Applicant Reactions in Selection: Comprehensive Meta-Analysis into Reaction Generalization Versus Situational Specificity

  title={Applicant Reactions in Selection: Comprehensive Meta-Analysis into Reaction Generalization Versus Situational Specificity},
  author={Neil R. Anderson and Jes{\'u}s F. Salgado and Ute R. H{\"u}lsheger},
  journal={O\&M: Personnel Management eJournal},
This paper reports a comprehensive quantitative summary into applicant reactions to popular methods of employee selection. A detailed search of published and unpublished studies resulted in a final sample (k) of 38 independent samples covering 10 popular candidate assessment methods. Applicant reactions primary studies included samples from 17 countries internationally. Counter to previous suggestions for the situational specificity of applicant reactions, findings showed considerable… 
Applicant Reactions in Saudi Arabia: Organizational Attractiveness and Core‐Self Evaluation
This paper reports findings from a survey into applicant reactions of working adults in Saudi Arabia. A sample of 193 participants from four job functions was obtained, with measures of
Improving Applicant Reactions to Forced-Choice Personality Measurement: Interventions to Reduce Threats to Test Takers’ Self-Concepts
Previous research has demonstrated that selection decision making is improved with the use of valid pre-employment assessments, but these assessments can often engender negative reactions on the part
Applicant reactions are similar across countries: A refined replication with assessment center data from the European Union.
Abstract. Many organizations receive applications from people from different countries, and this is reflected in the research interest in cross-cultural differences in applicant reactions. The
Applicant reactions to selection procedures: Method validity, cost, and utility
This paper gives an introduction to the impact of new technologies in the field of selection of applicants to job positions. We present two established theories intended to explain applicants’
Applicant Reactions to Selection Methods in China
This study examines applicant reactions to ten popular selection methods in China. Using a sample of 294 graduates we found that Chinese applicants’ reactions were highly favorable for work sample
Applicants reaction towards the personnel selection methods in Pakistan
Abstract The purpose of this study is to investigate applicants’ reactions towards different personnel selection methods used in Pakistan. A sample of 149 undergraduates, graduates, and working
A Dispositional Approach to Applicant Reactions: Examining Core Self-Evaluations, Behavioral Intentions, and Fairness Perceptions
PurposeDrawing from core self-evaluations (CSE) theory, we argue and demonstrate that disposition plays an important role in explaining the way job applicants respond to testing procedures in the
Applying Organizational Justice Theory to Admission into Higher Education: Admission from a Student Perspective
Applicant perceptions of methods used in admission procedures to higher education were investigated using organizational justice theory. Applicants to a psychology study program completed a
Applicant Reactions as a Function of Test Length
Abstract. This study investigated how the length of preemployment assessments affects applicant reactions to the testing process and organization. Using a between-subjects design, participants took
INDIVIDUAL DIFFERENCES AND APPLICANT PERCEPTIONS 1 Effects of Individual Differences on Applicant Perceptions of an Operational Assessment
Knowing to what extent applicant reactions are related to stable individual differences and not only to characteristics of a selection procedure is important for the design and administration of the


Applicant Reactions to Selection Procedures: An Updated Model and Meta-Analysis
An updated theoretical model of applicant reactions to selection procedures is proposed and tested using meta-analysis. Results from 86 independent samples (N= 48,750) indicated that applicants who
We note that applicant reactions to selection procedures may be of practical importance to employers because of influences on organizations’attractiveness to candidates, ethical and legal issues, and
Effects of Explanations on Applicant Reactions: A Meta-Analytic Review
One cost effective way to improve applicant reactions is by giving explanations. Although a literature on this topic has accumulated, the effects of explanations on applicant reactions have not been
Reactions to Selection Methods: An International Comparison
This paper reviews the nature of applicant reactions to recruitment and selection methods from the standpoint of perceived procedural fairness of the selection methods used. Following the research of
The Status of Research on Applicant Reactions to Selection Tests and its Implications for Managers
The status of research on applicant reactions to selection tests was reviewed. Four areas of concern were identified. First, more work on construct validation of applicant reactions, which includes
This paper describes research that fills a void in the applicant reactions literature by developing a comprehensive measure of Gilliland's (1993) procedural justice rules, called the Selection
Applicant reactions to alternative selection procedures
The present study solicited the reactions of 390 current and future job seekers to 13 selection procedures. Results suggest that applicants prefer selection methods with high apparent content
Fairness reactions to personnel selection techniques in France and the United States
The authors examined the bases for fairness reactions to different selection practices and considered cross-cultural differences in these reactions by comparing respondents from 2 cultures. College
Les réactions des candidats envers les techniques de sélection du personnel : une étude dans un contexte francophone
This study examined, first, the reactions of job applicants to selection techniques and, second, the relationships between favorability judgments and other reactions of job applicants. The study was
Fairness Reactions to Selection Methods: An Italian Study
This study examined the fairness reactions to 10 personnel selection methods in a sample of Italian students. University students (N=137) were asked to rate the favorability of these selection