Appealing to fear: A meta-analysis of fear appeal effectiveness and theories.

@article{Tannenbaum2015AppealingTF,
  title={Appealing to fear: A meta-analysis of fear appeal effectiveness and theories.},
  author={Melanie B. Tannenbaum and Justin Hepler and Rick S. Zimmerman and Lindsey Saul and Samantha Jacobs and Kristina Wilson and Dolores Albarrac{\'i}n},
  journal={Psychological bulletin},
  year={2015},
  volume={141 6},
  pages={
          1178-204
        }
}
Fear appeals are a polarizing issue, with proponents confident in their efficacy and opponents confident that they backfire. We present the results of a comprehensive meta-analysis investigating fear appeals' effectiveness for influencing attitudes, intentions, and behaviors. We tested predictions from a large number of theories, the majority of which have never been tested meta-analytically until now. Studies were included if they contained a treatment group exposed to a fear appeal, a valid… 

Figures and Tables from this paper

Self- and Response Efficacy Information in Fear Appeals: A Meta-Analysis
Fear appeals are designed to inspire intended and actual actions to avert a danger. Although prior meta-analyses report that the average effect of fear appeals is moderately positive, the role of
Examining the Effectiveness of Fear Appeals in Prompting Help-Seeking: The Case of At-Risk Gamblers
With a sample of Australian at-risk gamblers, this research examines the impact of gender and individual difference in experiential avoidance (EA; cognitive and emotional suppression) on the
Ignoring theory and misinterpreting evidence: the false belief in fear appeals
TLDR
It is concluded that extant empirical evidence does not support positive effects of fear appeals, and their use persists and is even promoted by health psychology researchers, causing scientific insights to be ignored or misinterpreted.
Fear appeals to promote better health behaviors: an investigation of potential mediators
TLDR
Compared the impact of three versions of an existing online course on how to prevent noncommunicable diseases, perceived efficacy was positively associated with intention to change behavior, as well as with lower suppression, lower reappraisal, and greater denial.
Meta-Analysis of Anger and Persuasion: An Empirical Integration of Four Models
Despite the increasing use of anger in persuasive messaging, such as political ads and health campaigns, very little is known about when and how anger affects persuasion. Building on theoretical
How Scary Are Threat Appeals? Evaluating the Intensity of Fear in Experimental Research
One long-standing concern holds that much is unknown about the operation of threat appeals because practical and ethical matters preclude the use of seriously frightening messages. This project
The Moderating Role of Self-construal in Culturally Reflected Fear Appeals
TLDR
This study found that self-construal moderates the effects of reference type on perceived threat and perceived threat to freedom and self-efficacy.
The effectiveness of a positively vs. negatively valenced PSA against sexually transmitted diseases – evidence from an experimental study
TLDR
Findings provide further evidence for carefully using fear appeals in persuasive health communication and speak in favor of integrating positive emotional appeals in these contexts.
This May Come As a Surprise: How Prior Knowledge of Information in a Fear Appeal is Associated with Message Outcomes
ABSTRACT Two related studies were performed aimed at finding if and how prior knowledge of threat and efficacy information in a fear appeal message is associated with message outcomes (attitude and
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 278 REFERENCES
Threatening communication: a critical re-analysis and a revised meta-analytic test of fear appeal theory
TLDR
A meta-analysis of six studies that satisfied the inclusion criteria clearly showed a significant interaction between threat and efficacy, such that threat only had an effect under high efficacy, and efficacy only had aeffect under high threat.
A Meta-Analysis of Fear Appeals: Implications for Effective Public Health Campaigns
  • K. WitteM. Allen
  • Business, Psychology
    Health education & behavior : the official publication of the Society for Public Health Education
  • 2000
TLDR
The meta-analysis suggests that strong fear appeals produce high levels of perceived severity and susceptibility, and are more persuasive than low or weak fear appeals, and the results indicate that fear appeals motivate adaptive danger control actions such as message acceptance and maladaptive fear control actionssuch as defensive avoidance or reactance.
Fear Appeals Motivate Acceptance of Action Recommendations: Evidence for a Positive Bias in the Processing of Persuasive Messages
TLDR
Results show that participants who felt vulnerable to the health threat were more persuaded, experienced more negative emotions, and had more favorable cognitive responses, regardless of the quality of the arguments in the recommendation.
The Impact of Vulnerability to and Severity of a Health Risk on Processing and Acceptance of Fear-Arousing Communications: A Meta-Analysis
This meta-analysis of studies of the persuasive impact of fear appeals evaluated the contribution of our stage model of the processing of fear-arousing communications relative to other fear appeal
Perceived efficacy, conscious fear of death and intentions to tan: not all fear appeals are created equal.
TLDR
The findings revealed that messages impacting sun protection efficacy moderated sun protection intentions only when death was conscious, and have implications for understanding the conditions that render certain fear appeals, and accompanying messages of efficacy, more influential than others.
An empirical investigation of the influence of fear appeals on attitudes and behavioral intentions associated with recommended individual computer security actions
Through persuasive communication, IT executives strive to align the actions of end users with the desired security posture of management and of the firm. In many cases, the element of fear is
FEAR AROUSAL AND PERSUASION
This study was designed to re-examine the validity of the defensive avoidance hypothesis in the study of fear-arousing communications.In the present study, three independent variables were used-that
Fear appeals in HIV prevention: The role of anticipated regret
TLDR
The role of a number of cognitive beliefs in explaining the effects of fear appeal information on behavioral motivation was examined, and only anticipated regret qualified as a mediator of the effect of the fear appeal message on intention.
The Effectiveness of Empathy- Versus Fear-Arousing Antismoking PSAs
TLDR
Results from multilevel modeling analyses showed that empathy-arousing messages are potentially more effective than fear-arouse ones, and Implications for persuasion, health communication campaigns, and future research were discussed.
...
...