Analogy in Archaeological Interpretation

@article{Ascher1961AnalogyIA,
  title={Analogy in Archaeological Interpretation},
  author={R. Ascher},
  journal={Southwestern Journal of Anthropology},
  year={1961},
  volume={17},
  pages={317 - 325}
}
  • R. Ascher
  • Published 1 December 1961
  • Sociology
  • Southwestern Journal of Anthropology
THE WORK of the archaeologist can be divided into four tasks. First there is the formulation and refinement of concepts; second, data gathering and processing; third, the interpretation of the data, and finally, synthesis. The four tasks are obviously related in an hierarchical scheme: concepts enable meaningful synthesis, synthesis depends on interpretation, and interpretation is ultimately founded on archaeological data. Substantial progress has been made in approaches to the first, second… 

Archaeology and roman society: Integrating textual and archaeological data

Although the collection of new data and the development of an enduring interest in theoretical concerns characterize much current work in Roman archaeology, the field continues to experience, tension

Middle-Range Theory in Paleolithic Archaeology: The Past and the Present

Middle-range theory (MRT), as the concept of intermediate theory between observed empirical data and general theories, was first formulated by the sociologist R.K. Merton in the context of the

Archaeological and Other Evidence: A Fresh Look at the “Laurentian Iroquois”

Abstract Prehistorians frequently must depend on archaeological evidence alone in forming judgments. It is evident from prehistoric studies, however, that difficulties are likely to arise when

Thinking Beyond the Tool: Archaeological Computing and the Interpretive Process

The scope of the book aims to build on previous approaches to archaeological method and theory, and place emphasis on the fact that archaeological computing, with its wide range of applications and

Analogy and the Acceptance of Theory in Archaeology

The “new archaeology,” a philosophy of archaeological research based on deductive logic, has both resolved and created problems. It has rightly stressed that the empirical content of a theory

THE USE OF ANALOGY FOR INTERPRETATION OF MAYA PREHISTORY

Many reconstructions of the prehistoric culture of the southern Maya lowlands include extrapolations from ethnographic descriptions. Although we lack data at present for a proper application of the

Problem Orientation in Australian Historical Archaeology

Australian historical archaeologists still have to convince many academics in other disciplines and the public at large that archaeological research concerned with the material record of the last two

Concepts of Time and Approaches to Analogical Reasoning in Historical Perspective

TLDR
The role that concepts of time (e.g., stone age, traditional, modern) have played in selecting relevant analogues is examined and Fabian's critique of how anthropologists have used time to distance contemporary peoples guides this inquiry.

Thinking from Things: Essays in the Philosophy of Archaeology

Alison Wylie, Berkeley: University of California Press, 2002, 357 pages.Reviewer: Erika EvasdottirColumbia UniversityOne of the most enduring--and endearing--consequences of the New Archaeology is
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 13 REFERENCES

The Subjective Element in Archaeological Inference

WILLEY2 has described the two large problem fields of archaeology as the spatial-temporal arrangement of cultural materials and the reconstruction of cultural and ecological contexts. He points out

Archeological Theory and Method: Some Suggestions from the Old World

A second Wenner-Gren Foundation regional supper conference was held at Harvard University on November 6, 1953 (see AMERICAN ANTHROPOLOGIST 55: 353 for an account of the first such regional conference

A Prehistoric Population Estimate Using Midden Analysis and Two Population Models

  • R. Ascher
  • Environmental Science
    Southwestern Journal of Anthropology
  • 1959
FOR THE GREATER PART of human history man gathered and hunted his food rather than producing it. As a food gatherer he stood in a similar elationship to his environment as do other mammalian groups.

The Evolution and Persistence of Ceramic Motifs in Northern Georgia

Stamped or impressed designs on pottery from a group of relatively early sites in northern Georgia provide new data on the origin of several well known motifs of later times, and add to the evidence

The Direct Historical Approach to Archaeology

In recent years considerable attention has been given to theoretical statements and to concrete applications of what is called the “taxonomic method“ in archaeology. Although this method is not

Excavations at Star Carr (Cambridge)

    The Seven Caves ( New York ) . DART , RAYMOND A . 1957 " The Makapansgat Australopithecine Osteodentokeratic Culture " ( in Third Pan - African Congress on Prehistory

    • 1957