Autonomy in Neuroethics: Political and Not Metaphysical

  title={Autonomy in Neuroethics: Political and Not Metaphysical},
  author={Veljko Dubljevi{\'c}},
  journal={AJOB Neuroscience},
  pages={44 - 51}
This article examines and refutes the claims that neuroscientific evidence renders autonomy “quixotic” and thus supports a shift toward paternalism in medical and political decision-making. The author argues that the notion of autonomy has been mistakenly associated with the metaphysical concept of free will, and offers a political definition of autonomy to clarify how responsibility is implicitly grounded in the legal and political system: An agent acts autonomously when she/he (a) endorses… Expand
Autonomy is Political, Pragmatic, and Postmetaphysical: A Reply to Open Peer Commentaries on “Autonomy in Neuroethics”
In a target article (Dubljevi c 2013), I concluded that the moral–political notion of autonomy was mistakenly associated with the metaphysical concept of “free will.” Although there are importantExpand
The Illusion of Post Hoc Autonomy
Veljko Dubljević (2013) resolves the “quixotic” nature of autonomy by drawing a distinction between autonomy as a political construct and free will as a metaphysical abstraction. According toExpand
Autonomy as a Negotiated Concept: The Case of Informed Consent
On the broad question of autonomy as more political than metaphysical, Dubljević’s arguments (2013) are useful and worth serious consideration. What I argue here is that indeed autonomy inExpand
The Importance of the Self for Autonomous Behavior
Neuroscientific findings have often been argued to undermine notions of free will and to require far-reaching changes of our political and legal systems. Making a difference between the metaphysicalExpand
Is the Proposal of the Political Notion of Autonomy Problematic?
  • Veljko Dubljević
  • Psychology
  • The International Library of Ethics, Law and Technology
  • 2019
My prior work on autonomy (see Dubljevic in Am J Bioeth Neurosci 4(4):44–51, 2013 and Chap. 3) took up the challenge posed by Felsen and Reiner (Am J Bioeth Neurosci 2(3):3–14, 2011) to substantiallyExpand
The Metaphysical Assumptions Required for Political Autonomy
person’s circumstances decisively warrant it? Though the truth of determinism wouldn’t erase the significance of choice when deciding who to compensate, it does presumably reduce the weight it shouldExpand
Autonomy, Free Will, and a Rational Life-Plan: A Practical Perspective
According to Dubljević (2013), there is a conflation of the metaphysical concept of free will with the moral-political concept of autonomy. Because of this conflation, concerns about free willExpand
A Blurry Line Between Metaphysical Free Will and Autonomy in Addiction
actual initial factors most of us would consider necessary to make an autonomous decision. We can easily imagine an analogous scenario, albeit with a normal adult like Jimmy, who offers an entirelyExpand
Judging Deeds, Not Psychopaths
The target article, “What We Owe the Psychopath: A Neuroethical Analysis” (Gillett and Huang 2013), argues that we need to rethink our attitudes toward psychopaths because they are both victims andExpand
Autonomy and justice in neuroethics of cognitive enhancement
A great number of existing, emerging and hypothetical technologies offers the possibility of neuroenhancement of human beings, promising (or threatening) to drastically change the lives of citizens.Expand


Toward A New Model of Autonomy: Lessons From Neuroscience
In “How the Neuroscience of Decision Making Informs Our Conception of Autonomy,” Gidon Felsen and Peter Reiner (2011) argue that decisions typically regarded as rational and autonomous are in factExpand
How the Neuroscience of Decision Making Informs Our Conception of Autonomy
Autonomy, the ability to make decisions for ourselves about ourselves, is among the most prized of human liberties. In this review we reconsider the key conditions necessary for autonomous decisionExpand
Full Autonomy, Substantial Autonomy, and Neuroscience
In their article “How the Neuroscience of Decision Making Informs Our Conception of Autonomy,” Gidon Felsen and Peter Reiner (2011) argue that the neuroscience evidence they present calls intoExpand
Autonomy, responsibility and the oscillation of preference
Publisher Summary This chapter argues how the claim that the behaviors characteristic of addiction are voluntary does not entail either that the disease model of addiction is wrong or that addictsExpand
Reviewing Autonomy: Implications of the Neurosciences and the Free Will Debate for the Principle of Respect for the Patient's Autonomy
The concept of autonomy should be elaborated further, built on recent developments within the neurosciences and the free will debate, and some important elements of autonomy are neglected. Expand
The illusion of conscious will
Wegner (Wegner, D. (2002). The illusion of conscious will. MIT Press) argues that conscious will is an illusion, citing a wide range of empirical evidence. I shall begin by surveying some of hisExpand
Neuroscientific challenges to free will and responsibility
  • A. Roskies
  • Psychology, Medicine
  • Trends in Cognitive Sciences
  • 2006
Three reasons are provided to think that neuroethical concerns about challenges to the authors' conception of freedom are misguided. Expand
Addiction Neuroethics: The Promises and Perils of Neuroscience Research on Addiction
Drug addiction is a significant problem facing most societies. It is associated with increased violence, crime and mental illness, and is one of the leading causes of preventable mortality andExpand
Rationality and Compulsion: Applying Action Theory to Psychiatry
The author begins by clearly outlining the three basic purposes of the book. The first is to introduce philosophical action theory. The second is to develop concepts central to the text, such asExpand
Principles of Biomedical Ethics, 5th edn.
The Principles of Biomedical Ethics by Beauchamp and Childress is a classic in the field of medical ethics. The first edition was published in 1979 and “unleashed” the four principles of respect forExpand