Corpus ID: 18713223

Auditor Independence, Conflict of Interest, and the Unconscious Intrusion of Bias

  title={Auditor Independence, Conflict of Interest, and the Unconscious Intrusion of Bias},
  author={D. Moore and G. Loewenstein and Lloyd Tanlu and M. Bazerman},
Information about the financial health of public companies provided by auditors ideally allow s investors to make informed decisions and enhances the efficiency of financial market s. However, under the current system auditors are hired and fired by the companies they audit , which introduces incentives for biases that favor the audited companies. Three experim nts demonstrate bias in auditors' judgments, and show that these biases are not easily cor rected because auditors are not fully aware… Expand

Figures from this paper

Professional independence and attachment bias: An exploratory study
Policy makers have focused on auditor independence-related reforms to address the perceived loss of credibility in financial reporting that followed major accounting scandals from late 2001.Expand
Hospitality and auditor independence: do gifts blind the eyes?
Abstract In the Chinese audit market, some firms provide hospitality to their auditors. There is a well-known saying in China: ‘Gifts blind the eyes and there is no such thing as a free lunch’. TheExpand
A Review of Experimental and Archival Conflicts-of-Interest Research in Auditing
I review empirical (archival and experimental) accounting research that has addressed the issue of conflicts of interest, focusing on the audit setting that has received so much recent attention. IExpand
Findings on the Effects of Audit Firm Rotation on the Audit Process under Varying Strengths of Corporate Governance
Abstract While performing an annual audit of a client's financial statements, an audit firm's staff identified what seems to be a material misstatement. Two discussions with the client have led to anExpand
Joint Audit – A Means to Reduce Bias and Enhance Scepticism in Financial Statement Audits?
This paper proposes a contribution of joint audit to audit quality through the mitigation of cognitive bias during the audit process, a potential largely overlooked in the prior literature. WithExpand
Why auditors are unable to see their own behavior as others do: Understanding a potential blind spot
Auditors are obligated to perform audits that are both effective and efficient. Audit firms train their auditors to avoid behaviors such as taking shortcuts (i.e., ignoring inconsistencies that theyExpand
Auditors : their mindset and their decisions
Schwitzgebel (2009) finds that ethicists are more likely to steal books from the library than other library users. Now the question is: Would the auditor trained in ethics have avoided TescoExpand
The Effect of auditor-provided non-audit services on auditor independence and Sarbanes-Oxley: What separates tax services from other non-audit services?
Objectives of the Study The Sarbanes-Oxley Act prohibited a large number of individual auditor-provided non-audit services, which were seen to have a negative effect on auditor independence. TaxExpand
Bias in the boardroom Effects of bias on the quality of board decision-making
Good boardroom decision-making can be facilitated by appropriate policies and processes. However, even when combined with well-intentioned and competent directors, such policies and processes may notExpand
Completing and Corroborating the Model of Auditor-Client Negotiation about Accounting Issues by Comparing Auditor and Chief Financial Officer Views
Much attention is beginning to be paid to auditor client management negotiation as a result of recent events in the financial world. Gibbins, Salterio and Webb [GSW 2001] developed an accountingExpand


The Impossibility of Auditor Independence
The growing number of audit failures leads the authors to question the current auditing relationship. In no profession is impartiality more important than in auditing, they say. Yet psychologicalExpand
Auditing, Consulting, And Auditor Independence
The question of whether an auditor should also provide management advisory services (MAS) to an audit client has been extensively debated. On the one hand, the Metcalf Committee Staff Study [1976,Expand
Why good accountants do bad audits.
True auditor independence will entail fundamental changes to the way the accounting industry operates, including full divestiture of consulting and tax services, rotation of auditing firms, and fixed-term contracts that prohibit client companies from firing their auditors. Expand
An Experimental Investigation of Self‐Serving Biases in an Auditing Trust Game: The Effect of Group Affiliation
It is found that manager‐subjects use noncredible communications to induce auditors to develop an unwarranted trust of managers (i.e., a biased judgment), which calls into question the Bazerman et al. (1997) conclusion that auditors cannot conduct impartial audits due to self‐serving biases resulting from repeated interactions between auditors and their clients. Expand
Auditor size and audit quality
Abstract Regulators and small audit firms allege that audit firm size does not affect audit quality and therefore should be irrelevant in the selection of an auditor. Contrary to this view, theExpand
Contingent rents and auditors' independence: Appearance vs fact
Abstract A common theme in discussions of auditors' independence is the concern that provision of nonaudit services may compromise auditors' independence. We use a simple model to show that althoughExpand
Explaining Bargaining Impasse: The Role of Self-Serving Biases
The authors review studies conducted by themselves and coauthors that document a 'self-serving' bias in judgments of fairness and demonstrate that the bias is an important cause of impasse inExpand
The Relation between Auditors' Fees for Nonaudit Services and Earnings Management
This paper examines whether auditor fees are associated with earnings management and the market reaction to the disclosure of auditor fees. Using data collected from proxy statements, we presentExpand
Biased Judgments of Fairness in Bargaining
When court trials (or arbitration) are the mechanisms for resolving bargaining impasses, the costs and risks associated with third-party intervention should motivate settlement (Henry Farber andExpand
First Impressions Matter: A Model of Confirmatory Bias
Psychological research indicates that people have a cognitive bias that leads them to misinterpret new information as supporting previously held hypotheses. We model such confirmatory bias in aExpand