electrical supplies, and driving trains. Soon, service robots will be taking care of the elderly in their homes, and military
Wendell Wallach and Colin Allen: Moral machines: teaching robots right from wrong
TLDR
It is incumbent upon anyone with a stake in this technology to address head-on the task of implementing moral decision making in computers, robots and virtual ‘‘bots’’ within computer networks, and it is concluded that Wallach and Allen are committed to building machines that are capable of telling right from wrong.
Why Machine Ethics?
TLDR
Machine ethics is an emerging field that seeks to implement moral decision-making faculties in computers and robots that violate ethical standards as a matter of course.
Lethality and Autonomous Robots: An Ethical Stance
TLDR
This paper addresses a difficult issue confronting the designers of intelligent robotic systems: their potential use of lethality in warfare, as well as developing methods to engineer ethical safeguards into their use in the battlefield.
Just Culture: Balancing Safety and Accountability
TLDR
In this book, the author explores the importance, risks, and benefits of reporting and disclosing human errors and challenges the reader with intriguing and interesting questions.
Joint Cognitive Systems: Patterns in Cognitive Systems Engineering
Preface CORE ACTIVITIES AND VALUES Adaptability versus Limits Complementarity Core Values of CSE in Practice On Systems in CSE Patterns Discovering Patterns in Joint Cognitive Systems at Work A JCS
...
...