Archaeology at the Heart of a Political Confrontation

  title={Archaeology at the Heart of a Political Confrontation},
  author={Shereen Ratnagar},
  journal={Current Anthropology},
  pages={239 - 259}
Despite its recourse to scientific (laboratory) investigations, archaeology is a social science, researching the cultures of past societies through their material culture residues. No social science proceeds in an ideological vacuum, and historians or geographers who claim not to be theoretical may simply be unaware of the conceptual or ideological underpinnings of the paradigms they use. Being “apolitical,” in turn, often amounts to an acceptance of the status quo. Thus archaeological methods… 
‘Order’-ing Excavations: Constitution of Archaeology as Legal Evidence in the Ayodhya Case
This paper examines the case of the court-ordered excavations at Ayodhya to understand the process by which archaeological evidence as expert opinion was reconfigured into judicial evidence in a
THROUGH WARY EYES: Indigenous Perspectives on Archaeology
AbstractArchaeology has been linked to colonialist attitudes and scientific imperialism. But what are the perspectives of Indigenous groups concerning the practice of archaeology? Numerous
Social and Political Factors in Post-Colonial Indian Archaeology: The Case of Sanghol, Punjab
In this paper, I present the case of Sanghol, Punjab, in Indian archaeology to highlight the influence of social and political factors on the interpretation of archaeological data and the
What do spatial approaches to the history of archaeology tell us?: Insights from post-colonial India
Archaeologists increasingly find themselves confronting members of local communities, raising the question: who owns cultural heritage and the interpretation of archaeological data? In this paper I
Human evolution and culture change in the Indian subcontinent
Given the extraordinary discoveries of human fossils in Africa, the fascinating finds of cave art in Western Europe, and the antiquity of agriculture in the Fertile Crescent, one may wonder, why
Anthropological, historical, archaeological and genetic perspectives on the origins of caste in South Asia
A volume that addresses the population diversity, both past and present, of South Asia must obviously include a discussion of caste. The institution of caste undoubtedly plays, and may well long have
Heritage and corruption: the two faces of the nation-state
Nation-states’ investment in heritage supports Benedict Anderson’s thesis that nationalism offers collective immortality in the face of individual mortality. By the same token, however, corruption –
Spatial Cleansing
This article comprises preliminary remarks about spatiality and power, with a particular focus on field data from Greece and Thailand (with secondary materials from Italy). I suggest that the
The Archaeology of South Asia: From the Indus to Asoka, c.6500 BCE-200 CE
Part I. The Context: 1. Introduction and definitions 2. Environment and culture: South Asia's environmental, linguistic and religious patterns 3. Histories of South Asian archaeology Part II. The
Hindutva, Mythistory, and Pseudoarchaeology
Abstract This essay elucidates ideologically-inspired interpretations of the South Asian archeological record, particularly by those called Hindutvādins, and those who write about (and against) them.


Facts on the ground : archaeological practice and territorial self-fashioning in Israeli society
Archaeology in Israel is truly a national obsession, a practice through which national identity and national rights have long been asserted. But how and why did archaeology emerge as such a pervasive
Archaeology and identity in south Asia — interpretations and consequences
Whilst archaeological discoveries initiated by the Europeans have long encouraged a pride in India's past among its educated elite, there is even less evidence of nationalism influencing the practice
A Place in History: Social and Monumental Time in a Cretan Town
Michael Herzfeld describes what happens when a bureaucracy charged with historic conservation clashes with a local populace hostile to the state and suspicious of tourism. Focusing on the Cretan town
The Political Economy of Archaeology in the United States
▪ Abstract The professionalization of archaeology in the late nineteenth century was linked to the growth of antiquities markets and the development of museums as institutions of education and social
The past as propaganda: totalitarian archaeology in Nazi Germany
An important element to the future of archaeology in the ex-Communist countries of central Europe will be the freeing of archaeological ideas from the constraints of a particular set of social
Alternative Archaeologies: Nationalist, Colonialist, Imperialist
This article examines similarities and differences in the questions that prehistoric archaeologists ask and the answers that they are predisposed to accept as reasonable in different parts of the
A tale of three sites: The monumentalization of Celtic oppida and the politics of collective memory and identity
Abstract Three fortified hilltop settlements (oppida) of the ‘Celtic’ Iron Age have been resurrected in recent history as symbolic focal points in the highly politicized construction of collective
Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism
What makes people love and die for nations, as well as hate and kill in their name? While many studies have been written on nationalist political movements, the sense of nationality - the personal
The Last Sixty Years: Toward a Social History of Americanist Archeology in the United States
This paper provides an overview of the development of Americanist archeology in the United States. Since the 1920s, there have been two, and sometimes more, interpretive communities among
caste, colonialism, and the speech of the colonized: entextualization and disciplinary control in India
In the wake of rebellion and other crises of colonial rule in mid-19th-century India, particular varieties of oral folklore began to appear in land settlement reports, official glossaries and