Anthropology in the Clinic: The Problem of Cultural Competency and How to Fix It

  title={Anthropology in the Clinic: The Problem of Cultural Competency and How to Fix It},
  author={Arthur M Kleinman and Peter L. Benson},
  journal={PLoS Medicine},
Cultural competency has become a fashionable term for clinicians and researchers. Yet no one can defi ne this term precisely enough to operationalize it in clinical training and best practices. It is clear that culture does matter in the clinic. Cultural factors are crucial to diagnosis, treatment, and care. They shape health-related beliefs, behaviours, and values. But the large claims about the value of cultural competence for the art of professional care-giving around the world are simply not… 
Cultural Factors in Ethics Consultations
What is culturally informed psychiatry? Cultural understanding and withdrawal in the clinical encounter
  • A. Leseth
  • Medicine, Psychology
    BJPsych Bulletin
  • 2015
Using ethnographic material from anthropological fieldwork, it is suggested that the encounter with cultural differences could be a useful point of departure for the clinician to develop cultural understanding.
Beyond Cultural Competency: Skill, Reflexivity, and Structure in Successful Tribal Health Care
As notions of cultural competency have risen to prominence in health care, some of our most powerful models and strategies come from successful tribal health care. In this chapter, we deconstruct
Rethinking cultural competence
This issue of Transcultural Psychiatry presents papers from the McGill Advanced study Institute in Cultural Psychiatry on ‘‘Rethinking Cultural Competence from International Perspectives,’’ which was held in Montreal, April 27 and 28, 2010, and shows how conceptual analysis and critique of cultural competence can point toward ways to improve the cultural responsiveness, appropriateness and effectiveness of clinical services, and in doing so contribute to reducing health disparities.
Cultural Competence in Trauma
The construct “Cultural competence”, or some variation thereof, has unfortunately been abused to the point that it really has no clear definition and, indeed, can signify rather contrasting notions
An Analysis of Cultural Competence, Cultural Difference, and Communication Strategies in Medical Care
This dissertation investigates how Anglo-American clinicians and Mexican immigrant patients communicate in a medical setting and examines the popularity of cultural competence as a panacea to health inequalities.
Cultural competence in the era of evidence-based practice.
The relevance of clinical ethnography: reflections on 10 years of a cultural consultation service
A cultural consultation service such as the authors' can contribute to institutional cultural competence by drawing attention to the challenges of caring for diverse patient populations, identifying the training needs of clinicians and gaps in resource provision, and providing hands-on experience with clinical ethnographic interviewing.
“Shattering culture”: perspectives on cultural competence and evidence-based practice in mental health services
It is argued that discussions of culture—patients’ culture and the “culture of medicine”—should be sensitive to the risk of improper stereotypes, but should also besensitive to the continuing significance of group-based discrimination and the myriad ways culture shapes clinical presentation, doctor–patient interactions, the illness experience, and the communication of symptoms.
Revealing the (in)Competency of “Cultural Competency” in Medical Education
There are multiple factors that influence the quality of health and the health care experience of Aboriginal patients and an emerging awareness of the paucity of data showing evidence of positive health outcomes for Aboriginal patients of “culturally competent” medical professionals is revealed.


Confronting “Culture” in Medicine's “Culture of No Culture”
  • Janelle S Taylor
  • Medicine
    Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges
  • 2003
The author presents reflections from medical anthropology on the institutional culture of medicine and medical education, which sees itself as a “culture of no culture” and which systematically tends
American Medicine: The Quest for Competence
Competence provides the framework for discussing the power struggles between rural general practitioners and specialists, organizational changes in medical education, and the clinical narratives of high-technology oncologists.
Patients And Healers In The Context Of Culture
  • A. Kleinman
  • Psychology, Medicine
    The Journal of Asian Studies
  • 1981
This book discusses the construction of Illness Experience and Behavior in Chinese Culture in the context of Health Care Systems, Culture, Health Care systems, and Clinical Reality and its consequences.
The place of culture in DSM-IV.
A step forward has been taken to introduce cultural elements in DSM-IV, but much remains to be done to ensure that future diagnostic systems incorporate a genuinely comprehensive framework, responsive to the complexity of health problems in increasingly multicultural societies.
Mental health: a report of the Surgeon General.
  • M. Gabe
  • Medicine
    Home care provider
  • 2000
The enduring contributions of minorities, like those of all Americans, rest on a foundation of mental health, which is the basis for successful contributions to family, community, and society.
Stigma and global health: developing a research agenda
Cultural competence--marginal or mainstream movement?
Joseph R. Betancourt argues that cultural competence is not a panacea, but a necessary set of skills for physicians who wish to deliver high-quality care to all patients.
The DSM-IV Outline for Cultural Formulation: a critical demonstration with American Indian children.
Clinicians working with children should recognize the strengths as well as the limitations of the Outline and expand their cultural descriptions accordingly and add additions to the text of the outline that will facilitate the development of comprehensive cultural formulations specific to children and adolescents.
The story catches you and you fall down: tragedy, ethnography, and "cultural competence".
Anne Fadiman's The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down: A Hmong Child, Her American Doctors, and the Collision of Two Cultures (Noonday Press, 1997) is widely used in "cultural competence" efforts
Moral experience and ethical reflection: can ethnography reconcile them? A quandary for "the new bioethics.
Past criticism of bioethics on account of its Eurocentric orientation and grudg ingly limited engagement with non-Western and ethnic value orientations is broadened to critique the way ethicists psychologize moral issues that in everyday life are more often expressed by ordinary people via religious, social, and somatic idioms.